Mini Mafia Game; No thrills Good and Evil!

[stevenryals]

My main focus for right now I'd the vote patter for mophead a lunch.  Understanding that any mafia member would likely know who is mafia and who is not, it's conceivable to say that at least one of the voting party is mafia. Probably a dangerous once I was vote number two, but I know I'm town, so the logic adds up for me. 

I'm certain that one of Laserblue, masterzulu, or dickenscider are evil.

Dickens: if someone else who had an actionable trophy can confirm a similarity to dickens trophy action claim, I could be inclined to think he is town.

Laserblue,  as the first voter, to difficult to know, but he should likely be given a 50/50 probability based on the vote pattern

Masterzulu: if my theory on dickens cider turns out to be false by way of confirmation of similar trophy actions, I'm most inclined to think he is evil. Out of 5, the third vote is most typically the "evil goes here" vote based on previous games.  It feels safe when the vote is made, but it does cause the bandwagon to begin to roll. Nobody knew there was a trophy in play to reduce the # of votes needed to lunch down to 4, but I think that can be used to highlight these two players.   Dickens and Zulu.   I think one of those two are defo evil. Im either voting for dickens or Zulu.. 

Again, can anyone with a trophy confirm this type of action that dickens has claimed?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[stevenryals]

(FFS at the typos and autocorrects - on my phone - horrible)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

My main focus for right now I'd the vote patter for mophead a lunch.

Gold!!

[stevenryals]

Ffs. This is why I don't use my phone to do anything but play pet rescue. Lol.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

I had a night action..  I actually have a variety of choices for night action.  I am definitely town and the town need me.  I'll probably be killed tonight if I don't get lynched, maybe someone will be so kind as to use a protective action on me if they have one, but if you're town and your vote is still on me, you're making a mistake. 

So you have a variety of night actions? That suggests at least three? And none of the variety of actions allows you to protect yourself ? That seems a bit suspicious. What can town do apart from investigate or protect/save. Giving a townie the power to kill in a game this small just wouldn't work. Mophead was the copper which suggests standard townie role with one action, yet you are claiming town with multiple night actions?!? Plus if you are town what is the harm in telling everyone what night action you did?

This just doesn't seem right

so vote steve

please explain

[stevenryals]

Dumb choice TCH.  Very dumb. 
I think there are probably other town members with multiple night action options.  For me I do have the option to protect myself, or protect another. Each action costs points, I gain points when I get through a day phase.  I can protect myself tonight, but if I protect someone else I also learn a little about their role. So it would be best for me to protect someone else.  But without knowledge that someone else is protecting me, now that I've given this info, I will likely protect myself. 

Again, quite a horrible conclusion.  Poor play if you're a town member, predictable if you're mafia, which I'm beginning to think is the case.

Good job TCH.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Happy Axeman]

Current Vote Count
Steve x2 Laser, TCH
Miasg x1 Dicky
Tch x1 Zulu
Dicky x 1 Steve


We require 4 to clinch a lynch 

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

so if this is true what did you do last night? If you protected someone you should know something? As I have a more traditional role like Mophead's I might seem dumb to you Steve, poor play I don't think so just calling it as I see it based on what I can do in the game, can anyone else comment?

Why is this predicable mafia play? The aim is to find things to question, if you answer to my satisfaction then I will remove the vote

[MIASG]

So TCH you have a standard role like mophead but had no night actions?  Is this right?  Happy made it clear from the start this isn't as such a traditional mafia game its just good v evil.  People keep using phrases like town this townie that .. not sure if its habit or you are evil and have no idea what role (s)  the good have. 

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

[MIASG]

I should clarify the bit that starts "Happy made.." isn't addressed to TCH but to everyone - although he does like saying town

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

So TCH you have a standard role like mophead but had no night actions?  Is this right?  Happy made it clear from the start this isn't as such a traditional mafia game its just good v evil.  People keep using phrases like town this townie that .. not sure if its habit or you are evil and have no idea what role (s)  the good have. 

Yes town/townie is my terminology, I only know two roles, mine and that Mophead was the copper (which is a traditional town role). If you read Happy's first post on day 2 it states there were only 3 night actions during night one, so 3 people did not have a night action, I was one of those.

