Mafia 9 - Lost - Abandoned

[SilverTiger]

The plot thickens - think I'm going to sleep on this one, wouldn't want to be too hasty with my first vote....   

[dotLeo]

I've not watched Lost so can't make the connections so to speak, but the possibilty of a paranoid cop is not something we should overlook mind you.  Can't recall their being one in the games I have played.

It does seem convenient SVH, but stranger things have happened.  I would say that investigating two mafia on the trot would be akin to being a paranoid cop and choosing a real mafia first time round, therefore being correct.

I'm not sure you can really question his authenticity a great deal, as the results speak for themselves.  He said Hippo was guilty straight out and sure enough, Hippo was.  Although yorkshire's post don't generally inspire confidence I think the empirical evidence here is good enough. 

Your defence has hardly been any goood, although I understand it is going to be hard to defend yourself against such strong opposition.

Going to hold out on the vote for now, just to see how things develop.

Good to manage to get a post in, on this day!

Warning - while you were typing 4 new replies have been posted. You may wish to review your post.

SVH, I think he investigated you because you questioned his authority yesterday.  It is weak to claim that a cop would do as you have suggested.

[Quig]

I think the most important thing that has happened is the double claim of Locke. Clearly one of them is evil.
It depends on how thick Yorkshire is. Either he is Locke and Axeman is trying to take him down, or he is mafia and stupidly claimed Locke when there would defently an actual Locke.
They could of mastered a little play in that Yorkshire (mafia) reveals cop and snitchs on Hippo who kills himself + random townie, this would clear York for the rest of the game. Also, I don't recall there being a night before the first day whicih is normally when stuff happens.

[MIASG]

there is a few who are trying to say it's either one or the other but my vote stands .. I've decided to UNVOTE SVH on the suspiscion that some mafia are trying to lay blame one way while saying to look at 2 parties .. therefore I reckon Tommy Caton Hairstylist, Axeman, and Yorkshire are all mafia working together ... but who to vote for now ... VOTE Yorkshire[someone may need to protect me tonight  ]

Anyone seen that crazy french woman ?

[*Afroboy*]

Look people why don't we just all go and kill SVH (sorry if you're innocent) and if SVH dus turn out innocent we go kill yorkshire, either way we wil get the mafia man down and, like tommy caton said, it's 2 mafia in the first three days.

[SilverTiger]

Had a crazy thought before I went to sleep last night - what if Yorkshire is Mafia?  He would then know who the other Mafia were.  

He may be offering the others as sacrifical lambs to throw us townies off the scent - a bit like Church did with Laser in the last game.  

I thought I'd wake up today and have a good idea who to vote for - but I'm still not convinced by Yorkshire.

 

[i2i Killer 89]

Vote Count

5 - Steve Van Halen (Yorkshire, Afroboy, Bluestars, Manic, Tommy Caton)
2 - Yorkshire (Steve Van Halen, MiasG)

It will take 8 votes to get a lynch

[MIASG]

Look people why don't we just all go and kill SVH (sorry if you're innocent) and if SVH dus turn out innocent we go kill yorkshire, either way we wil get the mafia man down and, like tommy caton said, it's 2 mafia in the first three days.

true but if SVH is a townie then they might get another in the night phase and thats 3-1

[froganomis]

and so the plot thickens...i completely missed the first day,it all happened so fast...

so whats happened

yorkshire claimed cop,and at the same time claimed hippo guilty?
in retaliation,hippo then blows up ryals,even though yorkshire accused hippo?

this looks rather fishy to me,this is why.

i adopted a tactic in a previous game,i helped get fozza killed then went on to win the game,even though we were on the same side,n it looks suspiciously like thats what yorkshire is doing here....thats not to say he isnt telling the truth,but seeing as svh is halfway to being lynched im not gona help the process,and so il vote for york on the hunch above vote:yorkshire,FOS: SVH how many votes,fos's etc do we have?

but my vote stands .. I've decided to UNVOTE SVH

bit contradictory dont ya think? lol

Had a crazy thought before I went to sleep last night - what if Yorkshire is Mafia?  He would then know who the other Mafia were.  

