Mafia 17 - Harry Potter Game *Mafia Win*

[stevenryals]

Simply thats the rules every time you get a role it states you can only communicate during the night phase. Thats it steve.

What?

The mafia and masons or whoever are ALWAYS allowed to talk between receiving roles and the game starting aren't they? I did for the 3 games previous to this anyway.. if that was against the rules, i apologise.

VERY INTERESTING DEVELOPMENT.

[wesmancity]

VERY INTERESTING DEVELOPMENT.

lol, you really are funny

[stevenryals]

Simply thats the rules every time you get a role it states you can only communicate during the night phase. Thats it steve.

lol, you really are funny

What's funny is that my role said nothing about any communication during the night phase..  but you claim every time you get a role it states you can only communicate during the night phase.... 

[hippo]

Why was my bit interesting then?

[wesmancity]

What's funny is that my role said nothing about any communication during the night phase..  but you claim every time you get a role it states you can only communicate during the night phase.... 

No the fact you see nothing in what i have been saying about Hippo, but you are clutching at straws on me, you my friend are funny.

[stevenryals]

if yorkshireblue posts retarded short one liners that make no sense, that's not suspicious... but if people vote for him claiming that his posts are suspicious..  is that suspicious?

did I just tell yorkshire to keep posting retarded short one liners that make no sense? 

I dont understand the ground your basing your argument on.. 

however, I do believe that you have discovered a chink in Hippos armour with the "I'd have told him before the game" bit..  seems like a major slip..  but your other argument to me, is unfounded..

[hippo]

however, I do believe that you have discovered a chink in Hippos armour with the "I'd have told him before the game" bit..  seems like a major slip..  but your other argument to me, is unfounded..

Genuinely baffled.

I would have discussed tactics before the game if i was mafia. I know this. Other people know this. Not because it happened in this game (it didn't), but because it happened in the 3 games before this. I know it's hard to believe, but i'm pro-town this time.

[stevenryals]

Genuinely baffled.

I would have discussed tactics before the game if i was mafia. I know this. Other people know this. Not because it happened in this game (it didn't), but because it happened in the 3 games before this. I know it's hard to believe, but i'm pro-town this time.

You're either mafia or you will now have an * next to any records you set in Mafia stating how you blatantly cheated and spoke with your fellows before the game started  lol 


I simply found it interesting that you and wes both stated basically the same thing, and your reason for saying so were completely opposite..  wes saying "every time you get a role it states you can only communicate during the night phase" and you saying "are ALWAYS allowed to talk between receiving roles and the game starting"... at the very least you have to say that is an interesting fact.

I've not been mafia enough to know the rules for each moderator, but considering there is such a drastic difference in opinion here... it's possible, and I'm fairly certain of it, that one of the two of you received a role that stated something to the effect of the above comments.

TCH hasn't modded in a while, so rules may have change for this game as opposed to the previous few.  So, that may be what's caused the confusion with one of the two of you.

[yorkshire blue]

hippo you best go back and read some of the mafia games there was only the last one where i didnt post alot
when you dont get much chance to post and then theres 5 pages to read its not easy

[hippo]

Sorry, Yorkie.

[stevenryals]

After looking back:  I'm going to retract my argument against Wes & Hippo with their inconsistencies..
I could definately be wrong, but here's why:

last 3 mods:  Hammerbro, Currieman, & Villian
Wes was never evil in any of those 3 games, so he would still be going by TCH's past rules since the last time he was evil was a TCH game I think (not completely sure about that, focused mostly on the past 3 games)
Hippo was evil in 2 of the last 3 games modded by others.  So it seems hippo may have been going by rules of Hammerbro/Currieman/Villian, while Wes was going by rules from previous TCH modded games..  which in my opinion, nullifies my point..  

I was really hoping that Wes had been evil in one of the last 3 games so as to diminish his excuse.... but he was not..  and that really screws my argument..  

So for now... a simple FOS for both of them based on an uneasy feeling.

[stevenryals]

when you dont get much chance to post and then theres 5 pages to read its not easy

we can all agree with that..  just wait until Laserblue gets on here  lol... 

[i2i Killer 89]

What's funny is that my role said nothing about any communication during the night phase

Not sure if I've got this in the right way but here it looks to me like you're basically saying that you were told you can't communicate at all during the night phase.

I believe that you're telling the truth with this statement making me think that you probably aren't mafia or a mason or any other role that can communicate at night.

Also Steve, I think you over-analysed what Hippo and TP were saying a little bit.

[stevenryals]

Also Steve, I think you over-analysed what Hippo and TP were saying a little bit.

that's the name of the game isn't it?

[i2i Killer 89]

I thought the game was called Mafia?

[stevenryals]

I thought the game was called Mafia?

[Blue Blooded Maniac]

Vote wesmancity.

simply cos hes askin a hell of alot of questions. its ok askin questions i suppose. but maybe hes makin a sharade and askin for the sake of askin so it makes him look innocent.

[stevenryals]

 

[wesmancity]

Vote wesmancity.

simply cos hes askin a hell of alot of questions. its ok askin questions i suppose. but maybe hes makin a sharade and askin for the sake of askin so it makes him look innocent.

PMSL!!! yeah hang me

[Blue Blooded Maniac]

WILL DO!