Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD

[billyman]

How on earth do you figure that Blue and I are working together
 

aha! correct was i?

[yorkshire blue]

im goin to vote billyman cos he wants me killed and hes making stuff up like me teaming up with raygin and he always states how innocent he is he says i dont post enough he posts too much protesting his innocence

vote billyman

[sweeney]

aha! correct was i?

Lol

Its says figure, not figure out

[billyman]

im goin to vote billyman cos he wants me killed and hes making stuff up like me teaming up with raygin and he always states how innocent he is he says i dont post enough he posts too much protesting his innocence

vote billyman

BUT YOU DONT POST ENOUGH

[stevenryals]

OK ok... looks like we have 3 directions:

Pointing the finger
Redirecting the finger
and returning the finger to the original

Billy votes for yorkshire
dotleo points at raygun
Raygun FOS's Billyman AND dotleo (the 2 that just pointed at yorkshire and raygun)
Yorkshire votes for Billyman
Raygun vows to vote for either Billyman or Dotleo
I think we have a little bit of teamwork on the part of Raygun and Yorkshire.

Dotleo makes some decent points about Raygun, but not great points... enough to get an FOS RaygunBull

Hippo has totally slipped under my radar, so, since I've never even really looked at him thus far, I'll go back and read through to see what I can find on him, I actually forgot he was playing...


(oh.. may be a good idea to remove the bold characters from your quotes.. happy may get confused.. and we don't want a confused axeman.)


-Steven

[Happy Axeman]

the computer screen refreshes

Story so far...
GAME UPDATE
the Story so far:
Deaths:
Fozza - Shadow Master: Neutral
ManicMonkeyMan:  GOOD Malitia Captain
Der Hammer: Explosives Expert: GOOD
EvilWeasel: revealed Day5!
Amadjin: Revealed Day5!
Churchy: Revealed Day5!

there has been 10 investigation attempts.
there has been 3 people protected.
there has been 4 recruit attempts.
there has been 2 day actions.
someone had made something.
2 people were healed.
there has been 6 kill attempts.

DAY 4
There are 6 alive.
It will require a maximum of 4 votes to make someone enter the door...
Otherwise the Majority goes through...
Or Something Else happens...

People with votes against there name:
Raygin Bull x1(Dotleo)
YorkshireBlue x1(Billyman)
Billyman x1(YorkshireBlue)

Prime suspects(FOS):
StevenRyals x1(Dotleo)
Billyman x1(Dotleo, Raygin)
Hippo x1(Dotleo)
RayginBull x2(billyman, StevenRyals)
YorkshireBlue x1(Hippo)
Dotleo x1(Raygin)

People Who Have voted:
Dotleo, Billyman, YorkshireBlue
People not voting:
StevenRyals, Hippo, Raygin Bull

People Who Have Used All FOS's:
Dotleo

please enter your action>

[dotLeo]

:SNIPE: hahah 

love the comments!  yorkshire, I think you were too quick to vote in retaliation there - time will tell though.

[billyman]

steve ray and hippo, cmon lads get yer votes/actions in

[Happy Axeman]

All of a sudden Billyman Falls over like Ronaldo does, unfortunately it looks like he has actually been shot and is not play acting!
Billy lies there motionless with blood seeping from the bullet wound in his head.... its safe to say he lies there dead!


THANKYOU FOR YOUR DEPOSIT....

IT IS NOW NIGHT, THE DAY WILL RESTART WHEN ALL NIGHT ACTIONS ARE IN AND HAVE BEEN ACTIONED....

[Happy Axeman]

the night passes, and as you all gather around, there is no-one missing!

IT IS NOW DAY 5, AND THE END IS GETTING CLOSER, THERE WAS 12, NOW THERE IS 5. WILL GOOD PREVAIL, OR WILL EVIL WIN?

HAVE A NICE DAY...

the computer screen refreshes

GAME UPDATE
the Story so far:
Deaths:
Fozza - Shadow Master: Neutral (vote death)
ManicMonkeyMan:  GOOD Malitia Captain
Der Hammer: Explosives Expert: GOOD
EvilWeasel: Psycho: EVIL (vote death)
Amadjin: EVIL Righthand Man
Churchy: GOOD Leader
Billyman: Revealed Day6! (day kill)

there has been 12 investigation attempts.
there has been 3 people protected.
there has been 4 recruit attempts.
there has been 3 day actions.
there has been 1 block attempt
someone had made something.
2 people were healed.
there has been 7 kill attempts.

DAY 5
There are 5 alive.
It will require a maximum of 4 votes to make someone enter the door...
Otherwise the Majority goes through...
Or Something Else happens...

