Mafia 17 - Harry Potter Game *Mafia Win*

[MIASG]

and no i'm not claiming or counter claiming to be sirius black, the 3-headed dog, or the other character I thought he was referencing too.

[Steve Van Halen]

then I definitely need to ask my girlfriend about it! wasnt it sirius blacks friend who was a werewolf?

why have I still got a vote for the Spartacus incident?!

Amadjin considering you have been missing for nearly a week why ask about my whereabouts?

[laserblue]

Never read the book or seen the film so who's "sirius black"

[froganomis]

Amadjin considering you have been missing for nearly a week why ask about my whereabouts?

your first post states you werent going to disappear,and then you hardly show up,like usual.
i didnt even realise i had signed up,which iv already said...

and no i'm not claiming or counter claiming to be sirius black, the 3-headed dog, or the other character I thought he was referencing too.

when did that come into the equation?

Never read the book or seen the film so who's "sirius black"

a guy who can basically transform into a dog,protrayed as evil but is actually good

[hippo]

a guy who can basically transform into a dog,protrayed as evil but is actually good

Probably something to bare in mind for any investigator then.

[bluestarsneyes]

Watching those trying to railroad Hippo into a bandwagon intently...

I find your posting in this game just really bizarre....I think it was typical Hippo that started the questioning which led to people questioning him back....typical for getting the game rolling....however what I find interesting is that you consider Hippo being the one bandwaggoned when I think it's obvious Mikeblue and BBM were leading in the votes?


Something is at work here....not exactly sure what.

[Happy Axeman]

UNVOTE MIKEBLUE (for now) he didnt come after me all defensive when i thought he would, maybe he is playing a different game this time? not sure but I'll retract the vote for now as he has gone quiet.

I think the hippo comment about pre-game talking was blown out of proportion, and twisted in a way to try to make hippo slip up. I cant really see if he has, but is a clever player so i wouldnt rule him out of the equation for being mafia. But the way Wes was trying to pin stuff on him(along with StevenRyals) I kinda guess they thought they had an easy target for the lynch on the grounds of cheating...

BlueBloodedManiac is posting really weird shit, but he has never played this game before so is probably mega confused as to what is going on. lol Its hard to judge but I dont think we should hang someone who is playing there first game just yet, we should just see what develops and if he has an evil role, will probably hang himself in his confusion anyway. lol
wes seems intent on hanging the new boy without letting the guy get a feel for the game, yet wes was in the same situation not so long ago too...

Steve whats your take on the hippo and yorkshire blue thing, did you not find it odd him saying them things?

Wes also seems to be fishing for allies with stevenryals, why would he assume Steve is innocent, or are they part of the same team and wes is looking for input from his teammate? although Steve then starts on Wes... and then retracts?

So for me at the moment, I see too many things which wes constantly appears to be at the centre of the shit stirring... although i guess that is the point of the game, but the way he goes about it is a bit dodgy.
so VOTE WESMANCITY and i'll see how that develops. lol

and no i'm not claiming or counter claiming to be sirius black, the 3-headed dog, or the other character I thought he was referencing too.

Like Amadjin asked, where did that come from?

I dont bother with FOS's as there pointless...

FOS STEVERYALS, FOS HIPPO, FOS MIKEBLUE, FOS BLUESTARS, FOS TRICKPONY, FOS HAMMERBRO, FOS LASERBLUE, FOS YORKIE, FOS MIASG, FOS BBM, FOS FOOTYNEWB, FOS VILLAIN, FOS AMADJIN, FOS SVH, FOS CURRIEMAN, FOS TCH!

[wesmancity]

wes seems intent on hanging the new boy without letting the guy get a feel for the game, yet wes was in the same situation not so long ago too...
Wes also seems to be fishing for allies with stevenryals, why would he assume Steve is innocent, or are they part of the same team and wes is looking for input from his teammate? although Steve then starts on Wes... and then retracts?

As what you said in bold.

I have played this game 4/5 times now, if Steve was a "team mate" as you put it why would i make it so obvious?

[MIASG]

when did that come into the equation?

I figured since I thought he was referring to the werewolf character and not sirius black people might assume or confuse that with me counter claiming .. just putting it out there before the confusion.

I have played this game 4/5 times now, if Steve was a "team mate" as you put it why would i make it so obvious?

Wes - One could argue that you are not on the same team but you might know that steven is in fact good and your alligning yourself with a town player who more often then not is elliminated before day 2 ... or simply you both have silimar views/opinions so far in the game .. everythings specualtion at this point and most people make giant assumptions

[hippo]

The main suspicious thing to have happened in this game is, quite simply, the activity of Mikeblue..

Came out fairly aggressively for him, active, with a couple of FOS's towards people for various things. I mentioned him briefly in a post along with a few others for some very minor things, he got quite angry, i explained stuff, he got angrier and voted. Stevenryals then questioned stuff that he'd said, and mike explodes at him too, accuses steven of not posting (despite being the clear post leader from the first page onwards), and votes for him too. Hammerbro voted for him, Currie queried what he was on about, Axeman also disagreed with him, Trick Pony expressed suspicion, as did Hammer. What did Mike do to counter this suspicion?

Mike disappeared.

Completely.

His last post was on page 5. Considering he posted 19 times up until that, this represents a conscious disappearance to avoid incriminating himself any further. Townies don't do this. People with something to hide do.

