Mafia 17 - Harry Potter Game *Mafia Win*

[Quig]

Woof.

Vote: Mikeblue
I swear he never makes this much sense and posts this much that isn't random shit.

[Sir Villain]

Possibly something there Hippo, I dont think Mike has ever been mafia, hes possibly who im looking for.. it will be interesting to see if he changes his style now.

That actually might make alot of sense,

Unvote:SVH, FOS:Mike

[wesmancity]

Hi Wes,

Why did you take it as me telling YB to play the game he normally plays, and not me telling Stevenryals or Trick Pony the same thing? The bit you quoted said the same for each of those people as well, after all. So why leave them out?

I'd have probably just given out that advice in the pre-game bit though, if i was mafia, rather than waiting until everyone else was watching? Would make more sense wouldn't it?

Hello Hippo,

The reason for it Hippo was this, Why would you give Yorkshire Blue any advise on how to play the game if you are not on the same side as him?. For instance why would you say and Ill quote you

You need to pick up on players indvidual styles to acknowledge what is and isn't suspicious - if Stevenryals posts alot, that's not suspicious; if YB posts alot, that is. If i post some bizarre crap that makes no sense, that's suspicious; if TP does it, that's normal. He can't be the "most suspicious" in your eyes, if he's doing nothing different. It makes no sense.

If you look at it from my point of view, It looks like you are sending a message to Yorkshire Blue without  direct contact with him and also you only name him by using his initials e.g. YB, which doesn’t really draw too much attention to him. When you said the same to Stevenrynals you used his full name and you could of just said Steve.

The reason I never mentioned Steverynals or Trickpony is because they do normally start the game this way and it is normal for them to be asking questions about everyone, but Yorkshire Blue is different; he has already posted so soon as the game started with

tp dont go after miasg all the time he was probably only oking
tp is looking sus but he always does

And this was on the first page! He posted this at 2:14 yesterday and then at 3:55 you posted that statement to tell people don’t post any different than you normally would.

All Im trying to do Hippo is trying to find stuff out, no offence pal. 

[Mikeblue]

grasping at straws mike??..  if you really believed that you would think about your chances at really finding mafia.  and you said, it's either a bandwagon or i'm following "my leader"...   

wouldn't you rather get "my leader" if you truely believed i was mafia? wouldn't you figure if it's 50/50 to go for the one that you've identifed in this post as the 'leader'??

yes you would..  you're not thick...  you'd rather get the head honcho...

but you know I'm not mafia because in your PM from TCH the mafia were listed for you to see, with your name in there somewhere, and you know that you've not found anything really to go after hippo yet.. so you went for me instead..

I based it on the fact that you are either trying to start a bandwagon or following your leader. Hippo could be town and you are trying to create something or he may be the godfather and you are following him. I do think however that you are not stupid enough to do this so early so I am going with the bandwagon theory. Either way I think you are evil!

[Mikeblue]

yes i agree, and i was thinking the same as bluestars although TP could also mean 'Town Prohibitor', 'Testing Patience', 'Tripe Poster', 'Turd Pusher', 'Trickly Poo',  or perhaps 'Tiny Penis'    lol Soz TP, no offence meant, i got carried away. lol

MikeBlue does tend to be a bit paranoid, but then he always does when someone even mentions his name.
but surely he cant be Pro Town yet again? how many games would that be? law of averages say he must be evil at some point?
my initial thoughts on him are that he is being rather defensive so early in the game when its all about mud slinging just to get the game moving. Hippo has barrely stuck his teeth in him and he is really getting his back up.
*Axeman gets ready for the defensive abuse cause ive just mentioned him!*

I've said this almost every game, but someone who is mafia always makes a mistake in there first few posts, wether it is just banter with another evil member, or they make a blunder with there subconsious... how StevenRyals picks up on stuff is quite genius, and he picked up on what could be a mistake by MikeBlue.

then again, I really am thinking Toilet Paper has made a blatent diversion by mentioning Lord Voldemort in his first post.. but surely he is not that daft?

I dont usually use Fos's as they are pretty pointless, so I'm gonna VOTE MIKEBLUE to see what develops.

WTF?!?!?!?

Are you that blind? Have you read all the posts? I was trying to dig a little about Hippo and the pair just blatently tag teamed me? Can you not see how sus it was the way Steve jumped in to Hippos rescue when I started asking questions?

[hippo]

Wes:

The one post of YB's you quoted seems pretty much like a standard post of his to me?

The reason i mentioned the people i chose to use in my example is because Stevenryals always posts the most, Yorkshire always posts the least, Myself because i wanted to big myself up, and Trick Pony because the whole point i was making was centred around him.

Good effort trying to actually find stuff out though, some other people should take note. You're not right in this case, but i can see what you're saying.

[wesmancity]

Wes:

The one post of YB's you quoted seems pretty much like a standard post of his to me?

The reason i mentioned the people i chose to use in my example is because Stevenryals always posts the most, Yorkshire always posts the least, Myself because i wanted to big myself up, and Trick Pony because the whole point i was making was centred around him.

Good effort trying to actually find stuff out though, some other people should take note. You're not right in this case, but i can see what you're saying.

Cheers Hippo,

But you do give him two clear messages here the first one:

You need to pick up on players indvidual styles to acknowledge what is and isn't suspicious - if Stevenryals posts alot, that's not suspicious; if YB posts alot, that is.

