Mafia 17 - Harry Potter Game *Mafia Win*

[MIASG]

yeah sorry it all blends a bit after a while  .. it was the LOTR game ... so was yorkie modkilled TCH or no comment

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

no comment

[MIASG]

would seem the strangest choice for mafia or any vig/SK etc to target  ... he still hasn't come on so it's not like he has a role and attacked the godfather and therefore was killed for it.

[Steve Van Halen]

BBM was going to be voted off anyway, I just finished the job off. We knew he was mafia but I gave bluestars theory some thought and suspected that YB was a lazy mafia godfather hence why there were no kills. This obviously wasnt the case now and we made the right move.

So Im being voted for because I cast the final vote?

[hippo]

would seem the strangest choice for mafia or any vig/SK etc to target  ... he still hasn't come on so it's not like he has a role and attacked the godfather and therefore was killed for it.

He was blatanly modkilled. Unless TCH is suggesting that someone's choice of murder weapon is a banana skin left on the stairs.

Does look a bit of a stupid claim from Villain. My assumption would be that he was either just trying to lure out the actual Harry, or trying to make it look like a guaranteed cult, so people would stop looking for his mafia buddies.

I'm also guessing that someone knows who the godfather is, and has them blocked off, ready to claim and reveal whenever we've identified a significant number of the henchmen that it could be passed on to. Either that or some townie hero is correctly guessing every night and protecting the right people, which would seem unlikely. Especially considering we know who the doctor and who he's (selflessly) protecting every night.

BBM was going to be voted off anyway, I just finished the job off. We knew he was mafia but I gave bluestars theory some thought and suspected that YB was a lazy mafia godfather hence why there were no kills. This obviously wasnt the case now and we made the right move.

So Im being voted for because I cast the final vote?

Pretty sure you're being voted because he'd already been lynched for about 6 hours when you added yours. The bit i've bolded in your post looks somewhat dodgy.

Thre reason SVH looks evil is he jumped after it was clear the voting had ended and the thread should have been locked...

In fairness, didn't you do the same thing on the wes lynch? You removing your vote from the lynch of a townie and applying it to a mafia member after everything was over, isn't much different from SVH taking his vote off a townie and adding it to a mafia member after the vote was over, when you think about it, is it?

[Steve Van Halen]

the voting hadnt ended, as far as I could see there were 8 votes for a lynch and he was on 7. If the voting had ended I wouldnt have bothered!

[Steve Van Halen]

I miscounted, I didnt realise he was already on 8 otherwise I would have kept my vote on YB. I thought he was on 7

As far as im concerned the voting hadnt ended because the thread wasnt locked!

[stevenryals]

StevenRyals who is supposed to be good was not in on the lnch was he? me really thinks he could be cult. I dunno. Gonna have to study the previous days posts and try to come up with some new suspects as all mine are now dead(except Ryals). lol

I wish you had aimed this at someone else axeman, becuase it would sound much better coming from me with a rebuttal...  but out of everything you said this is the most suspicious..

You tend to really think these things through, and you've not done it this time.  Here's why...

The reason everyone agreed 100% that there was a cult, was Hammer's claim that he was a anti-cult role.  Now that claim turns out to be crap, so we're back at square one.   you ignore the possibility that there may actually be no cult in this game.  This type of oversight is unusual for the Happy Axeman who plays for the town, becuase he usually digs deep and thinks things out greatly.   you've not done that, and this is the first time in a while I can say that you've slipped.  I believe you are mafia my friend..

Vote Happy Axeman

[stevenryals]

Does look a bit of a stupid claim from Villain. My assumption would be that he was either just trying to lure out the actual Harry, or trying to make it look like a guaranteed cult, so people would stop looking for his mafia buddies.

this is the appearance of someone who thought things through a bit more..  (as an example)
which is why i feel its so strange for axeman not to have noted this same point.. 

[bluestarsneyes]

BBM was going to be voted off anyway, I just finished the job off. We knew he was mafia but I gave bluestars theory some thought and suspected that YB was a lazy mafia godfather hence why there were no kills. This obviously wasnt the case now and we made the right move.

So Im being voted for because I cast the final vote?

You've credited me with this "theory" twice now...it wasn't my "theory" at all..and as a matter of fact I said quite clearly that Yorkshireblue hadn't logged onto the site since Feb 12th and he would be a wasted vote...he literally was the only player we could confirm as worthless. However, you mentioning it as the "bluestars theory"....seems a bit of an effort to deflect.

