Mini Mafia Game; No thrills Good and Evil!

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

Miasg x1 - Trophy of the Pointless Fos (first person to use FOS)
Dicky Cider x1 - Trophy of the Last poster (the last person to post at the start of the game)


These two have not said anything about their trophies? Gents?

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

Current Vote Count:
Mophead x4 Laser, Steve, MZ, Dick

Lastly MZ I did not vote for Mophead I am not responsible for the cop being lynched. But you did.

[stevenryals]

You comment about how others are playing but so far you have been a lot less active than you normally are so it's a case of pot calling kettle.

I completely agree.  I should be finishing up with this project today and resuming normal service next week. 

Waiting for Steve to explain himself before I cast my vote.

Already did.. huge project hit my desk.. hoping to finish up today..

It's ages since TCH played so it's hard to say what I think about his play but something's going on with Steve either he really is busy, can't be arsed or evil.  vote Steve

you're either evil yourself and trying to off another townie, or you're just unable to read.  yes, I'm not posting much, but I've been putting in extra hours at the office trying to finish up a massive ethernet project.  basically over the last 5 years there was no procedure in place for disconnecting cloud circuits and a huge backlog built up.. i've having to clear that entire 5 years of backlog..  so.. 

vote if you want,, but you'll not like the result if i get lynched.. 

[laserblue]

I completely agree.  I should be finishing up with this project today and resuming normal service next week. 

Already did.. huge project hit my desk.. hoping to finish up today..


you're either evil yourself and trying to off another townie, or you're just unable to read.  yes, I'm not posting much, but I've been putting in extra hours at the office trying to finish up a massive ethernet project.  basically over the last 5 years there was no procedure in place for disconnecting cloud circuits and a huge backlog built up.. i've having to clear that entire 5 years of backlog..  so.. 

vote if you want,, but you'll not like the result if i get lynched.. 

I really hope that's the truth & you do join in properly unvote steve for now.

[laserblue]

Lastly MZ I did not vote for Mophead I am not responsible for the cop being lynched. But you did.

I know this is an answer to MZ but
Voting or not voting for Mophead doesn't make anyone good or evil. an evil player would know he was good & might not vote for him so they look good next day. I don't mind admitting I voted for Mophead. Voting on the first day is always a bit of a guess & I fully explained my reasons at the time .. why would he tell the evil side right from the start that he had an important role .. it's madness?

[MIASG]

My trophy for the FOS had an inscription that FOS are pointless  and mean nothing therefore my effect of holding the trophy : nothing.   

Sent from my SM-G900I using Tapatalk

[MASTERZULU]

Lastly MZ I did not vote for Mophead I am not responsible for the cop being lynched. But you did.

Well if anyone was responable for that lynch it was Mophead himself.

What better way to subvert suspicion that to hold back from voting on a sure fire lynch.

[MASTERZULU]

I know this is an answer to MZ but
Voting or not voting for Mophead doesn't make anyone good or evil. an evil player would know he was good & might not vote for him so they look good next day. I don't mind admitting I voted for Mophead. Voting on the first day is always a bit of a guess & I fully explained my reasons at the time .. why would he tell the evil side right from the start that he had an important role .. it's madness?

indeed. Applying that faulty logic the other way would imply that if Mophead had been a bad guy that everyone who voted was good.
Just doesn't work on a first day vote, last time I'll say it but Mop essentially killed himself. 

[stevenryals]

indeed. Applying that faulty logic the other way would imply that if Mophead had been a bad guy that everyone who voted was good.
Just doesn't work on a first day vote, last time I'll say it but Mop essentially killed himself.

The difference is that evil likely would know that mophead was good.  If there are 2-3 evil and we need 5 for a lynch, town only need 2-3 votes before they can pile on and cause a lynch. 

Whereas evil would be less likely to vote for their fellow mafia members.   

I'm sure you understand clearly the difference here and, in my opinion, it's extremely sus for you to attempt to justify this extremely flawed logic. 

FOS Zulu


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[MASTERZULU]

The difference is that evil likely would know that mophead was good.  If there are 2-3 evil and we need 5 for a lynch, town only need 2-3 votes before they can pile on and cause a lynch. 

Whereas evil would be less likely to vote for their fellow mafia members.   

I'm sure you understand clearly the difference here and, in my opinion, it's extremely sus for you to attempt to justify this extremely flawed logic. 

FOS Zulu


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Absolutely no idea what your going on about tbh,  just another useless post of nothing.

In fact you have managed 2 posts now since I asked you why the sudden u-turn and you've still not managed to answer it.

Went from playing usual game to highly sus in no time with no basis. And yet you can't say why, don't tell me you have a trophy that's forbids you saying something also, that would be golden. 

Seems to be the mafias game plan in this game to just simply ignore anything they don't want to answer and hope it gets swept under the rug.

My votes still with TCH at this point but I will happily jump all over a band wagon on you as your so sus it's nearly off the chart.

[MIASG]

I'm leaning towards steve over TCH as he's, when playing, been single focused like towards mophead, and this is different to his normal style.     
For that I'm favouring him over TCH. 
vote stevenryals 
Also TCH had a trophy that assisted him.  Not sure if his had an expiry
or used as mine had no expiry - but again it has no effects.  And really it doesn't matter what he says now because i doubt I'm inclined to believe it.

[laserblue]

To be honest I think that at least one of you Aussies are evil (you all say you think each other is evil) they way you all picked on each other in the first round, I believe that at least one of you did that as a deliberate ploy to make it look like you were involved in the game & looking for evil it's a ploy used by at least one of you in previous games.
 Having said that I don't know who to believe I tried going back & looking at your posts .. Miasg you made several "errors" when having a go at TCH & despite what you say it looks like you were skimming,, only thing stopping me voting for you right now is that you did exactly the same in the last game & turned out to be good? TCH has been only to happy to get involved arguing with you tit for tat. makes it look like he's busy .. then there's Tricky Dickey Cider been a bit quite lately I would say?? like I said I don't think your all evil but I'm certain at least one of you is.

Steve is doing nothing for the game just bluffing his way through. He only seems to appear when someone votes for him. He did it when I voted for him & did it when MZ said he said he was suspicious of him. so I expect to see him on soon now you voted for him?

[laserblue]

Things seem to have dried up.. vote Steve  I think you are the most suspicious person at this point. your not playing your normal game but calling others for doing the same.  your not challenging others with anything useful
anyone can say there busy & anyone can say there town but so far your actions don't reflect that.
so far you added nothing to the game.
I also think DickensC needs to start posting as he's quickly going up my list of suspicion for sliding through.

[Dickens Cider]

Miasg x1 - Trophy of the Pointless Fos (first person to use FOS)
Dicky Cider x1 - Trophy of the Last poster (the last person to post at the start of the game)

These two have not said anything about their trophies? Gents?

It says I can't discuss it until after it's used... I have no idea if it's been used or not, so I'm not taking the risk to discuss it.

I also think DickensC needs to start posting as he's quickly going up my list of suspicion for sliding through.

Twas the weekend, I rarely sit at a computer on the weekend.
Unless I'm getting paid for it.

[MIASG]

It says I can't discuss it until after it's used... I have no idea if it's been used or not, so I'm not taking the risk to discuss it.

thats pretty cryptic... you don't know if its been used? Guess that'll make more sense once we all know about it.

[stevenryals]

There has been a lot of skimming in this game thus far.. this post is a bit longer than most, so please don't skim it. 

In fact you have managed 2 posts now since I asked you why the sudden u-turn and you've still not managed to answer it.

I'm really not sure how else I could have said it..  I was given years worth of backlogged orders to complete and it took up all of my time that I would use to play this game.. 

anyway, i'm alive now..  but it seems like a bit of a bandwaggon is forming..

4 votes for a lynch..  I have 2.  I'm not going to roleclaim yet, but I will if I pick up one more vote.. so,  if you see 3 votes on me, hold off before lynching me to give me a chance to role claim..  I'm 100% town, and if I'm lynched the town doesnt stand much of a chance.. 

