Author Topic: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD  (Read 148187 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

yorkshire blue

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #120 on: August 14, 2006, 01:55:44 PM »
thats co i am :tease2: :hammer:
you are proving how innocent u r again

Offline stevenryals

  • A true blue from across the pond
  • I am the Law
  • Community Star
  • *
  • Posts: 11142
  • Karma: 47
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #121 on: August 14, 2006, 02:03:42 PM »
what do you want him to do yorkshire? 

What response to "you are mafia" do you expect besides "no i'm not"

I'm not saying he is innocent, but you are making yourself look very suspicious by this short oneliner posts over and over...

-steven

Offline stevenryals

  • A true blue from across the pond
  • I am the Law
  • Community Star
  • *
  • Posts: 11142
  • Karma: 47
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #122 on: August 14, 2006, 02:06:10 PM »
Again::::  WARNING  :::::::   This one's going to be long....
sorry, but I missed a lot over the weekend............ .

Manic:  first, I thought you had investigated me, because you came instantly to my defense, but then you turned and voted for me without giving much reason...??? .  I'm now a little more suspicious of you.  But I think there are bigger fish to fry..

Dotleo:  FOS Dotleo Simply because you are playing in too many directions right now.  Staying in the background for the majority of the time, and you're just going with whatever flow you can find, and thats the formula for mafia right there, nothing too out of the ordinary, nothing to cause too much suspicion.

Hammer: You're a townie, you're innocent, so stop even thinking about me being evil, you need to keep an eye on Fozza, Dotleo and Amadjin.  And if I get lynched, they need to be the first to go.. because you will see what my role was....

Billy:  I think you have a high probability of being mafia, however, with that said, I do not think you deserve my vote yet.  The reason I picked you out, is basically becuase, well, you were the only one here, and I wanted to get things roling.  In a game with permanent votes, the only way I could see to get everything going, was to begin puting hard pressure on someone, and see how everyone responds.  Well, it worked.  : )  Had I not done that, it would have been very difficult to decipher who was who.  and we would probably still be on about post # 40.

Amadjin:  FOS Amadjin I was going to vote for you earlier, but then you FOS'd dotleo, I was sure you guys were in cahoots together, however, since you didnt' give any reasons to why you fos'd him, and because maybe that was a cover.  If you were 100% innocent, you would have tried to root him out, and get him to defend himself, however, you just put a quick one liner and fos'd him.  But I'm still not sure, since you did fos him, and that's 1/3 of a vote.....?????  

Weasel:  I dont know about you, usually you post more, but you seem very quiet in this game????
Hippo:  You seem innocent for the most part...
Raygun Bull: Same for you, but you usually post more.. ???
Halo: Same for you, you seem innocent but you usually post more...


Fozza: You have been suspect from day one, minute one, and heres more reasons why:
   you said:
Quote
DotLeo has posted only TWICE in the whole game. However he is one of steven's main suspects. Why? Because he FOS'd you steven. Is that a crime?
why are you sticking up for dotleo, who has acted suspiciously by posting very few times, and his first post to fakevote and his second to FOS and his 3rd was to cast his vote on someone else?? He hasn't posted since???.   If you cant see that as suspicious activity, then maybe he is your mafia brother and you can't see it, because that woudl cause everyone else to see it as well.  In my book, dotleo is now up to about 70%.

Quote
If steven is making assumptions like this, why should we believe him on anything because all he is doing is fos ing anyone who has said a word about him
why try to discredit me when I'm an innocent, unless you know i'm innocent and thats something you dont like.  All i've done is be active in the game, and point out discrepancies in billy's posts.  Really, I've brought some good points to the table, yet you overlook them, and simply say, "why should we believe ANYTHING steven says?"  because simply, i've brought some valid points, that can be confirmed by previous posts in this thread.  That's why, I'm not talking voodoo here, I'm not making stuff up, I'm pointing out valid points that you can go back and read yourself and make your decision based on the facts.  However, you tell everyone to simply, "don't listen to steven"... why?  Even if you think i'm a baddie, and want to vote for me, thats fine, but my points have been valid, you can see it, but you can't admit it. because you are mafia yourself.    and I'll continue now....