I'm still try to figure out this person .. but you just voted for him - didn't think it was that hard to figure out .. i'm thinking mason or mafia for SVH myself

I personally think yorkie would have been replaced by now if he was normal townie

Here another post that is what it is.....First Miasg plants a thought that SVH could be Mason or Mafia...um...alrigh t...that's specific...either he's evil or he has this specific towny role...just find that a bit off....

Then Miasg...once again plants another idea that Yorkie is something other than normal townie....well..tha t turned out to be false...

I find the posting of SVH and MIASG to both be very Mafia in nature...planting little bits of ideas, deflection, not to mention the banter of Hammer and SVH early in the game....seems all a bit different looking at it in the light of day.

VOTE SVH

[stevenryals]

Bluestars,,, there were more implications in your post that MIASG is evil than SVH...

I'm still try to figure out this person .. but you just voted for him - didn't think it was that hard to figure out .. i'm thinking mason or mafia for SVH myself

I personally think yorkie would have been replaced by now if he was normal townie

this quote is a good find.. 

this comment makes no sense and seems intended to throw more doubt towards yorkshireblue, who turned out to be town.. 

FOS MIASG     because your logic behind this statement can't be found anywhere..  however, seems you were trying to push people away from the BBM lynch.... this is very sus here miasg...

[bluestarsneyes]

During the night several of you are woken by crashes and the sounds of fighting in the halls of Hogwarts, the Deatheaters are about.

As the morning comes you all head down to the dining hall and are relieved to find that everyone is accounted for, whatever Lord Voldemort and the Deatheaters were up to last night didn't succeed.
......
Day Two starts now

Something has been mentioned as well over and over again that I think is a mafia attempt to cause town to deflect attention away from something.

Just because there have been a lack of mafia kills doesn't mean they haven't tried...read this above....it says there was fighting but it was obviously unsucessful.

[bluestarsneyes]

Another restless night at Hogwarts, magic crackles though the air and several petronis' are seen in the halls.

However come morning you all gather in the dining room and you are delighted to discover that once again everyone has made it through the night and no kills occurred. There are currently 15 players;

Once again...another night where magic is in the air...but it isn't sucessful....that doesn't mean that Mafia isn't putting in night kills...just means they are being blocked, or picking bulletproof townies or someone's protecting the right person.

[MIASG]

in response to bluestars :-
svh - I do think SVH is in a group of some sorts .. I'm hoping to find out which one.   SVH footynewb clearly said the lynch happened and to lock the thread - pretty hard to miss.

yorkie - what I meant was I didn't think yorkie was town - which as it turns out I was wrong.  There may not be a cult but does anyone else think somethings up with having Henchmen and Zealots?   you said he was a wasted vote but that also doesn't mean you thought he was town.  In fact it was the same reason why I went with BBM - I think it was pretty even at the time.  Can't see how that makes me mafia specifically.  

FOS Amadjin - been on the site but not here = not good enough.

in resposne to StevenRyals - I'm very much a big 'ol harmless townie. I've said many times I wasn't 100% convinced about BBM and there seemed to be this massive push without giving him a go after day 1 - I was thinking easy bandwagon and nothings wrong with questioning decisions over's have decided is fact.  I got no hint that anyone knew this for fact.  

[stevenryals]

Another restless night at Hogwarts, magic crackles though the air and several petronis' are seen in the halls.

another example... someone's doing something right..  unless they just keep trying to kill me at night, which is doubtful..

[bluestarsneyes]

Miasg....what makes you feel SVH is in a group?

[bluestarsneyes]

actually Steven I voted for SVH because of is early banter with Hammer...and his and Hammer's lack of accusations towards one another...it all sits a bit weird with me from the get go....I can't vote for both but I feel Miasg is different in this game as well.

Miasg...you seem in every post since the Wesmancity lynch to want to mention Cult...Serial Killers...the fact that you think there is obviously more mafia left...maybe two groups....anything that is to deflect from the fact that you and Wesmancity went at each other quite hard.

[mophead]

I did forget that no one locked the thread and that SVH miscounted.

UNVOTE SVH

As for steve i still think there is a possibility that u r recruted in the cult

VOTE STEVENRYALS

[bluestarsneyes]

***mophead if you are sick and can still play mafia...you are well enough to do schoolwork today...LOVE MOM ON HER WAY HOME IN A BIT!!!!!!!!*********

[mophead]

im in my bed