He may be offering the others as sacrifical lambs to throw us townies off the scent - a bit like Church did with Laser in the last game.  

as i explained its what i did also in the game before the one you mentioned,so its perfectly reasonable for us to think like that

Look people why don't we just all go and kill SVH (sorry if you're innocent) and if SVH dus turn out innocent we go kill yorkshire, either way we wil get the mafia man down and, like tommy caton said, it's 2 mafia in the first three days.

goin in gun-ho has never been a good way to go about things,lets get more people into the game posting there ideas and suspicions before we go crazy n kill everyone eh rambo? lol as newbie said,we could be 3-1 down with your way of things,excuse the newbie thing...been watching far too much scrubs...

[Quig]

SVH, York, Axeman.

Eith SVH and axeman are mafia, or York is. It doesnt matter that much which one we kill. Which ever one we take out then it will clear or damn the others. Since he is almost dead anyway, I say we lynch SVH then if he is guilty Axeman goes down, otherwise its time to kill York. Vote SteveVanHalen

[ManicMonkeyMan]

are you lot being serious, he had tried and tested results against hippo which got ourselves a baddie and day one... now steve van halen is trying to put a defence of himself which is expected, and he has swayed a few of you with his defence.  but how can we even think of lynching yourkshire at this point, if we do and he is a cop, were truly fucked.. so we should lynch svh, if he is innocent.. then we can get yorkshire the next day..

why risk losing a cop, who has so far come up trumps

[MIASG]

  LOL Amadjin - DID YOU REALLY READ MY POST ?? 

try "there is a few who are trying to say it's either one or the other but my vote stands .. I've decided to UNVOTE SVH " it reads much better .. nice try setting me up next though

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

I was beginning to think i didn't care who was lynched but Manic does make good sence as if Yorkshire is lynched and turns out to be a cop then 2 cops are gone, and maybe all of them. SVH has claimed to be a normal townie so but if lynched and a townie then Yorkshire must know he would be next to go.
Still nothing from the Axe.


 

[Sir Villain]

I stopped the bandwagon on eddie for a reason, to get more discussion. What a genius decision that was?

We now have these options that have seemingly appeared

1. Lynch Steve Van Halen,
a) If innocent, Yorkshire is either a paranoid or random cop, or a mafia member trying to fool us
b) If guilty, Yorkshire is a hero and either a lucky cop or a paranoid cop, or still a mafia member trying some mass sacificing plan etc.

2. Lynch YorkshireBlue
a) If innocent, then we have been foolish. If he is John Locke then we lynch Axeman
b) If guilty, then we give Axeman and Steve Van then benefit of the doubt FOR NOW! (never trust anyone for certain in this game)

3. Lynch Axeman
a) If innocent and John Locke, then we must lynch Yorkshire for lying to us about his name
b) If guilty and not John Locke, then he has outed himself for no real reason
C) If guilty and is John Locke, then im very confused


At the moment Im leaning towards the Steve Van Halen option. He has to understand that we can't risk lynching Yorkshire at this point as we have already lost one cop. Lets see what results he brings tomorrow.

[dotLeo]

Nothing has changed in my opinion, so I am happy to make the final vote to lynch him.

Nice try SVH, but I am sure we will be proven to be right and you will come up guilty.