People with votes against there name:

Prime suspects(FOS):
Dotleo x2(Hippo, StevenRyals)

People Who Have voted:

People not voting:
StevenRyals, Hippo, Raygin Bull, YorkshireBlue, Dotleo

People Who Have Used All FOS's:

please enter your action>

[stevenryals]

I dont know what to do now, It's down to the 4 people that I'm not sure about.

Billyman was an innocent I'm sure, so we've lost another.

Looks like with 5 left, and needing a max of 4 votes, FOS votes will mean quite a bit, so don't just be throwing them around like they don't matter, because they really matter this time around.

-Steven

[hippo]

Right, people seem to not want us to get through a whole day. There's only been two full days of voting hasn't there? Nobody died at night either?

Amadjin and Weasel were both evil so that was pretty good, by my reckoning now there can only be 2 of them left at most? And probably one? And from some things said yesterday, i think i now have a fair idea as to who they might be.

This is how I see it.  I think one of Church and Amadjin were good/neutral and bad.  Churchy more likely the latter. 

Add to that, accusing Evil Weasel after the attack on Steve (see later) and I'm sure Evil was good.

These go a long way to proving that dotleo is evil. It certainly proves that he isn't good, what with accusing the good leader of being evil.

fos dotleo

i don't consider this to be an fos being thrown around, it has a valid reason.

[hippo]

i don't know what happened there, the sentences after the second quote, "Add to that, accusing Evil Weasel after the attack on Steve (see later) and I'm sure Evil was good.", are not a quote from dotleo, but my words.

Just to make sure axeman doesn't miss it because of it being tucked away in the quote.

fos dotleo

[stevenryals]

agreed, that is incriminating...

Also, notice that upon Church and Monkey's death, I said they were both Good guys, and I was right
Also note, I knew EvilWeasel and Amadjin to be evil.

Billy is also a good guy.


So we have 4 good, 2 evil and 1 neutral dead:

Leaving 5 of us.

I assume, since there haven't been any other recruitments since night 1, we are looking at
2 mafia, 1 good, and 2 neutral
Thats 40% chance to lynch mafia just on a guess.
With a little work and smarts I figure we can up that to a 65-70% chance to get an Evil guy....



Here is my first points of the day...

Yorkshire voted Billyman Then billyman died???
RayginBull was going back and forth just before Billy died.. the last thing billy did was to accuse Raygin of being Evil

any thoughts?


-Steven

[yorkshire blue]

if u r accusing me of been evil because i am not billyman was always trying to prove he was innocent and said it all the time plus he was wanting me killed and wanted more people to vote me out so there was only really goin to be one person that i would vote for

[stevenryals]

Now is not the time to say 'im innocent', now is the time to point out things that may help us find the ones who are guilty.

Yorkshire hasnt done much of that for the whole game, I guess i shouldn't expect any help from him.  Maybe because he is mafia, maybe because this is his first game...  I dont now??

-steven

[hippo]

Yeah, i picked up on those points about those two, and that billyman had just put yorkshire and raygin together in a post of his. Dotleo also tried to discredit billy's list of who's evil and who isn't as well yesterday. And when you look at it, you can see why..

steve 60% evil
hippo 40% evil
amadjin 100% evil (steven posted you came back guilty)
church 40% evil
dotleo 70% evil
yorkshire blue 70% evil
evil weasel 100% evil (gut feeling from the start)
raygyn 40% evil
billyman 100% nice fella

players in red = good
players in bold = evil
players in blue = neutral
you could split the remaing players into 2 teams the way i see it with a couple of players neutral

Billy gave 2 people 100%, and they were evil. And 2 people 70%, and those 2 (yorkshire blue, and dotleo) are still alive and under suspicion. The fact that dotleo said:

anyone under 50% is mafia, and anyone over 50% is neutral or good.  

Therefore Billy knows who his fellow mafia are, leaving only myself and yorkshire good and in an unfortunate position of being fated to die very soon as I see it

This does not do anything to prove his innocence, or prove that there isn't a link between them. Why would you proclaim that you and someone completely unconnected are good. I say unrelated, because, from the numbers, it's very unlikely that there is another 2 good people.

Interesting stuff.

[stevenryals]

Good point on Dotleo, Hippo... 

Hippo, if you are evil, you are playing a very good game... 


FOS Dotleo

-Steven

[hippo]

As pointless as it is..

I'm not evil. But that means nothing to any of you, unless you've investigated me and know it to be the truth.

[dotLeo]

Good point(s) hippo, I'd be inclined to agree with you if I didn't know what I do - that I'm actually neutral.  I made a few dodgy calls, but wanted to get things moving.  I'm still convinced however that Raygin is 100% evil.  Not so sure about Billyman being evil any more though..