Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD

[stevenryals]

I think your ASSAULT is what did you in...  still no excuse for that, and not much defense...

However, I have a guilty verdict on Amadjin, so i'll be going for him next.

-Steven

[Happy Axeman]

OK WEASEL, ITS TIME FOR YOU TO ENTER THE DOOR...

Evil Weasel starts to confidently enter the door...

AHH, I SEE YOU HAVE COURAGE.

Evil Weasel takes one look back at everyone watching, then turns and continues to enter the door, the door then closes behind them quickly.

UNFORTUNATLEY THAT WAS THE WRONG CHOICE TODAY.
you hear screams coming from behind the doors for a second or 2, then there is nothing.
the doors open suddenly, and Something is thrown out, it appears to be Weasels head, gargling in its own blood, "oh Fuck" it says, then the eyes close for one last time...

THANK YOU FOR YOUR DEPOSIT, IT IS NOW NIGHT.
DAY WILL RESTART ONCE ALL NIGHT ACTIONS HAVE BEEN ISSUED.

HAVE A NICE NIGHT...

[Happy Axeman]

so as night 3 comes to a close, you all look at each other, StevenRyals seems fine, and appears to of almost recovered from his attack by Weasel, but Amadjin isnt moving... He's Dead, it appears someone put a pillow over his face and watched his life force eb away...

Wheres Churchy? you go off to look, only to find him lying face down with an axe protruding from the back of his head... he is dead!

WELCOME TO DAY 4 OF THE EXPERIMENT.
THERE ARE 6 OF YOU ALIVE, YOU WILL NEED 4 VOTES MAXIMUM FOR THE PERSON TO ENTER THE DOOR...

HAVE A NICE DAY.

the computer screen refreshes

Story so far...
GAME UPDATE
the Story so far:
Deaths:
Fozza - Shadow Master: Neutral
ManicMonkeyMan:  GOOD Malitia Captain
Der Hammer: Explosives Expert: GOOD
EvilWeasel: revealed Day5!
Amadjin: Revealed Day5!
Churchy: Revealed Day5!

there has been 10 investigation attempts.
there has been 3 people protected.
there has been 4 recruit attempts.
there has been 2 day actions.
someone had made something.
2 people were healed.
there has been 6 kill attempts.

DAY 4
There are 6 alive.
It will require a maximum of 4 votes to make someone enter the door...
Otherwise the Majority goes through...
Or Something Else happens...

People with votes against there name:
Raygin Bull x1(Dotleo)
YorkshireBlue x1(Billyman)
Prime suspects(FOS):
StevenRyals x1(Dotleo)
Billyman x1(Dotleo, Raygin)
Hippo x1(Dotleo)
RayginBull x1(billyman)
YorkshireBlue x1(Hippo)
Dotleo x1(Raygin)

People Who Have voted:
Dotleo, Billyman,
People not voting:
StevenRyals, Hippo, Raygin Bull, YorkshireBlue

People Who Have Used All FOS's:
Dotleo

please enter your action>

[stevenryals]

So.. Evil & amadjin gone.. that's good...

too bad churchy took the axe.. he was innocent im sure..

hmm... there was only 1 investigation, and no more recruit attempts??

I guess.. we are down to these #'s..

Good 1-2
Bad 1-2
Neutral 2-4

hmm... so that's going to make it difficult to chose someone, seeing as we have a 30-60% chance of lynching a neutral character..


I'm keeping my eye on Dotleo, and Yorkshire....
actually at this point I'm looking at everyone..

-Steven

[hippo]

Right, i'm not sure what to make of it all now. As a gut instinct - from the list of Dotleo, StevenRyals, Raygin Bull, Billyman, and YorkshireBlue - i'd say i suspect yorkshire blue the most out of this group. But this could well be just because it's his first game and he's playing oddly.