So in my eyes you are telling YB not to post a lot, and on the second message in reference to Yorkshire Blue comment which is this:

tp dont go after miasg all the time he was probably only oking
tp is looking sus but he always does

You then say:

 if YB posts allot, that is. If i post some bizarre crap that makes no sense, that's suspicious;

So to me you are telling Yorkshire Blue not to post bizarre crap also as he looks suspicious.

[Steve Van Halen]

I dont like the idea of voting for someone as evil just because of the law of averages, its a bit too risky for my liking. What if hes evil in the next game?

[hippo]

Yorkshire is the least likely person i'd try to send a coded message to - he quite simply wouldn't read it. If i was in a mafia with him, i'd have told him to play his own game before the game started. He hadn't done anything out of the ordinary, so why would i feel the need to re-iterate this to him in the form of a code so early?

For the "bizarre crap" bit you've quoted, you've actually merged two halves of different sentences in order to try and create something new. That's pretty manipulative?

[wesmancity]

Yorkshire is the least likely person i'd try to send a coded message to - he quite simply wouldn't read it. If i was in a mafia with him, i'd have told him to play his own game before the game started.

I didnt think that was aloud!

For the "bizarre crap" bit you've quoted, you've actually merged two halves of different sentences in order to try and create something new. That's pretty manipulative?

thats a fair point, but as i said i am trying to piece things together and ATM you stood out to me, but i have said what i have said now and i will put it to bed and see if anyone else thinks there is a need to comment.

[bluestarsneyes]

Tops of my list at the moment are a pick between drivel v truly bizzarre drivel.

1) SirHammer....comes on long enough to say he's Spartacus...then when SVH claims he's Spartacus and his wife...SH mentions there can only be THREE Spartacus's.....now if my math is right at that moment there were only three claims at Spartacus....so his apparant bad math smacks of something....he is a very calculated player....and well...FOS SIRHAMMER...although I'm very inclined to vote...we'll see what kind of  dead language he can muster up to respond.

2) Blue Blooded Maniac or Monkey or whatever....you have to be evil or some kind of nuts. First post meaningless drivel...fine...get a pass...then someone questions your post...and the only response you give is that you understand the game...okay...so you verify you know what's going on....then someone votes for Hippo and the exact next post from you is "DUNTDDDDUUUNNNTT"....I'm American so maybe I'm confused but doesn't that mean Don't? What are you referencing? What the hell are you even on about...or is that the point...you are some kind of Towny Psycho? Either way....FOS BLUE BLOODED WHATEVER.

We have other players TCH mentioned that haven't posted yet....even though I'd normally assume mafia have at least posted once so far in the game....we've had a case previously where mafia came in late....so...that being said...I'll withhold an actual vote at this moment until we get all the players posting.

[bluestarsneyes]

Vote:Steve Van Halen

There can not be 3 Spartacus's

Sorry didn't quite make that clear now on point about SH...he votes SVH based on the fact there can only be 3....SH, SVH, SVH Ball and chain=3....so why kill SVH when they make 3...unless a hidden message? Or complete drivel?

[stevenryals]

Yorkshire is the least likely person i'd try to send a coded message to - he quite simply wouldn't read it. If i was in a mafia with him, i'd have told him to play his own game before the game started.

I didnt think that was aloud!

Wes, that's an EXCELLENT point..

Hippo may have made a mistake here.  Its up to the moderator to tell the mafia when they are allowed to begin speaking with each other.  Hippo here, makes an insinuation that he knows the mafia could communicate before the first night phase.   

FOS Hippo

[stevenryals]

Wait a second..

Wes, why did you not think that was allowed?  It's clearly up to the mod when people can use their roles!

FOS Wesmancity

you said "I didn't think that was allowed"...  which has the same effect on me as what hippo has said.. 

I'd say one of you are mafia who has made a mistake.. 

[hippo]

I'm almost certain Hammer's not Spartacus, Bluestars.

[stevenryals]

next post from you is "DUNTDDDDUUUNNNTT"....I'm American so maybe I'm confused but doesn't that mean Don't?

the sound of "The Plot Thickens"   Da Da Da...  with a "uh" kinda sound there..  not "Don't Don't Don't"  lol...  how the hell did you not get that.. 

[wesmancity]

Wait a second..

Wes, why did you not think that was allowed?  It's clearly up to the mod when people can use their roles!

FOS Wesmancity

you said "I didn't think that was allowed"...  which has the same effect on me as what hippo has said.. 

I'd say one of you are mafia who has made a mistake.. 

Simply thats the rules every time you get a role it states you can only communicate during the night phase. Thats it steve.

[hippo]

I didnt think that was aloud!


Wes, that's an EXCELLENT point..

Hippo may have made a mistake here.  Its up to the moderator to tell the mafia when they are allowed to begin speaking with each other.  Hippo here, makes an insinuation that he knows the mafia could communicate before the first night phase.   

FOS Hippo

What?

The mafia and masons or whoever are ALWAYS allowed to talk between receiving roles and the game starting aren't they? I did for the 3 games previous to this anyway.. if that was against the rules, i apologise.

[wesmancity]

Steve whats your take on the hippo and yorkshire blue thing, did you not find it odd him saying them things?

[stevenryals]

Steve whats your take on the hippo and yorkshire blue thing, did you not find it odd him saying them things?

not a bit, he said the same bit about me as well.