Mafia 17 - Harry Potter Game *Mafia Win*

[bluestarsneyes]

When I read what Trick Pony said I immediatly assumed he had just thrown a tantrum and that he was just talking straight from his ring piece! I did find interesting though how many people must have believed him and voted for him straight away. I find this far more suspicious than what Trick Pony actually said. Seemed a fair few were quite quick and happy to vote him when it seemed obvious he was lying.

I find this a bit confusing Mike....you say...you immediately assumed TP was throwing a fit....okay...that was obvious.

You then say that people believed him? Believed him how? I've just reread who exactly posted a vote for him AFTER that stunt...and never did anyone vote for him for the content of what he said...but his intent...and if you need a reminder that his intentions were not to shed light on the game or just throw a fit...it was to intentionally RUIN the GAME!

miasg votes for him and ask him why he would do that?...meaning..say Fkit and roleclaim....miasg didn't question whether he was telling the truth...he could tell in his tone his intentions of ruining the game.

stevenryals asks TCH if he can be removed from the game for just doing something intentional that could just ruin the game....not assuming he was telling the truth...just his attempt to do so..

then what is the response of TP?

HE DID IT TO INTENTIONALLY RUIN THE GAME!

That's why people voted for him. His attitude towards the game not the fact that anyone actually believed anything that came out of his trap....he always explodes in almost every game...and if you go back and read you will see I even predicted that he would!

However, this post from you makes me think you are stretching a bit to point some kind of issue towards people that thought TP was an idiot...sorry I think if that is a position to use in this particular game of guilt...we might as well stop now.

[bluestarsneyes]

and how do we know TP didnt guess correctly that at least one of you lot was indeed mafia? so in real terms it may not be 100% bullshit. I for one am not assuming any of you are town despite it being obvious TP was being a malicious idiot. so dont be expecting a free ride like you are quite obviously trying to angle..

I for one am not asking for anyone to assume anything. I however happen to think that if people can't make out why he put me on that list...then you probably wanted to vote for me anyhows.

I called TP out for talking so much smack and doing his whole routine of dishing it out to Miasg and then disappearing....I sware it's just annoying...what it does...and this is old hat said it before in other games...even if TP is innocent in games...it's hard to defend him if he simply strikes out in his first post that miasg is guitly....it's just stupid. I mean...give him hell if you want...but then there are normally more than one mafia in a game...even if Miasg is suspect by TP...he refuses to question anyone else...EXCEPT those that question him going against Miasg.

Whatever...I'm done talking about TP

[bluestarsneyes]

Actually if my vote has to be on anyone...and I simply base it off of content posted by that player in this game...I'd have to FOS Sir Hammer....I still never got any responses to my original questions to him...and since he seems to have fallen off the radar a bit. The entire Spartacus and voting for SVH over that...seemed so weird...I can't shake the feeling that it has been obvious something wasn't right in that post...or some kind of message.

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

Well only 4 votes cast

MikeBlue has 2 Votes
BBM       has 1 Vote
Wes       has 1 Vote

The people who have voted are FBN, Hippo, Laser and Wes

The deadline is Midnight Monday UK time so not too much longer to make decisions if no one receives 9 votes which looks highly unlikely at this stage.

[laserblue]

TCH I did vote .. for Wes .. remember .. he winged like a bitch about it.

anyway I'm thinking of changing it to Mike ... that bit about needing a break from the game sounded a bit defeatist, like he was already resigned to his fate?
hey Mophead were are you

[stevenryals]

laser, it says "people who HAVE voted" not the opposite..

so ive read through.. and i'm sticking with Vote Mikeblue...  cant see anyone more suspicious as he..  I'll be on tomorrow & monday, so my mind could still change... 

[wesmancity]

TCH I did vote .. for Wes .. remember .. he winged like a bitch about it.

anyway I'm thinking of changing it to Mike ... that bit about needing a break from the game sounded a bit defeatist, like he was already resigned to his fate?
hey Mophead were are you

stop being a bitch yourself keep it on me!!

and TCH i have voted pal if you look.

[Steve Van Halen]

Actually if my vote has to be on anyone...and I simply base it off of content posted by that player in this game...I'd have to FOS Sir Hammer....I still never got any responses to my original questions to him...and since he seems to have fallen off the radar a bit. The entire Spartacus and voting for SVH over that...seemed so weird...I can't shake the feeling that it has been obvious something wasn't right in that post...or some kind of message.

The whole 'I am Spartacus' thing is from festivals in the UK. Around the campsite someone will shout 'I am Spartacus' and someone else will shout 'I am Spartacus and so is my wife'. This started at Reading in the late 90s, early 00's which spawned tshirts bearing the slogan.