DC said he had one, from Steve's post he's indicating that he had one and are you saying the third night action was you ? Laser MZ can you shed any more information on the matter? It would stand to reason that one of three people who had a night action is evil, why would someone evil do nothing it serves them no benefit? To win they need to kill us off so a no kill night phase is a bad result for them.

[Dickens Cider]

Yes town/townie is my terminology, I only know two roles, mine and that Mophead was the copper (which is a traditional town role). If you read Happy's first post on day 2 it states there were only 3 night actions during night one, so 3 people did not have a night action, I was one of those.

DC said he had one, from Steve's post he's indicating that he had one and are you saying the third night action was you ? Laser MZ can you shed any more information on the matter? It would stand to reason that one of three people who had a night action is evil, why would someone evil do nothing it serves them no benefit? To win they need to kill us off so a no kill night phase is a bad result for them.

While this logic is usually good, this is a HappyAxeman game, so any twist and turn is possible.

It is possible that Zulu is evil and the trophy he received disabled evils ability to have an action.
Happy also mentioned other objects / artefacts that are in play, so it's a possibility one of them prevented evil from performing a kill action.
Its also very possible that my block on MIASG prevented him from killing someone, leaving steves action as the 3rd.

Any of these are possible, yet none of them may be correct.

[MIASG]

Are you skimming?   I've said I had no night action

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

[MIASG]

DC your night action if true was just wasted as I didn't have a night action.  So its the next 2 to look at.

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

[Dickens Cider]

DC your night action if true was just wasted as I didn't have a night action.  So its the next 2 to look at.

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

I beg to differ...
I didn't die, nor did any other person on the good team. So was it really wasted ?!

[MIASG]

Was on me i had no actions

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

[stevenryals]

from Steve's post he's indicating that he had one and are you saying the third night action was you ?

No, each action costs points.  I didn't have enough points to do anything on the first night.
Interestingly I had to make a decision last night in a old school role playing game format..  i saw a blood stained man, I was asked if I want to try to get a better look at his face or not..  I chose not to and was awarded 20 points (the points have a special name which I think any townie with a decent role will know - but I'm not going to say it because that detail may be important later in the game)

I'm kind of banking on happyaxeman keeping a similarly worded theme from my role through to other roles..  if you are town, and have a role that requires this type of 'edible' points, you should know that I'm also town and you should probably do what you can to stop me from getting lynched. 

if you are evil you certainly won't know what these 'edible' points are so I'll give you three guesses, BUT ONLY 3..  Begin guessing now.. 

[MIASG]

So in seeing this blood stained man did you pick a name or did this magically just appear ?

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

[stevenryals]

So in seeing this blood stained man did you pick a name or did this magically just appear ?

uh-oh.. I think you've dropped one here miasg..

Ah.. yes..  clever use of wording..  "just magically appear", try to immediately discredit the post as you may know it's beginning to lead toward you.

and, apparently the 'edible' point system is foreign to you since you didn't mention it, meaning you're likely not a good town role.   

I think it means that there was an attack last night, but it was blocked.  someone, somehow got bloody.  It's been said that you were blocked last night and there were no kills last night. 

the language used by dicken's cider regarding his trophy has not yet been confirmed (or even acknowledged actually) by another player yet, but it seems legit.  So, while remaining near the top of my list until I get a trophy or until someone else can somewhat confirm that the language he used may be typical for a townie, I'll UNVOTE Dickens Cider

I'm also going to VOTE MIASG.  In my previous post I gave some very critical information and your first response was to attempt to nullify this by "oh this just magically appeard then?".  I think you've been caught out Miasg.  I think it was you who was bloody, and someone was there to block your attempted kill. 

[MIASG]

I said I didn't have a night action on night 1 and it was true. There was nothing to block.  I never said I was a vanilla player.  I'm not role claiming cause I'll be mod killed.  I could have introduced items but decided i didn't know enough and could hurt good more than evil. Which is why I used the term magical .. thinking it may be similar to your claim and if you are good or "town" as you keep claiming you would see I'm the same.  I had an item that made me ammune only during night 1 but if investigated i could appear to be the opposite.  I had a choice to pass it on and I didn't. It is one part of another item someone else has .. i don't know who has it.  So to me someone else may have these edible points and have magical items. 

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk