Mafia 9 - Lost - Abandoned

[SilverTiger]

Hello

This is my first post and as a "Community Mafia Virgin" I've found all of the posts and what has happened so far rather intriguing....

Why is Yorkshire not dead??  You would have thought that having outed himself as a "cop" that the Mafia would have had him last night  

Two options:-

either he is telling the truth and is really a cop and was protected during the night or

he offered up Hippo as a sacrificial lamb - a bit like Church did with laser in the porevious game to fool the townies....

I'm not sure - the only thing we can do is vote for Steven Ryals and call his bluff.

[SilverTiger]

Sorry - Xmas shopping sending me mad!!  Didn't mean Steven Ryals - I do realise that he is dead, I meant SVH

[Sir Villain]

just a few points to mull over

1.why didnt hippo kill the person that shopped him and revealed a quality (cop) role ? why didnt the other kill him last night
2.yorkshire just claimed that he is John Locke, then Axeman said he was John Locke. = one liar?
3. Hes not actually told us his role, just vaguely came on twice and said someone was evil?
4.John Locke is easily conned in the series and tricked many times, he also has a weird fasination with the island and the others. both lead me to believe that he could easily be an insane (gets random results) cop or paranoid (always gets guilty results) anyway?
5.loads of people have not posted yet so lets here from them
6.isnt it quite lucky he got 2 guiltys with his first investigations?
___

In response to Tigger who just posted before me...

yeah spot on apart from lets wait for Yorkshire and Axeman to determine which one is the real Locke.


Could some of you just unvote Steve Van Halen for now just so he has some breathing room?

[yorkshire blue]

my roles just cop and my game name is john locke
so if i werent a cop how come i got a pregame investigation

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

well if you do vote for SVH Silver Tiger your vote will be the 8th and cause the execution.


I can see the conflict with Yorkshire and the Axe's claims but for me if Yorkshire's is right then good we've got a mafia but if he's wrong then he's toast.

Personally i don't think John Locke would be a cop, but that's only based on his character in the show, a mason maybe but not a cop. i would have thought someone like Sayid would be more likely to be a cop and of course AnnaLucia but as she's already passed on it's a mute point.

[Steve Van Halen]

To me its likely that yorkshire got lucky guessing that hippo was mafia. He claimed to know he was evil right from the start as he was allowed an investigation beforehand? And he just so happened to get the right guy.

Then he gets lucky twice? Since Im not evil this is not the case

hmmmm

Now he claims to be John Locke which Happy Axeman also claims to be. I think I was right not to believe Yorkshire and he is indeed evil as a cop has already been taken out. I did say in the previous day that he might be a psycho and he says im evil the next? Now that has to be suspicous

[laserblue]

I don't know whats going on anymore

OK I'll unvote svh for now........ but I don't know if i'm doing the right thing

  

[Steve Van Halen]

In fact I dont think he was guessing that hippo was mafia! He was just trying to get an innocent lynched but luckily for the rest of us (but not so lucky today  ) he managed to get a mafia member.

I dont think he was allowed a pregame investigation, he made that up after his mistake on day 1 when he just came out and stated hippo was evil and claimed he was the cop.

Its all a bit too dodgy for my liking.

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

Well Axeman over to you, Yorkshire has said what his role is as Locke, what do you have to say in reply ??

 

[Sir Villain]

Im ruling out Yorkshire telling the truth I just want everyone to chip in with their thoughts, and im waiting on Axeman to be abit less vague with his Locke claim. Why should we believe him over someone who has seemingly handed up one mafia already?

In my mind its between Eddie, Ripper and Bossman for todays lynch as one of them is lying......but who?

Going to FOS all three anyway


FOS: Steve Van Halen, Yorkshire Blue and Happy Axeman

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

i agree Hammer that those 3 are the main suspects, Yorkshire's correct call/investigation/guess on Hippo is so far what puts him ahead for me and hence my vote for SVH. Until the Axe comes with some more info to sway me unfortunately for SVH my vote will stand.


 

[*Afroboy*]

I say we go with yorkshire for now, if it's true that SVH is evil he will of proved his point, if SVH is innocent, we kill yorkshire! Problem solved and if we do have to kill yorkshire then we will find out his name as well.

[SilverTiger]

I'm still not sure about Yorkshire - you would have thought that the chances of picking someone who was Mafia at random for his first investigation would be very, very small.  

Is he really a cop?? And if he is why would he out himself on Day 1.....

I suppose if we give him enough rope and go along with it he should hang himself.  

But what if he is kosher?? Can we really afford not to believe him and spare SVH......

[i2i Killer 89]

Vote Count

6 - Steve Van Halen (Yorkshire, Afroboy, Bluestars, Manic, Tommy Caton, MiasG)
1 - Yorkshire (Steve Van Halen)

It will take 8 votes to get a lynch

[yorkshire blue]

I say we go with yorkshire for now, if it's true that SVH is evil he will of proved his point, if SVH is innocent, we kill yorkshire! Problem solved and if we do have to kill yorkshire then we will find out his name as well.

y me r u evil and want the cop killed y not svh seen as i investigated him and he was evil
then if hes innocent il be the next

[Steve Van Halen]

Grrrr, can you not see that Yorkshires claims are far too convienient? Correctly guessing two evil members in succession is too coincidental especially as he has this one wrong!

I think that he got lucky with hippo and is now relying on being protected by the doctor at night otherwise surely the mafia would have gone for him last night? Instead they go for a random.

I understand I would be under suspicion after yorkshires claim but only a select few have questioned his authenticity which i think is dodgyl to to say the least.

[*Afroboy*]

What i meant when i said i say we go with yorkshire is that i believe you and the we should kill SVH you've got it completely wrong, try reading it again.

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

I say we go with yorkshire for now, if it's true that SVH is evil he will of proved his point, if SVH is innocent, we kill yorkshire! Problem solved and if we do have to kill yorkshire then we will find out his name as well.

I agree Afroboy, either way the odds are strong that one or the other are mafia so if your innocent SVH sorry but my vote stands as for the greater good of the game executing you will determine if Yorkshire is telling the truth. If he's wrong then he dies next and either way we have got rid of 2 baddies in 3 days which is a good start.

 

[Steve Van Halen]

I think yorkshires last post says it all. When someone questions him he answers with a question and tries to deflect some suspiscion on to him. Thats mafia behaviour if ever I saw it.

Yorkshire I do not believe that you investigated me. I believe you have accused me because I questioned your authenticity yesterday. You claim to be the john locke character but your bluff was called as Happy Axeman claims to be John Locke also.

Why would Axeman do that? Tommorow he would be the one under scrutiny for doing so and also if Yorkshire were to die his role would be revealed leaving axeman out in the open as a liar. Axeman is too clever a player to do that.

Yorkshire is the man you want. With this I bid you all good night, I hope you come to the right decision

[yorkshire blue]

sorry afro its late i read it again properly