fozza said:
Quote
Manic Monkey Man has posted twice, (again if we exclude the "welcome post"), his two posts stated fakevote fozza and fos amadjin. If one FOS means someone is half guilty. does two fos's mean he is 100% guilty.

you want to talk about my funny math?  what is this?  Manicmonkey voted for me, however, at first he was on my side, backing me, I'm not sure where the change happened, but that's suspicious activity to me.  Firstly, what you wrote here makes no sense.  But the strange thing is, you said ,
 
Quote
The answer will be from you "No he isnt"
 
How do you know that?  why would you assume that?  This was a mistake on your part fozza.  Bad form.

Quote
your'e talking absolute BS.
  I think you discredit my accusations because some of them are correct, given i'm sure I'm not 100% correct, but why would you simply come out and try to do nothing but discredit me?  You accuse me of being biased, yet you never gave me a chance.  In my opinion you are evil, and you deserve to die (or walk through the door) for it.  

In your first post Fozza, you said,
Quote
if any good person did an investigation and knows of any evil or in fact anyone good so we can eliminate them from voting then letus know.
 ?????  and nobody else sees this as suspicious?

your third post was your 'discredit everything steven has said, do not believe him' post.

then on your 4th post, you voted for me.  Yea, I've put myself out there for everyone to see, and you have sat in the background waiting for your chance.  4 posts, i dont thing happy will even count your vote, that's not anywhere near enough for people to get a feel for who you are, but the fact that you feel that you have to sit in the background while the rest of us play and put ourselves out there, means to me you are mafia.  

your 5th posts:
Quote
All he has done through every post is look at someone to get rid of.
 Is this not what we are here for?  then you say:  
Quote
 I could be wrong so base your vote on your own decision, not my words.
This wat a feble attempt to cover yourself after I am lynched, because I will be shown as innocent, and you think that because you said this, nobody will point the finger at you.  Even though you casted the first vote, and your mafia brothers bandwaggoned on top of it.

5 posts: 1 welcome posts, requesting the cops to reveal, one saying , "i didnt ask them to reveal", one trying to discredit me, one voting for me, and a final posts covering yourself so it looks like your just a misinformed townie.

VOTE Fozza


Maybe everyone should start looking at the people who have posted very little rather than the ones that are willing to put themselves on the table for everyone to see.  Use the force... If you lynch me, you'll be 1 less innocent person...  Billy and I were willing to let everyone see us, Billy put a little less into it, and he was dragged into it a bit, so I am still suspicious of him, but he hasn't done anything worse than many others.  I wish Fozza had been online all day friday so I could have called him out... I'm sure that would have been a different story.
Billy, you're a good sport...  : )


-Steven

ManicMonkeyMan

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #123 on: August 14, 2006, 02:08:29 PM »
to be honest, i think his short posts are all to do with that its his first game, and he is still getting to grips with it.  maybe once he gets to grip with it then he may elaborate on his posts.  but until then don't really think you can accuse him ;)

ManicMonkeyMan

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #124 on: August 14, 2006, 02:14:40 PM »
that last post was reffered to yorkshire blue by the way ;)

steven you have pursuaded me that you are not evil, only thing being though... i think its in the rules that once you have voted it cant be changed :-\  so if that is the case, i am sorry i was too hasty in my vote :(

dotLeo

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #125 on: August 14, 2006, 02:21:11 PM »
In my books he has spoken enough. All he has done through every post is look at someone to get rid of. And he has placed a bullseye on billy's head when (as far as i can see) billy hasnt done that much to be suspicious. Yorkshire blue and DotLeo definetely look suspicious with them dodgy posts so we're going to have to keep an eye on them. But they have aroused suspicion from one post where has steven if u look back and read through has said something dodgy in every post. I'm stickin by my guns here. I could be wrong so base your vote on your own decision, not my words.

lol @ dodgy posts.  In my case it is down to inexperience, and I can't vouch for yorkshire blue but I reckon it is the same for him. 

dotLeo

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #126 on: August 14, 2006, 02:25:53 PM »

Dotleo:  FOS Dotleo Simply because you are playing in too many directions right now.  Staying in the background for the majority of the time, and you're just going with whatever flow you can find, and thats the formula for mafia right there, nothing too out of the ordinary, nothing to cause too much suspicion.