Vote SVH

[billyman]

wow! 3 pages to read

looks pretty darn obvious to me that yorkshire is telling the truth and had a pre-game investigation, so in that case VOTE : SVH

I am a little confused as to why axeman has also roll claimed, even if he is john locke then it seems a bit of a dangerous thing to do as he is offering himself up to the "others" as locke is a busybody and would need to be taken out first.

so after this lynch if yorkshire is indeed telling the truth then axeman needs to be lynched next

[i2i Killer 89]

Final Vote Count for the day

8 - Steve Van Halen (Yorkshire, Afroboy, Bluestars, Manic, Tommy Caton, Quigmaster, Dotleo, Billyman)
3 - Yorkshire (Steve Van Halen, MiasG, Amadjin)

Suddenly a polar bear sprints out of the trees, grabs Steve Van Halen and rips all of his limbs off.
Quickly everyone realises that they need to find out if he was one of the "Others" and so they frantically ask Steve Van Halen if he really was innocent.
He coughs up lots of blood before saying "I am inno...." and then dies.
Someone decides to search what's left of the body and finds a driving licence with a photo of him. Steve Van Halen's real name was Benjamin Linus.
Someone decides to check the flight manifest and it turns out that Benjamin Linus was not on the flight and was therefore one of the "Others"!

Somebody then asks why they didn't just check everyone's name on the flight manifest before and suddenly the manifest disappears.
Currieman comes out of the trees and says: "I will give you back the manifest at the end of each day to check if the lynched person was on the plane.
I'm doing this because I'm mad and want to make this fun to see whether you survivors can triumph


Players still alive
Afroboy
Billyman
Happy Axeman
Silvertiger
Manic
Sir Hammer
Quigmaster
YorkshireBlue
LaserBlue
MiasG
Amadjin
Bluestars
Tommy Caton
Dotleo

Dead players
Hippo: Tom AKA Fake beard man - Mafia Terrorist - Blown up on day one
StevenRyals: Sun Kwon - Townie Mason - Blown up on day one
Fozza: Ana-Lucia Cortez ? Townie Cop ? Stabbed through head on night 1
Steve Van Halen: Benjamin Linus ? Mafia Godfather ? Lynched and eaten by polar bear on Day 2

It is now Night 2. The deadline for night choices and communication is Sunday at 3pm

[i2i Killer 89]

A cuckoo type noise wakes everyone up and, as is the routine now, everyone gathers in a circle in the centre of the camp.
They quickly realise that someone is missing and, after figuring out that it's Happy Axeman, they run to his tent where his body is lying with a hole through it's head much like Fozza's body from earlier.

Currieman appears with the flight manifest and hands it to someone. Somebody finds Axeman's wallet and it turns out that Axeman's real name was Michael Dawson who was on the manifest!

It looked as if another townie had been killed so they search the body to find out what he was but they find a phone with messages from Benjamin Linus and "Tom" saying stuff like "Who should we kill tonight".

It looks as if Axeman somehow became one of the "Others" while he was on the island so everyone gets a bit happier knowing that 3 of the "Others" are now dead.

Players still alive
Afroboy
Billyman
Silvertiger
Manic
Sir Hammer
Quigmaster
YorkshireBlue
LaserBlue
MiasG
Amadjin
Bluestars
Tommy Caton
Dotleo


Dead players
Hippo: Tom AKA Fake beard man - Mafia Terrorist - Blown up on day one
StevenRyals: Sun Kwon - Townie Mason - Blown up on day one
Fozza: Ana-Lucia Cortez ? Townie Cop ? Stabbed through head on night 1
Steve Van Halen: Benjamin Linus ? Mafia Godfather ? Lynched and eaten by polar bear on Day 2
Happy Axeman: Michael Dawson ? Townie turned mafia henchman ? Stabbed through head on Night 2

It is now Day 3. It will take 7 votes to get a lynch

[*Afroboy*]

Ok this is very confusing now, yorkshires obviously a cop and it looks to me like there is some townie that can kill but how cum they didnt kill last night if this is the case?? does anyone have a reasonable explanation as to why mafia didnt strike agen? this has me totaly confused.

[SilverTiger]

   Well we have triumphed yet again - three mafia and only one townie down, a great result.  Still not totally convinced by Yorkshire but he has produced the goods yet again.

Didn't trust Axeman and I definitely would have voted for him next but don't understand how/why Axeman swapped sides 

It's a little worrying that townies can suddenly become Mafia - could make the job of killing them all a lot more difficult.

Townie today - Mafia tomorrow??