Unvote Currie
Vote Mikeblue

[laserblue]

sorry I've not been very productive so far I'm full off flu & feel shit & havent played for a bit ......

I don't think footynewb has been back on since I asked him what was so suspicious about Wes saying that mafia communicate at night... like I said everybody knows that & it just seemed like you were just putting something down to make it look like youv'e posted.

Hippo I can see what your saying but I think mike has done this before & not been guilty ... what do you have to say Mike ... hiding or not?

[stevenryals]

I agree with hippo here..  My vote is on Mikeblue and has been..  I think that he's been by far the most dodgy up to this point..  adn the fact that he's went AWOL since he was put under pressure...  speaks volumes.   

I mean, Mike is the guy who's on here every day posting replies to my replies...  you have to know he has internet access at work..  since he's on during the day ALL day long lol..  just like me..  but now he's gone adn hasn't come back..  frustration maybe? or trying to drop off the radar..

the only thing that makes me NOT want to lynch mikeblue is...    we are going to do the same thing as always..  lynch a big poster..  then kill another big poster or 2 at night.. then lynch another big poster and on and on..  and it's going to end up being another one of those games where the last month of it is 1 or 2 posts per day....  so..  I'd like to get a mafia member, but I'd also like to not f*** up and get rid of a good poster who's just slipped up..

Ive mentioned the psychological implications of his "I" post before..  that alone really isn't enough to lynch someone..  I feel like his subsequent responses to pressure, and now his disappearance says more than that...   

[stevenryals]

I agree with what Axeman said about wes to a certain extent..  it seemed like instead of him looking for an ally, he was looking for backup for his statement about hippo..  at the time I was prodding about trying to make hippo slip so i wasn't paying too much attention to wes to be honest... but i see your point..

[stevenryals]

not much going on today.....   

[MIASG]

not much going on today.....   

maybe the problem is that no one wants to post as the the posters get attacked for anything .. so maybe look at the quieter ones

this represents a conscious disappearance to avoid incriminating himself any further. Townies don't do this. People with something to hide do.

same could be said for TP who has disappeared since the Tiny Penis episode .. he usually has something to say but seems to be hiding .. knowing him like I do he will respond to me ..  so whatever gets you out and contributing little fella ..

@footynewb - I agree with laser .. nothing from you either - if you got nothing to say then I'd rather hear that in a post then assume your not around


BMM has also disappeared from his early barrage of posts .. I don't think a lack of saying anything is his problem. 

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

well quiet or not the deadline for Day one is moving closer, just a little over 4 days until we hit the night phase. Midnight Friday UK time is the deadline.

The current votes are

MikeBlue    2 Votes
Wes           2 Votes
BBM          1 Vote
Sir Villian    1 Vote
Stevenryals 1 Vote
SVH           1 Vote

People yet to vote, Amadjin, Bluestars, Footynewb, Laserblue, miasg, Sir Villian, SVH, TP and Yorkshire

9 votes will cause a lynch

[MIASG]

On a lighter note ...

I agree with hippo here..  etc etc

congratulations StevenRyals I believe that's your 7000th post 

[MIASG]

sorry I jumped the gun your on 6999 .. it's the next post ..  (gee it's a slow day isn't it)

[Dickens Cider]

I don't think footynewb has been back on since I asked him what was so suspicious about Wes saying that mafia communicate at night... like I said everybody knows that & it just seemed like you were just putting something down to make it look like youv'e posted.

It wasn't the fact that he said that, it was that he was so sure of the rules being that they could ONLY communicate during night phases. If you had read the argument I was referring to, you would have seen they were disputing if mafia could or couldnt communicate in the moments leading up to the start of the game. Hippo assuming they could (as he had been mafia in a game modded by someone else and was apparently allowed to do so) and Wes was so certain they couldn't...
Now Wes had not been mafia (in a TCH game) since the X-Men game... which was quite sometime ago... So to me, it seemed strange that he could be so sure of the Mafia rules (IN THIS GAME) and use it as a case against Hippo and anyone trying to defend Hippo... The only way i could see that he could be THAT sure... is he had very recently recieved a reminder of the Mafia rules....

I've never been Mafia, so have no idea what the PM to Mafia folk says... But I can only assume it outlines what they can and cant do...
and with that info fresh in wes's mind... he was able to be so sure about his attack on hippo and the others who questioned him...

Quite simple if you think about it...
But it seems as though you completely skimmed the argument/discussion leading up to my post...
Leading to you taking it completely out of context...

We all know thread skimming is a clear cut Mafia trait... flu ridden or not 

[bluestarsneyes]

sorry it has taken me so long to log in today...I've been dealing with some work drama....that's what you get when you do the payroll..someone's always biotching!

anyway....look I have a feeling mikeblue has to have lost internet or gone out of town....he is usually the only person on this site daily..lol!

If not...then he'd have to go to the tops of my list as well...because it would also fit him that he loves these games and to get all that pressure on day one...if he was evil...I could see him saying fkit and just bailing out for a few days to cool off...he's done that as well in other games...he'll be very active then disappear...not that other games should be used as evidence...but heck we've been playing them so many times it's hard not to take into account posting personalities in other games.

Honestly...what in the past has done a good job of sorting out mafia is to kind of talk about the game itself...that being said...I am going to have to look over the characters again...because it has been awhile since I've seen one of the movies and can't remember these character names off of the top of my head...someone's now posting while I'm posting...so if I can I'll post now and try to respond if I can