The only message I got from Der Hammer is that hes probably been to the Reading Festival. I go every year

[MIASG]

and how do we know TP didnt guess correctly that at least one of you lot was indeed mafia? so in real terms it may not be 100% bullshit. I for one am not assuming any of you are town despite it being obvious TP was being a malicious idiot. so dont be expecting a free ride like you are quite obviously trying to angle..

exactly I'm not disagreeing this point what I'm saying is his whole post was and is complete crap .. I can honestly say I don't know what TP/MH , FN, and BS are and they couldn't know me .. and as always it's your choice to who you belive and don't

Mike, you didn't post friday, or monday or wednesday (or saturday or sunday, but i don't count that for you). I know for a fact you were on this site on friday frequently, because i was too - that's not to say you were posting on other topics, i just know you were here via seeing your name at the bottom. If you've been unable to post on all of those days (1 in 6), you really should have told someone, otherwise everyone's just gonna assume you're hiding. Especially given how much suspicion you'd accumulated immediately before your disappearance.

same question to you hippo as I asked wes - what's your criteria for contribution?  post for the sake of posting? or only add if you have something.  Me I don't like to read and not comment about something - I don't feel I'm truely participating if I'm not posting.


I'm unsure of who my vote may fall upon  ..

actually TCH can you please post who is exactly playing ?  I'm sure I'm bound to miss someone in my thinking

and while I'm sure the spartacus stuff happens in reading I'd say it happened first in the movie of the same name lol 

[Steve Van Halen]

i bet it did but Der hammer is no kirk douglas!

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

Well 6 votes now cast

MikeBlue has 4 Votes
BBM       has 1 Vote
Wes       has 1 Vote

The people who have voted are FBN, Hippo, Laser, StevenR, SVH and Wes

The deadline is Midnight Monday UK time so not too much longer to make decisions if no one receives 9 votes which looks highly unlikely at this stage.

The current player list is

Amadjin
Axeman
BBM
Bluestars
Currieman
FootballNewb
Hammerbro
Hippo
LaserBlue
Miasg
MikeBlue
Mophead
Sir Hammer
Stevenryals
SVH
Wesmancity
Yorkshire Blue

[MIASG]

well mike since you don't play weekends you'd better start some convincing posts .. they only person who shuoldn't be posting is hammerbro becuase he said he was off to disneyland .. everyone else has no excuse .. I'd still like to see more posts and thoughts from Amadjin,  BBM, Currieman, FootballNewb,  Mophead, and Yorkshire Blue to name those who I think aren't participating enough for my liking although it would be hard for mophead to come in so late ..

[Sir Villain]

The whole 'I am Spartacus' thing is from festivals in the UK. Around the campsite someone will shout 'I am Spartacus' and someone else will shout 'I am Spartacus and so is my wife'. This started at Reading in the late 90s, early 00's which spawned tshirts bearing the slogan.

The only message I got from Der Hammer is that hes probably been to the Reading Festival. I go every year

Plus it's a world famous reference to a movie legend.


The Trick Pony thing seems best ignored since his list of accompliances is clearly his personal wishlist, although we should rule out that he is mafia, and just trying to cause misdirection.

That said Mikeblue is clearly the best bet for a lynch, if we are to be rushed into a lynch so early...therefore Vote:Mikeblue

[Mikeblue]

I have some information to share and I'm only going to say this once. I was hoping to not have to, but hey looks like every one is happy to lynch me yet again when I have a decent role. So cheers for mucking that up again. Someone better give me some help tonight.

I was allowed an investigation before the day started. I chose to investigate BBM as I thought with him being new to the game and rather eratic in general it would be difficult to figure him out. He cam back as "not with you"

[Mikeblue]

UNVOTE STEVEN RYALLS VOTE BBM

Even though I still think you are dodgy as Steve.

I wasn't going to go after BBM and try and get another investigation in, but looks like thats up the swanny now.

[froganomis]

your claiming?how can we be certain your right?have u got any other information?

[Mikeblue]

What you mean how can I be certain? I investigated and got a "not with you back"

I am allowed to investigate "every other night" and had a pre game investigation.

[MIASG]

The Trick Pony thing seems best ignored since his list of accompliances is clearly his personal wishlist, although we should rule out that he is mafia, and just trying to cause misdirection.

WTF ?? no we can't he hasn't claimed anything proven so you can't rule it out  FOS Sir Villian

[MIASG]

sounds desperate Mike but you are at that stage aren't you .. there are better targets to pick if you are mafia and trying to get a townie or 2 before your off ... therefore I'm inclined to believe you - for now .. your either townie or an evil genius .. VOTE BBM

[Mikeblue]

I'm on 5 votes and looking like going to my grave....what you want me to do take the info with me? Either way you believe me or not. If I'm lying then you have lynched a mafia member in me (which you won't have done) or you lynch BBM he turns out to be innocent then you lynch me? Its win win really but I would rather keep the power role in play.