Dotleo would then be rated as second, i did think he was innocent as a result of trying to make fozza give us information after his death, and manic stopping him. But now we know manic and fozza were good, maybe this was him trying to gain information for the evil cause? I dunno.

After that, billyman, steven, and raygin, i wouldn't rule out, but they seem less likely to be evil.

[stevenryals]

Just a note, Dotleo visited the board a few minutes ago to check last nights results. 

He left without a post.

Just info for everyone.

Here was his comment last time I called him out for lurking....

steve yeah, gotta admit i was coming back every now and then 'today' but to be fair there wasn't reallyt much more to comment on -

However, now there is plenty to comment on... but still no comment...

-Steven

[dotLeo]

Thanks Dad, every time I visit I don't always have the time to post a lengthy reply.  I'm sure you can appreciate that.  Going out on a limb here but I would say I'm possibly the third or fourth biggest contributor so far

I've got a bit to say but can't be bothered to do the research/reading back right now.  I'll post later tonight..

[dotLeo]

Raygin is reading the thread: hope you are going to post mate!!!!!

[sweeney]

Lol.

Have just been sitting in it an I forgot all about it

Just out of curiosity, has anyone posted if they have investigated Ryals?

[Sir Villain]

Im reading the thread as well!

Should I post or not?

Shit, I already have!!!!!!!

I have it with these motherfucking posts in this motherfucking thread

[dotLeo]

This is how I see it.  I think one of Church and Amadjin were good/neutral and bad.  Churchy more likely the latter.

Raygin Bull is almost certainly evil.  Very few posts with very little information (you guys love that for certain mafia).  The following vote is about the worst reason I have come across for a vote.  If that's not mafia-esqe I don't know what is. 

I don't really have much to say about it so far.

I've FOS'd Weasel, and not much has really changed to make me FOS someone else, so I may as well turn it into Vote Evil Weasel

Still feels a little like day 1 when too much guess work is going on

Add that to the very quick lynching/bandwaggoning of fozza on the first day, and you can't fail to see an evil person right there.  Add to that, accusing Evil Weasel after the attack on Steve (see later) and I'm sure Evil was good. 

From what Fozza wrote, I reckon you can only assume that he was evil.

Also, there were 4 investigations on the first night, and 3 the following day after 1 person was "killed", which also lends itself to the theory that Fozza was evil and couldn't do his night action

Incriminating. 

*Yes, I do realise that I am sorta bandwagoning but I stated a few pages back that Fozza and Dotleo were very suspicious

You knew by investigations that we were not mafia already

Enough on Raygin.  I could go on... Vote Raygin Bull.

Ryals is very quick to chuck around accusations - although seems to have missed Raygin out completely - not convinced you know whats going on steve otherwise you would know I wasn't evil, and wouldn't be on my case all the time.  Think you have me lined up as the victim for the next night?  Correct? :p If I were you, I would say that I was just being paranoid!   

The fact that you missed Raygin out suggest very strongly that you are in cohorts with him.  So FOS SteveRyals.

Which leaves Hippo, Billyman, YorkshireBlue.  I had been inclined to think that hippo was innocent until his last post.  He's a clever guy, and to not have picked up on the above would surprise me if he was innocent.  Could be wrong though tbh.

YorkshireBlue: Hard to make a call on this due to so few posts.  I'm going to say innocent due to the following point...

Billyman...

although i doubt you are evil hippo.

steve 60% evil
hippo 40% evil
amadjin 100% evil (steven posted you came back guilty)
church 40% evil
dotleo 70% evil
yorkshire blue 70% evil
evil weasel 100% evil (gut feeling from the start)
raygyn 40% evil
billyman 100% nice fella

anyone under 50% is mafia, and anyone over 50% is neutral or good. 

Therefore Billy knows who his fellow mafia are, leaving only myself and yorkshire good and in an unfortunate position of being fated to die very soon as I see it

Will leave my third FOS for billyman.  FOS Billyman.

