Author Topic: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings - Town Win  (Read 263124 times)

0 Members and 2 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline MIASG

  • Monster Member
  • *
  • Posts: 3026
  • Karma: 15
  • I don't want the world I just want your half -TMBG
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #500 on: June 12, 2008, 06:59:54 AM »
first of all your wrong .. I'm not a part of a mason group and I have no powers - just a normal townie.  I'd find it strange if I was the only one (although I do die early (hint hint)) as well since I'm part of the 9 of the fellowship of the ring - I can see what some of the other mason groups would be but it would just be wierd if I was the only townie Plus Faramir was a normal townie.  so far we def know --> Strider - doctor.  merry - mason B. mophead - nazgul, gimli - mason C, gollum - SK.

I'm also not sure what sort of a role blocker you are  .. and it appears not gandalf.  Why did you role block yorkshire and then laserblue?  why not me as you have me at the top of your list! I assume if you survive I'll be the one you role block tonight ..  and I can assure you nothing will come of it - of course that will just mean I'm not the godfather and not rule me out of anything for you.

Now you've pretty much said your not gandalf ..  assumptions I've made are - mason group A - Frodo and Samwise, B = merry and pippen, C = Gimli and Legolas.  Now I doubt very much that you are a mason with a roleblocker feature as you have not alluded to it. 

So the 9 are ..
Gandalf
Aragorn(strider)
frodo/sam -A
merry/pippen -B
gmli/legolas -C
Boromir

plus we know we have faramir.  so at least 10 townies.

your not a mason .. that leaves 2 alive fellowship townies with possible powers .. I'm not gandalf.  You said your not gandalf.

Your arguement has a massive hole in it.  who else that's not in the 9 that's not a mason would have an important roleblocker  role ...  quite frankly I'm pissed that I'm the only fellowship member with no mason buddy or another function/role ! 

I unvoted you yet you still applied all the heat on me despite the other votes for you.  I said for now I had to think of you as an important townie .. but I now feel you've dug yourself a little hole. 

If anyone see if there is a hole in my logic? - if so please point it out.

VOTE TRICK PONY
 

Offline Tommy Caton's Hairstylist

  • Moderator
  • Busy Bee
  • *
  • Posts: 2223
  • Karma: 9
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #501 on: June 12, 2008, 07:54:29 AM »
The votes now stand at

Trick Pony 4 votes
LaserBlue  1 Vote
Miasg       1 Vote



6 votes needed to lynch and we have about 2 and a half days to go till the end of Day Three

Afro, Bluestars, Liverbird, Wes and Yorkshire have not yet voted

Offline Sir Villain

  • Monster Member
  • *
  • Posts: 3628
  • Karma: -13
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #502 on: June 12, 2008, 08:53:59 AM »
Unvote:Trick Pony for now, just so I can think over on this claim.

hippo

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #503 on: June 12, 2008, 10:20:47 AM »
If you've claimed all of that, you may as well give us a name surely? That way, people will know conclusively whether or not you're telling the truth. Don't quote the PM obviously, just tell us the name.

yorkshire blue

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #504 on: June 12, 2008, 11:35:42 AM »
this is starting to look really sus with tp but as there are alot of votes on him i will wait to see what he as got to say
cant we get someone else in for liverbird because this is unfair she could be mafia and we wont have a clue

Offline MIASG

  • Monster Member
  • *
  • Posts: 3026
  • Karma: 15
  • I don't want the world I just want your half -TMBG
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #505 on: June 12, 2008, 12:13:15 PM »
anyone agree or disagree with what I said ?  I'm not getting any responses ..

also I don't want another player - still starting from scratch so what the point .. as I've said before we don't need to kill all the mafia to win this game just survive the ring or however it works to the end. 

if liverbird was mafia godfather than they wouldn't have gotten off there kills as I thnk she was away and didn't even log on during that time - I could be wrong for one of the night phases.  doesn't mean she's not mafia though. 

Offline Tommy Caton's Hairstylist

  • Moderator
  • Busy Bee
  • *
  • Posts: 2223
  • Karma: 9
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #506 on: June 12, 2008, 12:30:35 PM »
The votes now stand at

Trick Pony 3 votes
LaserBlue  1 Vote
Miasg       1 Vote


6 votes needed to lynch and we have about 2 and a half days to go till the end of Day Three

Afro, Bluestars, Liverbird, Sir Hammer, Wes and Yorkshire have not yet voted

hippo

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #507 on: June 12, 2008, 12:43:39 PM »
anyone agree or disagree with what I said ?  I'm not getting any responses ..

also I don't want another player - still starting from scratch so what the point .. as I've said before we don't need to kill all the mafia to win this game just survive the ring or however it works to the end. 

if liverbird was mafia godfather than they wouldn't have gotten off there kills as I thnk she was away and didn't even log on during that time - I could be wrong for one of the night phases.  doesn't mean she's not mafia though. 

