Mafia 17 - Harry Potter Game *Mafia Win*

[stevenryals]

Woof.

Vote: Mikeblue

I swear he never makes this much sense and posts this much that isn't random shit.

just a reminder..  maybe we should look hammerbro's first post before casting votes..  

EXPELLIARMUS:HIPPO

I protected Hippo 1st, night and then Stevenryals last night.

I have no opinion yet on Hippo. I genuinely think he will just play the same way regardless of role, too wise to slip up this early.
<<then he says the expellaramis thing then my name>>

Hammer seems to mention hippo and I alot in similar ways..  He also said the expellaramus or whatever to me as well.. but i swiped it off the quote, and don't feel like going back to find it..
now I know that I'm innocent..  I think hammer knew I was the first target, maybe for the first night or two.. so he wanted to show an innocent as someone he "protected"... this also links hippo to an innocent.. which is good for the mafia

Watching those trying to railroad Hippo into a bandwagon intently...

this said after 2 votes..  seems like a very strong statement for 2 votes..  almost like a nerve had been hit..  

hippo...  my friend..  i believe that sadly, you are in the last of the evils..

axeman has responded to seemingly meaningless claims with haste and with venom..  mike came at me earlier with the same type of claims, and they were responded to in the way a townie would..  axeman responds a bit more harshly as you can see.. 

5 posts since i started this.... 

ffs...  another one...

You keep claiming to have made people react, but there's a difference between that and someone responding to you.

guess you've not actually been reading axeman's posts.. compared to what he was posting on day 1 & 2...  major diff in his last 3 posts or so... 

[mophead]

Steve if you think im so evil and bad then wat do you think my role is

[stevenryals]

so he then defends himself and is accused of posting too much? lmao. oh the joys of these games. lol
Hippo is been accused of defending himself, to me it appears he is talking a fair bit of sense.

axeman in straightaway here to defend hippo...  just another example.. since i've been emplored to go back and read evidence..

[stevenryals]

Which is why I dont understand why hammer has also come out and role claimed harry potter?

thats all axeman had to say about such a big even in this game..  probably didn't want to give anything away by his responses..

Well, there must be one. Hammer claimed Harry Potter, and said he was a cult doctor. Unless that's a false claim or something (doesn't seem to be), then there must be. There's no need to even speculate about it.

"unless that's a false claim or something??"    hahaha!!! like you have no idea..  i believed him straight away when he claimed potter.. didn't really think anyone would pick the most popular character claim if it wasnt true..

come on!!  seriously...

[stevenryals]

Steve if you think im so evil and bad then wat do you think my role is

when did i say you're so evil and bad?   do your schoolwork

[i2i Killer 89]

I can't see where you're coming from when you say that Hippo hasn't been helpful Steven. He has always posted things that make sense and have good reasoning.

It's especially rich coming from you that wanted to keep BBM "over the pocket" and go and lynch someone else. We might've ended up lynching Yorkie (who turned out to be town) and then BBM would've still been alive and we'd be no further along. God knows who it was that killed Hammer but atleast there are 3 dead mafia rather than 2. OK so we could've killed BBM today but it's worked out much better this way. Rather than wasting a day killing Yorkie and then BBM we got rid of the dead cert mafia player and Yorkie is gone anyway so we didn't waste a kill.

Have been looking back and during the Wes lynch there was only Mophead, Wes, Hippo and I voting for BBM. It would be extremely unlikely that any mafia wouldn't be voting for Wes at this point as it would be a perfect opportunity to get a vote in and watch the bandwagon flow (for instance Villain was voting for Wes) so I think that Mophead and Hippo are likely to be town. On the other hand Axeman, Footynewb, Hammerbro, Laserblue, MiasG, Villain, SVH and Stevenryals voted for Wes. I think it's safe to say that all the remaining mafia members would be in those 7. Obviously Villain is so make that 6.

With the BBM lynch we had Hippo, myself, Bluestars & Mophead voting BBM all the way through just like with the Wes lynch.
Footynewb, Axeman, Laserblue & MiasG were all voting Yorkie before they then changed their vote to BBM.
MiasG and Stevenryals both changed their vote numerous times. However MiasG eventually switched his vote to BBM whereas Steven didn't.

If you look at the people that were involved in both lynches that would be Footynewb, Axeman, Laserblue & MiasG. I would say it's not too much of a stab in the dark to say that atleast 1 of those 4 are mafia. If they were mafia they wouldn't start by voting for 1 of their own would they. It was blatantly obvious that BBM was mafia yet they'd rather vote somebody off that was just inactive. Who do you vote for? Someone inactive but potentially town (Yorkie) or someone quite inactive and definitely mafia (BBM). Either they're stupid or mafia because it's obvious who to vote for.