Maybe I am all wrong

[dotLeo]

Reading back over that I'm not 100% sure, but as sure as I can reasonably be.  Also I made a mistake!!!

Forgot to FOS someone else for my third.  FOS Hippo.

[billyman]

im going to

vote:yorkshireblue

he may be good he may be evil i dont know and i dont really care, what i do care about is the fact that he aint bothering to play so why keep him in, cmon lads he could end up winning with contributing about 2 posts, thats highly unfair compared to the ones that have bothered there asses.



FOS RAYGYNBULL your posts are not helpfull in achieving anything which leads me to think you are a evil naughty little man

[hippo]

I had been inclined to think that hippo was innocent until his last post.  He's a clever guy, and to not have picked up on the above would surprise me if he was innocent.  Could be wrong though tbh.

It wasn't one of my more researched posts to be fair. I couldn't actually remember anything at all that raygin had said, which, you're right, can be taken as being suspicious.

Another quick point, billyman just voted for someone that he openly doesnt have a clue about, and then fos'd someone because he thinks they're evil. Bit random.

Won't be here for the rest of the day (as in today, not the game day). So i may as well fos my prime suspect at this stage. fos yorkshire blue, because he seems to be playing a bit on this whole 'first game' thing, after someone said that he was just appearing suspicious and not posting much because of that. Seems to have slipped off all lists of suspicion since then for some reason.

I'm not voting just yet though, i'd like to hear him speak, and a bit more from a few others before that.

[billyman]

do you want someone who has had no input into the game whatsoever to win, i dont, it makes a mockery of the game tbh

[yorkshire blue]

theres not only me whos not posting and im not posting cos this is my first post and im just gettin used to it cos i could just post crap and say ive posted and u would just be gettin rid of somebody innocent

[sweeney]

FOS RAYGYNBULL your posts are not helpfull in achieving anything which leads me to think you are a evil naughty little man

Such short memories and Dotleo's have been massive eh

I was a large contirbutor in the first few game days after I had finished my night shifts, and being that the people that have either gone thru the door or have been killed off by Dotleo and Billy, some of the people that have been left haven't been big on posting loads, ergo, not much to reply to

Reading back through his posts, this does seem a real possibility but there is the possibility that it is a bluff and he is looking for a scapegoat too.  All things considered I am inclined to think Billy is evil.

Changed your mind have you? Been recruited by the Evil Billyman?

In over 50% of Billys posts he is proclaiming his innocence. Anyone that does it that much is trying to hard to convince people.

I'm going to vote billyman as I think he was trying to hard to justify his innocence.   

My reasons exactly.

FOS Bilyman

Since day 1, you can go back and check if you like, I have suspected Dotleo. Quite quiet in the te first few "days" and has now become a lot more active. Getting to the end of the game, and the evil guys can start to team up on people

FOS Dotleo

I will turn one of those into a vote, but cannot decide who has recruited who.

*waits for Billy to protest his innocence for the umteenth time

[Sir Villain]

 

Perhaps the lady doth protest too much?

[billyman]

umpteenth plus 1

i am innocent, not recruited, still a loner, no      body      loves me      anymorrrreee!

the only times i have stated i am innocent have been after someone has posted "i think billyman is evil"  

the way that raygyn has jumped in deflecting or trying to deflect the attention of me pointing the finger at yorkie can only suggest to me that raygyn and yorkshire are working together now if they are evil or good i dont know but im defo putting the pair of you together

raygyn        ]
                  ]team A
yorkshire     ]

possibly with dotleo or hippo also.

steven powerfull loner(serial killer maybe)

hammer yer dead pal go forth and rot will yer

billyman = loner, good guy, very good looking, also modest to boot

[sweeney]

Not deflecting any blame sir, the votes have been casted and verified.

Just coming out with who are my main suspects.

How on earth do you figure that Blue and I are working together
 
The words straws and clutching spring to mind