Well i'd made the same assumptions. It's not difficult to actually work out who a few people are, but i'm not going to point them out obviously.

The mason groups i do believe to have 2 in each, and i believe them to be the characters you've set out. There are obviously people who are ordinary townies, which Trick Pony seemed to go against - like you pointed out, hammerbro was Faramir and simply a townie, so we know that they exist for certain.

And i agree that liver bird isn't the godfather, because of the reasoning you gave. Unless she's been very crafty and been emailing in the decisions or something.

I want to hear what Trick Pony gives as a name, before i make my judgement on the likelihood of his claim being true or not.

Offline bluestarsneyes

  • Sr. Member
  • *
  • Posts: 706
  • Karma: 2
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #508 on: June 12, 2008, 02:58:53 PM »
well lets think about it from my perspective for a change, you fools have just lost the game as I will have to role claim to save myself though you will still probably kill me like the fools from the last game to FBN who couldnt see what was right in front of them  :(

well since im going to die I may as well try help explain what I know from this game, I am the roleblocker and apart from the doctor who was killed in night one and possibly gandolf the rest of us are just masons in I think 3 groups based on the night kills. I have been saying that im a normal townie to save my self as Im sus at the moment because of my post against you fools. My role is to try work out who is who so I can block the most obvious person at that late stage in the game, I have already blocked Yorkshire Blue and Laser Blue in nights one and two, they were my prime suspects because of their posts but because mafia have taken two night kills and from previous games only the godfather provides the kill that leaves SVH, Afro, Liverbird, MIASG, and Bluestars as being sus for mafia as I havent blocked them. I believe Hippo, SH, and wes are townies / masons. 

Their is nothing more to say on this so either you believe me or lynch me and find out the hard way, from my point of view I didnt want to stand out as townie so mafia didnt kill me early in the game, as looking like Im not a threat to them is the best way to survive until this stage in the game. 

And MIASG your the only one who has said your innocent so why should I change my vote off you, your game has changed the most in this game apart from mine and I really cant trust you to change my vote, though I can see your point because you may be a townie instead of evil like the past two games.

Anyway I have stated my reasoning so ill leave it up to you. MIASG still has my vote for now though he has claimed to be innocent.

Lots of problems in what you have posted here for me TP. First off....I'm always supsect when a townie gets to threatening and says things like "you fools have just lost the game". Always makes me suspicious...normal ly a townie that looks to be on the lynch is more begging rather than threatening. It doesn't ring as a townie statement to me and first off the bat just made me really suspicious.

