OK, been very busy the last few days. Not an excuse as I could've posted something but thought it wouldn't have been very worthwhile as I would've just been defending myself like I have been since the start of this day. I have now finally got a chance to have a look back over the entire game so far and provide my thoughts on what's gone on.
1 thing I don't get already is that I said I was gonna go back and have a look at what's gone on and make another post like this but why has nobody else bothered?
Anyway, initially we start the game with 14 players. It's always hard to guess how many good/bad guys there are gonna be but from what's gone on so far I will have a guess at the possibilities.
14 players. 1 cult, 1 serial killer, 4 mafia and 8 town. That's just a guess, Amadjin may have had a cult buddy, there may be more mafia, who knows. Then obviously Manic joined as well. God knows what he is as Shoz was just a normal townie so would Steven put him straight in as another mafia or on his own or just another normal townie?
Immediately on the first day Amadjin gets put under pressure and makes himself look suspicious by the way he posts. That eventually resulted in his lynch.
The people that lynched Amadjin were Axeman, Footynewb, MiasG, Wes, SVH, TCH, Laserblue & Afro. Once again we can expect atleast a couple of mafia in there.
My reasoning behind that is that Amadjin was a very easy target as he was looking so suspicious. No matter whether you're mafia or town you're not gonna know that Amadjin is cult. If you're town he looks suspicious so you'd think he's mafia and vote for him. If you're mafia you just realise that he's an easy target for the lynch as he looks so suspicious.
Footynewb obviously thought this and jumped on the bandwagon so it just depends on everyone else. He actually voted for Amadjin in his
very first post as well
Axeman was probably the main person behind Amadjin's lynch and the whole oven thing as well makes me think he's town at the moment. Nobody has argued against the oven claim and he has been trying to get people posting all the time. He also picked up on a possible slip from Bluestars. Dunno if he realised it or not but he did so he looks one of the most town in my eyes.
MiasG has done lots of rooting out so far and has posted a lot along with Wes on both days so far so I'm inclined towards them both being town so far.
I'm unsure on SVH. He posted about 4 times on day 1 (because of his dissertation) and he almost seemed to just go along with the bandwagon vote on Amadjin. He's been more active on day 2 though and I don't understand the whole cheese thing but I'm leaning towards him being town at the moment. Only just though because he had a good excuse not to post on day 1 and then just went along with the bandwagon on Amadjin.
TCH posted a lot on day 1. He changed his vote a lot mainly targetting the non-posters. He was suspicious of Mikeblue (just like I am) but he did eventually vote off Amadjin because he didn't think enough people would vote for Mike. Definitely looks like bandwagonage but would he be so obvious if he were mafia to do that? On day 2 he's changed his style a bit. He did still vote for Mophead who hasn't posted much but he also had a look back over what's been happening and he has been challenging people. So far I think he looks town.
That leaves Afro and Laser. Afro was town and funnily enough, he voted for both Footynewb and Bluestars on day 1 at some point and he made a mammoth post at one point picking out stuff on Mike and Bluestars. Perhaps he was killed because of this?
Laser is one that looks very suspicious to me. He posted 7 times in 10 pages with 2 of them being 1 liners adding nothing to the game. I was suspicious of him because of this and he comes out with a huge post so fair play for that but after this he barely posts again and uses his huge post as a means of showing that he has contributed. He also just kills off Amadjin right at the end of the bandwagon and says that I've been commentating all the time when that's exactly what he did for all of day 1 apart from his big post.
Day 2 so far he has challenged Mophead for not being active and then turned his attention to me. Hasn't done anything to look at the lynch from the last day or even looked at any of the other players and it looks to me like he's trying to go under the radar making 1 or 2 posts each page not adding anything to the game but trying to look like he's doing something by calling people out for not posting.
At the moment the only person I am finding truly suspicious is Laserblue. SVH is another possibility but the cheese thing makes me unsure. Mophead also needs to get on soon and post more.