<snip, try paragraphs>

Maybe everyone should start looking at the people who have posted very little rather than the ones that are willing to put themselves on the table for everyone to see.


I'm not an independent thinker, that's all :P  Although I think you'll find my reason for my vote was unique.

It's very hard to judge with so few people contributing greatly. 

dotLeo

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #127 on: August 14, 2006, 02:27:45 PM »
Also I'm not just going to post for the sake of posting, if I don't have anything to say I'll keep quiet. 

Apologies for 3 consecutive posts!!!  :-*

Offline Happy Axeman

  • City till it kills me
  • The Gaffer
  • Community Star
  • *
  • Posts: 11847
  • Karma: 150
  • Smile, Be Happy
    • Happyaxeman.co.uk
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #128 on: August 14, 2006, 02:29:49 PM »
the computer screen refreshes after the latest happenings.


GAME UPDATE
the Story so far:
There has been 4 investigations already!

DAY 1
There are 12 alive.
It will require a maximum of 8 votes to make someone enter the door...
Otherwise the Majority goes through...
Or Something Else happens...

People with votes against there name:
STEVEN RYALS x5(x1 FOS VOTE, Fozza, Evil Weasel, Billyman, Manicmonkey)
BILLYMAN x3(x1 FOS VOTE, YorkshireBlue, DotLeo)
FOZZA x1(StevenRyals)
AMADJIN x1(x1 FOS VOTE)
DOTLEO x1(Amadjin)

Prime suspects(FOS):
BILLYMAN x4(Stevenryals, Hippo, Churchy, Amadjin)
STEVENRYALS x4(Dotleo, Der Hammer, Amadjin,hippo)
Amadjin x3(Der Hammer, ManicMonkeyMan, StevenRyals)
Fozza x2(Der Hammer, Hippo)
YorkshireBlue x2(Churchy, Billyman)
Der Hammer x1(Billyman)
Evil Weasel x1(ManicMonkeyMan)
DotLeo x1(stevenRyals)

People Who Have voted:
Billyman, ManicMonkeyMan, YorkshireBlue, Evil Weasel, Fozza, Dotleo, Amadjin, StevenRyals
People not voting:
ChurchofHalo, Der Hammer, Raygin Bull, Hippo
People Who Have Used All FOS's:
DerHammer, StevenRyals

Please Enter your action >
« Last Edit: August 14, 2006, 03:48:51 PM by Happy Axeman »

yorkshire blue

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #129 on: August 14, 2006, 02:39:33 PM »
when does a day end

ManicMonkeyMan

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #130 on: August 14, 2006, 02:40:19 PM »
when we get the required number of votes to send someone through the door, 8 i think we need now ;)

froganomis

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #131 on: August 14, 2006, 02:50:12 PM »
steve you should have no reason to acuse me,specially when theres people posting things like this.......DOTLEO - im not an independant thinker...which strongly suggests to me your part of a team.....this coupled with the attack on billy for no reason youve sure got my vote vote:dotleo

hippo

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #132 on: August 14, 2006, 03:09:33 PM »
Right okay, it's really hard to pick who to vote for because i'm pretty convinced steven isn't evil. And also have a suspicion that billyman is innocent. And they're the two that have really had any focus on them.

I think fozza has been pretty suspicious, but i did enjoy his post about steven's use of random maths. Manic i'm a bit wary of now - because he put in vote on steven without letting him respond, and then has wished he could retract it afterwards. Something i got accused of doing a few games ago - knowing full well, he can't change it, and trying to reduce any suspicion that goes to him as a consequence of steven appearing innocent after his lynch. Although, it could just be a genuine mistake.