This whole line bothers me.."I am the roleblocker and apart from the doctor who was killed in night one and possibly gandolf the rest of us are just masons in I think 3 groups based on the night kills".
1) like miasg points out he admits he's not gandolf
2) three mason groups...well the b and c gave that away I assume, however why would there only be masons (hobbits), a doctor (aragon), and roleblocker (character???) as the only townies? Many have posted all the possible town roles and seems there possibilities for other roles....not to mention I've not been in a game yet where there was no cop? Seems odd he'd leave those off right? Something is off here.
3) this really bothers me "the rest of us are just masons"....you just said you were the roleblocker...now you say the rest of US are just masons? Which is it roleblocker or mason?
4) Next, TP you state that as role blocker "My role is to try work out who is who so I can block the most obvious person"....okay...well most roleblocker would be INVOLVED in the game right? Where have you been? You want to call others out for not posting....you may have posted but what? NOTHING? You don't even bother to VOTE in this game...well except for one time that I can find
Trick Pony   FOS MIASG   8 (you FOS him early on)
      FOS Footballnewb   8 (well he's turned out to be innocent and well yeah...DEAD)
      VOTE:Stevenryals   11 (Oh here's a vote...and for whom..yep another innocent that is now DEAD)
      FOS MIASG   19 (another miasg)
      VOTE MIASG   23 (Shocker here right...although no evidence against him you offer just simply hey you are picking on me so I'll vote you...good one)
So as a roleblocker you offer us as town only THESE as on your suspicious listing???? Either you are the worst investigator in the history of this game or you are mafia scum!
5) then to top it off....you TELL us who you roleblocked....york shireblue and laserblue....WTF???? That does not make ANY sense....first of all it was really obvious that with all the back and forth either you'd have investigated me, axeman or hippo or miasg. I mean MIASG was even top of YOUR list? So why not investigage him? That makes no sense, you investigate yorkshireblue???? If I was the roleblocker and I saw a player like me or hippo or axeman sussing and asking all the questions back and forth the other day one of THEM would be tops of my list because they were doing my job for me! Instead what reason could you possible suspect yorkshire above anyone else on that list?
6) Your list for godfather is also quite well....unusual to say the least...I have to agree with miasg if liverbird was godfather that would be impossible? How would she be making the kills if she's gone out of town? Not to say i think she couldn't be a mafia person, but godfather that makes no sense. So...let's see you say SVH is godfather here is his voting
SVH      Vote Laserblue   13
      vote hippo   22
      unvote hippo   24 (well he unvoted him, but seems he was suspicious of him and yet if he was godfather and hippo was innocent...why not keep the vote and get a kill on hippo huh?)
      vote laserblue   24
Doesn't look like a godfather player if you ask me.
Miasg   (too many posts to put all his fos's)   
VOTE mophead   18 (turns out was evil and he voted to have him lynched...not godfather like if you ask me?)
      vote trick pony   20 (interesting here )
      vote laserblue   21
      vote trick pony   23
      vote laserblue   21
      vote trick pony   23 (just kind of never looses his opinion of you now does he...hmm...interest ing...not a very hard godfather to pick out who he's wanting to get rid of now...if he's godfather he's quite bad and very obvious...not the move I'd see a player like miasg being...but I could be wrong...who knows..just doesn't seem likely at all to me.)
Bluestars well I've voted twice in this game
VOTE FOOTBALLNEWBY   10 (wrong on that one, but this was on day one, he was not killed til day two)
vote laserblue   20 (voted for him but all the votes turned while I was out of town to mophead....debate still out on laserblue...so I might be wrong or right) Although if you look back on all of my posts I have no problem asking MANY folks in this game questions and fosing just about everyone also. I can tell you I'm not godfather, BUT you putting me on that list of course...along with your assertion yesterday that I've been absent this game make me sure you can't be townie! You didn't even BOTHER to respond to my posts...or even acknowledge that I said I was out of town and posted my quote to prove it.
6) You say that miasg has changed his way of posting JUST LIKE YOU...hhhmm...let's think this through...miasg has always been evil and yet now he's more involved and is saying he's innocent...well...b ased off of your assertions you'd assume he was innocent right? Well instead of removing your vote off of him...you keep it on miasg against your OWN LOGIC? What kind of freaking sense does this make? He even unvoted you prior to this so right there you don't even follow your own logic...but that's happened before right?
7) Where's the response from all of us that question how you can call Wes a mason and then mafia in the same post? As well as laserblue? You don't even follow your own logic? Why BECAUSE YOU ARE LYING!

Sorry....this doesn't fly with me nothing you are saying is adding up to making any sense and instead of staying on here and responding to us townies you give one post and say whatever kill me and it's a big mistake...yeah for mafia cause I think they'll loose their godfather?

Roleblocker....yeah I don't buy that at all....seriously... no name...and no response to Hippo asking you for it...good try but not good enough..got my vote for not making any sense....the only thing we as townies can listen to is FOOTBALLNEWBY...he said you posted pointless mindless dribble and voted to get you out...and oddly enough the day he takes YOU on he ends up DEAD!

The evidence all points out that you are lying and therefore VOTE TRICK PONY




      

Offline Steve Van Halen

  • Bluebird first, rag twat second
  • Busy Bee
  • *
  • Posts: 2139
  • Karma: 6
  • Have some of that Wurzels!!
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #509 on: June 12, 2008, 03:19:12 PM »
unvote laserblue

I dont think anyone is convinced by Trick Pony's role claim so i am saving my vote for the time being
Season 4 World Cup Winners - Sweden

Blooooobirds!!!!!

hippo

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #510 on: June 12, 2008, 03:21:27 PM »
unvote Trick Pony

Don't get me wrong, i haven't changed my opinions, i just don't want a couple of people to come on and finish it off quickly before he gets his chance to tell us his name.