-----------------

So, the lynching of mophead..
laser and I voted him first
then master Zulu
then Dickens Cider

I feel that the votes my be getting to a stalemate with MIASG and mophead.
So seeing as I think they are both evil I will unvote MIASG and vote mophead

*This is the vote that lynched mophead..  it mentions no evidence whatsoever.. 
*in this post (http://happyaxeman.co.uk/forums/index.php?topic=44941.msg177876#msg177876) he mentions mophead as one of his top 2 evil, but still no evidence.
*in this post (http://happyaxeman.co.uk/forums/index.php?topic=44941.msg177867#msg177867) he confronts mophead's defense of miasg, but doesnt sayanything other than "you're trying hard to look innocent".  hardly considered 'evidence'

this is literally his only interactions with & about mophead..

with mopheads trophy meaning it took one less vote to lynch, I think Dickens was trying to pile on without being the last one to vote, which would be too suspicious..  this was an easy lynch for evil..


I'm going to vote Dickens Cider as I think he is the most likely to be evil at this stage in the game.

[laserblue]

I still suspect either tch or miasg... can't see them being on same side... which one of you is evil

[Happy Axeman]

Current Vote Count:
Steve x2 Miasg, Laser
Miasg x1 Dicky
Tch x1 Zulu
Dicky x 1 Steve

We require 4 for the Lynch!

[laserblue]

There has been a lot of skimming in this game thus far.. this post is a bit longer than most, so please don't skim it. 

I'm really not sure how else I could have said it..  I was given years worth of backlogged orders to complete and it took up all of my time that I would use to play this game.. 

anyway, i'm alive now..  but it seems like a bit of a bandwaggon is forming..

4 votes for a lynch..  I have 2.  I'm not going to roleclaim yet, but I will if I pick up one more vote.. so,  if you see 3 votes on me, hold off before lynching me to give me a chance to role claim..  I'm 100% town, and if I'm lynched the town doesnt stand much of a chance.. 

-----------------

So, the lynching of mophead..
laser and I voted him first
then master Zulu
then Dickens Cider

*This is the vote that lynched mophead..  it mentions no evidence whatsoever.. 
*in this post (http://happyaxeman.co.uk/forums/index.php?topic=44941.msg177876#msg177876) he mentions mophead as one of his top 2 evil, but still no evidence.
*in this post (http://happyaxeman.co.uk/forums/index.php?topic=44941.msg177867#msg177867) he confronts mophead's defense of miasg, but doesnt sayanything other than "you're trying hard to look innocent".  hardly considered 'evidence'

this is literally his only interactions with & about mophead..

with mopheads trophy meaning it took one less vote to lynch, I think Dickens was trying to pile on without being the last one to vote, which would be too suspicious..  this was an easy lynch for evil..


I'm going to vote Dickens Cider as I think he is the most likely to be evil at this stage in the game.

do you still suspect MZ ... why did you suspect him before ... and why not know?

am I still high on your suspicious list, if so why ?

what do you think about tch & miasg? you've hardly mentioned them?

I hope the game does not descend into a bunch of roll claims .. it just ruins the game..

[stevenryals]

do you still suspect MZ ... why did you suspect him before ... and why not know?

am I still high on your suspicious list, if so why ?

what do you think about tch & miasg? you've hardly mentioned them?

I hope the game does not descend into a bunch of roll claims .. it just ruins the game..

I have no knowledge of any other players role or affiliations, so everyone is still highly suspect on my list. 

As I've had more time today than previously, I've went through the entire game.  What I picked up on was the manner in which dickens cider cast his telling vote on mophead.  Zulu was the "safe" vote (3rd on a bandwaggon) and typically mafia tend to be found there, but his game so far has been pretty tight, I didn't find anything substantial when review his posts, maybe he will slip, but so far the most concrete thing I can find is dickens method of lynching the cop..  I think unfortunately for him, he didn't expect the trophy to mean his vote caused the lynch, and I bet when he saw it he was worried he would be found out.