Other than that, dotleo, billy, yorkshire blue, amadjin, and weasel have all been moderately suspicious, but nothing that really warrants a vote. Hammer i've never seen play before, so is harder to judge. He seems innocent though. As do Raygin and Church.

By my calculations, with steve on 5, billy on 3, and fozza, amadjin and dotleo all on 1; and with only 4 people left to vote. Unless people have fos's left?  Because it seems for my vote to have any point to it, it has to go on steven or billy, because they're the only two who can possibly be lynched. What happens if it's a draw? Tell me that and then i'll choose someone.

Offline Happy Axeman

  • City till it kills me
  • The Gaffer
  • Community Star
  • *
  • Posts: 11847
  • Karma: 150
  • Smile, Be Happy
    • Happyaxeman.co.uk
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #133 on: August 14, 2006, 03:18:44 PM »
THERE WILL NOT BE A DRAW.
ALL I CAN SAY IS THAT DAY ONE IS DIFFERENT TO THE FUTURE DAYS THAT WILL FOLLOW.
OR THEY COULD BE THE SAME...

THERE ARE STILL SOME PEOPLE WHO ARE THREATENING TO MAKE THE GAME INTO NIGHT... AND THE NIGHT IS DRAWING CLOSER AND CLOSER...

ONCE ALL FOS'S AND VOTES ARE IN AND THERE IS NO MAJORITY THEN YOU HAVE ONE LAST CHANCE TO UTILISE YOUR VOTES. IF YOU WISH TO SUBTRACT YOUR VOTE AND PLACE IT ON SOMEONE ELSE, YOU CAN DO IT ONCE, BUT IT MUST ALL BE CONCLUDED IN ONE ACTION.
THERE WILL BE ROUGHLY 24 HOURS FOR YOU TO MAKE CHANGES.
THE PERSON LEFT AFTER THE DEADLINE WITH THE MOST VOTES GOES THROUGH THE DOOR

UNVOTE PLAYER
VOTE PLAYER
« Last Edit: August 14, 2006, 03:31:33 PM by Happy Axeman »

hippo

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #134 on: August 14, 2006, 03:32:11 PM »
Okay then. I'll just choose one of billyman or stevenryals because doing anything else could be akin to not voting at all. I don't know. There's a lot of wait and see with this game. But if people tie and that kills them both, that could be pretty damaging to the town. It could be brilliant obviously, but you've got to play the odds.

So between the 2, i've suspected both at various points of today. But i really don't think somebody who was evil would have put themselves out and accused people to the extent steven has. I'm not exactly convinced that billyman is, but if it's a choice between the two (thanks to some pretty hasty bandwagon voting) then i'd have to be forced to choose to vote billyman.

hippo

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #135 on: August 14, 2006, 03:35:07 PM »
Ah, that post changed as i was typing mine. That's annoying.

ManicMonkeyMan

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #136 on: August 14, 2006, 03:35:30 PM »
i've got a feeling that both may be innocent, and after steven ryals post i am inclined to change my vote for fozza.  but if changing my vote wont make any difference then there is no point in me chaging it.  will have to wait and see what the non-voters opt to do

Offline Happy Axeman

  • City till it kills me
  • The Gaffer
  • Community Star
  • *
  • Posts: 11847
  • Karma: 150
  • Smile, Be Happy
    • Happyaxeman.co.uk
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #137 on: August 14, 2006, 03:43:14 PM »
Ah, that post changed as i was typing mine. That's annoying.
I ONLY ADDED TO IT JUST TO MAKE IT CLEARER OF WHAT HAPPENS IF ITS A DRAW.
I CAN RETRACT YOUR VOTE IF YOU WOULD WISH...

hippo

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #138 on: August 14, 2006, 03:45:59 PM »
If that's possible? I'd like to yes, i really don't think either of those 2 are evil.

ManicMonkeyMan

  • Guest
Re: Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD
« Reply #139 on: August 14, 2006, 03:47:42 PM »
in that case, can you retract mine aswell ;)