Offline bluestarsneyes

  • Sr. Member
  • *
  • Posts: 706
  • Karma: 2
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #511 on: June 12, 2008, 03:24:30 PM »
Bluestars - 10-90 possible mason probably a Hobbit / gandolf Notice just a few posts ago I was most likely innocent??? Hmmm...what changed...oh yes...me asking him to respond to the fact in this very post he calls some people out as mafia bandwaggoning and innocent...must have not liked me after that huh???
FootballNewb - 50-50 either a mason or mafia godfather, he doesn't say enough to get anything else out of his posts. possibly mason group A? Calls him out as godfather and he wasn't as we know..but he also ends up dead...not looking good
Hammerbro - Dead - Hammerbros body is lost in the rockfall, you morn his loss as he was Faramir and a Townie seemed odd at the time but really odd to me that he'd include all the detail on how our fellow townie met his fate....really weird???
Happy Axeman - 50-50 not sure on axeman, he plays a clever game not giving any character hints in any game, possible serial killer though as he is very through in his though process from the way he is posting.
Hippo - 70-30 mafia to townie though possible serial killer as well. to quiet to tell in regards to trying to investigate players. Now...on this list Hippo is most likely mafia...and yet he didn't roleblock him????? even he HAD him on his suspicions list....and yet now he's 100% townie to him...he's trying to make a friend now isn't he??
LaserBlue - 30-70 mason group B or reg townie at this stage.Interesting coming back to this later
Liverbird - MIA so probably maifa probably to obvious to be the godfather at this stage, though some input would be good ...
Miasg - normal townie possible (mason) - Pippen ? - though he claimed This is NUTS...he calls Miasg a townie here and a mason....what changed his mind...oh yeah...he also questioned him and now TP has changed and got a vote out for him now doesn't he?
MikeBlue - Dead - MikeBlue unfortunately turns out to be Strider/Aragorn and the Doctor
Mophead -  defiantly mafia at this stage though hes irrational at times so he makes it hard to tell.
Sir Hammer - have no idea so 50-50. Ill read over his posts to get a better idea about him.No idea on him here and then yet with no explanation he becomes 100% townie...??
Stevenryals - Dead - Merry was Stevenryals and part of the Mason group B so another townie has been killed and a hobbit as well. Pippen  Am I stupid....didn't he just call Miasg Pippen? So he's saying Miasg was Pippen or the other mason with Steven?
SVH - same as hammer I have no idea so 50-50. Ill read over his posts to get a better idea about him as well.Once again someone goes from almost innocent on his list to godfather??? Without an explanation or...a vote?
Trick Pony - reg townie no powers - yes FBN thats a fact so either believe me or get over it and leave your vote on me, nothings personal your just doing a safety vote in my opinion so you dont provoke any one elses attention, though I still believe your REG TOWNIE NO POWERS....okay I get it you lied...alright...bu t who was it that didn't believe you here??? Footballnewby...and he of course turns out to be killed...nice!
Wesmancity - 10-90 mason group A?
Yorkshire Blue - 50-50 possible mafia / serial killer / reg townie. This is the guy you block...you are 50-50 on him and yet 70-30 on Hippo at this point and you pick him? You don't even have him as top of your own list...hahahaha! and yet even laserblue was by your own account 30-70 to being GOOD???
Also from above the players with townie next to them could also have a special role im just not sure who would have what as no one stands out, though im sure TCH has a roleblocker, investigator, doctor already dead, and possible bullet proof townie though least likely of them all at this stage. This was your list of players and now SOMEONE mysteriously you have narrowed that list to only a roleblocker, doctor, and masons??? You don't even buy your own lies????
Anyway im up the coast again this weekend but I should be on tomorrow morning giving everyone enough time to post a response for me to consider current opinions.


Offline laserblue

  • Veteran
  • *
  • Posts: 1495
  • Karma: 11
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #512 on: June 12, 2008, 04:58:15 PM »
unvote Trick Pony

Don't get me wrong, i haven't changed my opinions, i just don't want a couple of people to come on and finish it off quickly before he gets his chance to tell us his name.

Ok I'll take my vote off him for now until he gives us a name, but I still think he is as guilty as sin... there is too much evidence against & too many conflicting posts by him.

Liverbird

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #513 on: June 12, 2008, 05:48:35 PM »
Hey,

Here on my thoughts on everyone so far:

Afroboy - He hasnt been on as much as everyone for me to get a decent thought on him, I think he is town tho.
Yorkshire Blue - not really sure about him, not convinced whether mafia or town , waiting for him to slip up.
Trick Pony - i think trick pony is evil, the last 2 pages ive read just dont add up to me, and think he is contradicting himself a little...
Laser Blue - i think he could may be mafia because hes been going on at me to post more because he wants to try an get everyone to lynch me because he knows im townie , or then again he could be town and needs me to post more to help the rest of the townies ??  ???
Bluestarneyes - Her posts seem to be making sense ,and shes trying hard to find the evil,so im convinced she is town
Hippo - think hes good because hes puttin alot of pressure on & is trying to work ppl out.
Not convinced on MIASG, SVH, Sir Hammer or

Wesmancity - Hes role claim Mason and noone has disputed it , so i believe him for now

My vote is for TRICK PONY I'm 95% sure he's evil !!!