Steven's stupid over the pocket nonsense can be used as an excuse by them now but after this hopefully people will see that it is suspicious. I do believe Steven in his claim. I don't think he's mafia, I just don't think he's played this game very well. He started well getting Mike and that goes in his favour in my view as well and he's made a claim that nobody has refuted. However since lynching Mike he's not done that great and seems to be obsessed by Hippo who I don't think is mafia.

So you've got MiasG, Axeman, Laserblue and Footynewb that voted for both Wes and BBM. Stevenryals, Hammerbro and SVH all voted for Wes as well but I've already said why I think Steven is town. SVH wouldn't be stupid enough to make that mistake about the vote count on BBM if he was mafia. He'd have either got his vote in earlier on or he would've just left it. I don't think he's mafia either but he does seem bit suspicious so could be potential cult or serial killer if either exist.
Hammerbro is suspicious as well and he has been very inactive but he didn't vote for BBM and did make that odd woof comment early on. Still suspicious but I don't think he's mafia.

I'm just trying to figure out who I think is most likely to be mafia out of those 4 that I have picked out but I leave it up to you all to think about it as well. I am gonna leave it for a bit. See if anyone comes up with anything that I haven't and go from there

[mophead]

when did i say you're so evil and bad?   do your schoolwork

im done....but you have been saying me and axeman are together(complete crap) so why dont you

[hippo]

I can't see where you're coming from when you say that Hippo hasn't been helpful Steven. He has always posted things that make sense and have good reasoning.

It's especially rich coming from you that wanted to keep BBM "over the pocket" and go and lynch someone else. We might've ended up lynching Yorkie (who turned out to be town) and then BBM would've still been alive and we'd be no further along. God knows who it was that killed Hammer but atleast there are 3 dead mafia rather than 2. OK so we could've killed BBM today but it's worked out much better this way. Rather than wasting a day killing Yorkie and then BBM we got rid of the dead cert mafia player and Yorkie is gone anyway so we didn't waste a kill.

Have been looking back and during the Wes lynch there was only Mophead, Wes, Hippo and I voting for BBM. It would be extremely unlikely that any mafia wouldn't be voting for Wes at this point as it would be a perfect opportunity to get a vote in and watch the bandwagon flow (for instance Villain was voting for Wes) so I think that Mophead and Hippo are likely to be town. On the other hand Axeman, Footynewb, Hammerbro, Laserblue, MiasG, Villain, SVH and Stevenryals voted for Wes. I think it's safe to say that all the remaining mafia members would be in those 7. Obviously Villain is so make that 6.

With the BBM lynch we had Hippo, myself, Bluestars & Mophead voting BBM all the way through just like with the Wes lynch.
Footynewb, Axeman, Laserblue & MiasG were all voting Yorkie before they then changed their vote to BBM.
MiasG and Stevenryals both changed their vote numerous times. However MiasG eventually switched his vote to BBM whereas Steven didn't.

If you look at the people that were involved in both lynches that would be Footynewb, Axeman, Laserblue & MiasG. I would say it's not too much of a stab in the dark to say that atleast 1 of those 4 are mafia. If they were mafia they wouldn't start by voting for 1 of their own would they. It was blatantly obvious that BBM was mafia yet they'd rather vote somebody off that was just inactive. Who do you vote for? Someone inactive but potentially town (Yorkie) or someone quite inactive and definitely mafia (BBM). Either they're stupid or mafia because it's obvious who to vote for.

Steven's stupid over the pocket nonsense can be used as an excuse by them now but after this hopefully people will see that it is suspicious. I do believe Steven in his claim. I don't think he's mafia, I just don't think he's played this game very well. He started well getting Mike and that goes in his favour in my view as well and he's made a claim that nobody has refuted. However since lynching Mike he's not done that great and seems to be obsessed by Hippo who I don't think is mafia.

So you've got MiasG, Axeman, Laserblue and Footynewb that voted for both Wes and BBM. Stevenryals, Hammerbro and SVH all voted for Wes as well but I've already said why I think Steven is town. SVH wouldn't be stupid enough to make that mistake about the vote count on BBM if he was mafia. He'd have either got his vote in earlier on or he would've just left it. I don't think he's mafia either but he does seem bit suspicious so could be potential cult or serial killer if either exist.
Hammerbro is suspicious as well and he has been very inactive but he didn't vote for BBM and did make that odd woof comment early on. Still suspicious but I don't think he's mafia.