Im off to Puppy school now and will be back on after work about 5:30pm


Offline laserblue

  • Veteran
  • *
  • Posts: 1495
  • Karma: 11
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #514 on: June 12, 2008, 05:59:19 PM »
Ok I'll take my vote off him for now until he gives us a name, but I still think he is as guilty as sin... there is too much evidence against & too many conflicting posts by him.

sorry forgot to bold it again.... unvote trick pony ...until he tells us his charater's name... though I still think he's evil.

nice one liverbird hope you are going to be hanging around from now on.

Offline wesmancity

  • M.C.F.C
  • Veteran
  • *
  • Posts: 1014
  • Karma: 7
  • MCFC
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #515 on: June 12, 2008, 10:39:09 PM »
Vote Trick Pony

I will be away till sunday now as im moving, so see ya all then.
Axemans plastic moderator. I wear the suit, with fuck all power!

Offline Tommy Caton's Hairstylist

  • Moderator
  • Busy Bee
  • *
  • Posts: 2223
  • Karma: 9
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #516 on: June 12, 2008, 10:59:07 PM »
Well although you've nearly all voted at some point the current state of affairs is


Trick Pony  4 Votes
miasg        1 Vote


Yet to vote, Afro, Hippo, Laser, Hammer, SVH and Yorkshire


Six votes are required to lynch


Offline MIASG

  • Monster Member
  • *
  • Posts: 3026
  • Karma: 15
  • I don't want the world I just want your half -TMBG
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #517 on: June 13, 2008, 02:10:40 AM »
Well although you've nearly all voted at some point the current state of affairs is
:D

Trick Pony

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #518 on: June 13, 2008, 04:27:25 AM »
well for those of you who actually read every post would have already known that I role blocked YorkshireBlue and LaserBlue in nights one and two because I thought they were the godfather as they way they were playing at the time seemed way to sus. So Bluestars "IF" you actually read my posts earlier you would have seem that instead of reading over the past few pages to catch up since you have been away.... which is sus in its self but no one has bothered to challenge.

And I have already said I am a reg townie so I wouldnt get voted off as I have an important townie role which I didnt want to disclose at the time as I didnt think it was necessary.  Though since it was challenged and looks like im getting lynched I didnt see the point in hiding my role anymore as its the last thing that can save me from being lynched because of people not reading everything thats already been said.  I didnt roleblock hippo or sir hammer etc during the night phases as they dont seem to be evil though I was trying to figure out whos mafia by seeing peoples reactions to targeting innocent people, something I picked up from Stevenryals from earlier games. 

So after repeating everything once again, I will highlight this for the skim readers among us, im not sure what I can say in reagards to being mod killed etc but im Galadriel an Elf the roleblocker if you dont know it look it up !

now since you have all just waisted 3 days heading no where how about starting to look for mafia talk about focusing on one player everyone of you are in a TP vs MIASG senario apart from those who waited for a response.

Offline MIASG

  • Monster Member
  • *
  • Posts: 3026
  • Karma: 15
  • I don't want the world I just want your half -TMBG
Re: Mafia 13 Lord of the Rings
« Reply #519 on: June 13, 2008, 05:34:09 AM »
So after repeating everything once again, I will highlight this for the skim readers among us, im not sure what I can say in reagards to being mod killed etc but im Galadriel an Elf the roleblocker if you dont know it look it up !

now since you have all just waisted 3 days heading no where how about starting to look for mafia talk about focusing on one player everyone of you are in a TP vs MIASG senario apart from those who waited for a response.

Galadriel - hmmm - possible - plausable ..

Can you stop insulting people - you posts are the ones condridicting the next one, plus you've only really just copy and pasted your last post so apart from the name your not offering anything new.  We didn't waste 3 days you confused people with lies in posts and that's what taken the focus of the game ...

can you please re-write or explain your last paragraph ?  it makes no sense to me.  Are you saying for everyone to believe you and vote for me?  or to look into who voted for you ? or everyone waiting for a response is ok ?

and if you've had this important role why the FFFF have you not suss'd more people out?  do you get a response from the moderator if your actions are succesfull? or are you told if someone is guilty or not ?

I've pretty much told you who I am ..  I'd be surprised if anyone out there hasn't worked me out .. why are you still voting fo me ?