I'm just trying to figure out who I think is most likely to be mafia out of those 4 that I have picked out but I leave it up to you all to think about it as well. I am gonna leave it for a bit. See if anyone comes up with anything that I haven't and go from there

Brilliant post that.

[stevenryals]

So you've got MiasG, Axeman, Laserblue and Footynewb that voted for both Wes and BBM.

excellent post Currie.. 

I believe you have a high quality list of possible there, and the next lynch should come from it... 

the first 3, miasg, axeman & laser, have all been sus in my opinion..  i think FBN has been given an easy ride this game..    but it's usually that way with the Aussie contingent, because when all the heats happenin.. they're sleepin'..

I'm going to go back and read your post again and look around again...   good work currieman.. 

[Happy Axeman]

Why's that a brill post Hippo? because it absolves you?
people seem to of missed Amadjins post...

i think there were major deflection tactics in place when steve hippo and mike were arguin day one.

mikeblue turned out to be evil and i had a not with you on hippo in the last night phase.so i think it's time to get rid of another mafiosa

vote:hippo

StevenRyals seems so intent on getting me, that he and peeps also seem to of missed my role claim. lol but you know what, I know i'm pro-town. and my history of being a townie in mafia games when i'm accused that i'm not is that i tend to get aggressive and end up getting modkilled... so steve whats your point again?

UNVOTE STEVENRYALS
VOTE HIPPO

[Dickens Cider]

You've done a good job at trying to get people to see things the way you want them to see things Currieman...
But if you're going to throw accusations around... maybe check your facts first...

Haven't checked the prior movements of others...
But in the BBM lynch... I did not change my vote from Yorkie to BBM... I had been voting for hippo... as he appeared suss... and still does...
as for the wes vote... anyone who bothered reading the shit he was writing would and did vote for him.. he never even tried to defend himself or speak any reason... he just busted a nut and went off... not a good thing to do when under suspicion and trying to convince people you're town...

whether SVH is mafia or not... i think he slipped up "miscounting"... 5 + 3 is pretty simple maths... even mophead knows that equals 8

now im not saying that your post is crap... there is definitely some decent and useful info in there...
and a link will be formed somewhere from that info...
i'm just pointing out that you're lumping me in with a group that shouldn't involve me...

and to put a spin on your theory... as patterns go....
you hippo and mophead could be linked somehow...

personally I dont think mophead is evil... he would have tried to blow someone up by now if he was (even if it wasnt in his role) haha

hippo... i think is mafia...

currieman... still not sure... just a bit suss that you obviously put alot of thought and research into your post... but still got facts wrong... from the most recent lynch too...

vote hippo at the moment, hes the person i think is most likely to be mafia...

[hippo]

I'm definitely good.

[froganomis]

I'm definitely good.

you are the only person who came up as not with me that iv checked and that means your not town

[Dickens Cider]

Just re-read some posts....
on second thoughts... currieman... i think you're good...
even if you did mess your facts up...
just something about your posts from previous days...
nothing really looking suss there to me at all...

and i wrote the wrong name for my vote... haha (its 4.30am shhhhh dont tell TCH or MIASG )
unvote hippo
vote amadjin

i mean to be as quiet as he has been... and then to come out only after being voted for and post what he did...
seems very weird...
so are you claiming to be a cop amadjin ??

[Dickens Cider]

you are the only person who came up as not with me that iv checked and that means your not town

why dont you fill us in on who else you've checked and what they came back as...

[froganomis]

night one tp/mophead - with me
steve ryals - with me
hippo - not with me

and yes i am the cop

[froganomis]

with regards to my revelations i was going to mention it when i got online anyway,iv only been able to get on here in the last hour or so

[stevenryals]

StevenRyals seems so intent on getting me, that he and peeps also seem to of missed my role claim.

I've not missed it, I continued on my agenda and was hoping to get a response from hippo first..  

don't need it now..  i was right anyway

unvote axeman
vote hippo

[stevenryals]

and i wrote the wrong name for my vote... haha (its 4.30am shhhhh dont tell TCH or MIASG )
unvote hippo
vote amadjin

interesting..  after amadjin just claimed cop...  you have turned your vote on him..
no response to his claim other than to vote for him?

[Dickens Cider]

night one tp/mophead - with me
steve ryals - with me
hippo - not with me

and yes i am the cop

thats a hard claim not to believe... as i always thought tp/mophead was good...
even when tp was crying about his tiny appendage... 
steven's claimed to be good... so that ties in... and that claim is also a hard one not to believe... especially with no mafia kills at night thus far...
and hippo has looked suss to me the past day or so... so that works well for me...

i'm inclined to believe you...

in light of this... unvote amadjin
wont vote for anyone just yet...
will see what other people have to add to the new developments...