Mafia 15 - 24 - GAME OVER - TOWN WIN

[Sir Villain]

yes, but when one person has that power, and they call you out as sus.. you are forced into a response.. maybe that's what you are trying to avoid eh?   with one player is given that kind of authority, he can get better answers than all of us combined..

Although its true that one powerful voice gets more attention that a dozen-odd quieter ones, that doesnt mean its correct. I've got nothing to hide, but I see too much of a risk. The person he picks on is going to be forced to claim on the basis of one persons suspicions. That could led to another key role being outed on the first day...i.e the mafia will be laughing at us since they probably already have Jack Bauer out in the open.

[stevenryals]

what's your suggestion hammer? 30 pages of day one? 40??

[hippo]

Steve, i'm sure you're aware that MIASG has already voted for his prime suspect in YB. So what exactly are you discussing? If you want to go along with what MIASG says, do it. Vote. If you don't, you can hardly complain the day's lasting too long. A couple more votes, putting him close to a lynch, will also make him respond to questions - which used to be how the game was played?

Technically, i suppose i'm willing to go along with this "plan" to do as MIASG does, because we've already voted for the same person.

[i2i Killer 89]

Vote count
3 – YorkshireBlue (Mikeblue, Hippo, MiasG)
3 – Trick Pony (Bluestars, YorkshireBlue, Laserblue)
2 – Afroboy (TCH, Axeman)
1 – TCH (Hammerbro)
1 – Sir Hammer (Afroboy)
1 – Happy Axeman (StevenRyals)

It will take 8 votes to get a lynch

I may think about a deadline if nobody is lynched in the next few days as day 1 is nearly 2 weeks long and it seems to be going around in circles slightly. I would prefer a normal lynch though so will leave it for a few days before deciding on a deadline. Atleast people are posting though, you should all be able to reach a conclusion eventually

[wesmancity]

Looks like we are finally moving along a little more.

My vote is staying with Yorky for now but Afro and Wes are making me feel uncomfortbale aswell. Far too many pointless posts when they have bothered they have not inspired confidence.

This day is really starting to drag on. I have made my vote and it is staying so I will wait untill there is more voting from people and then we can progress. Day 1 is a nightmare and the sooner we can move along the better I feel.

The only two people I think are town at the moment are TP and Miasg. I have a feeling TCH may well be mafia though.

This alone put's you on my list of possible mafia, you have clearly read that other posters have come up with me posting nonsence post, and because you dont know what to say you thought of saying it aswell. You are really playing like mafia wondering what to say so you input by nicking some one elses thoughts

Vote Mikeblue

[wesmancity]

complete fluke..
she was in a training class all day with no access..  it shouldnt be sus if she's truly without access.. 
she's in the class again today for until 12:30, which is about 3 hours or so from now..

Can she not speak for her self?, ffs have i just asked you a question??

[wesmancity]

wes with his 'i give up' bit..

you said i was sus before that, so thats not a good enough for me. Please answer me and the rest of the town why i am a sus?? please we are all interested

[laserblue]

unvote TP I made that vote cause he is being annoying not because I really suspect him ....

I think that things have come to a better stage now ... things are becoming more clear peeps are taking sides now....

heres the peeps I strongley suspect & why & thiose I think could be innocent ...


Here goes....

Like I said out of the aussies I find TCH more suspicious

Reasons

I think he may of dropped a bollok in jumping in straight away & defending miasg from TP ... at that stage only the mafia would know who was not with them.. by jumping in & protecting Miasg TCH could be alighning himself to a townie

When miasg was saying his character was in every series it was TCH who pronounced him as JB to everyone

When he knew that going after the aussie was up he switched to Afroboy the youngest player on the board.


Axeman quiet at first then a flurry of activity latched on to tch vote for afro & his reasons for voting for him when challenged by hippo ... gut instinct please also his posting style so far is to much like last game when he was evil not not like when he is innocent.

I think afro is innocent .. ( I don't know this) but he is playing to much likehis normal style .. I played my first game with him & every game since , so I should be able to tell... he is always fairly quiet on the first day as usual & has been challenging people .. yes like hammer who a lot of peeps would shy away from at this stage

I also agree that yorks does not look particulaly mafia in this game once again yorks played his first when I did & everyone since.

This leads me to wonder about Mike blue he just seems to be carrying this yorkshire vendetta over from the last game when yorks has posted about & voted other people ... yes yorks style always makes him a target but he is infact getting more involved in this game when he's evil he refuses to enter the game

Hamer I'm not sure about... again like axeman hardly posted on first few actual days .... he started of by indirectly bigging himself up .. remember I don''t see why peeps think I so good.. or words to that effect, then in his later posts says how he finds it sus when people blow there own trumpet .. so which is it ? he also had an fos for afro is this a coincidence that he & the other people who I suspect most strongley all pick on the same player? maybe ? or maybe not?

other peeps who look innocent at this stage anyway are ..

miasg, steve, hippo 

don't knows

Tp may not be evil as he is running around like a madman attracting attention to himself?

Bluestars her first few posts seemed back to her oldsytle .... innocent?

wes .. just don't know

masterzulu it's impossible as he hasn't posted enough .. 2 posts I think.. & I don't know his style as this is only his second game .... it could be he is not posted because he is scared of giving himself away ... IF YOUR TOWN YOU NEED TO GET ON THE BOARD ACTUALLY SAY SOMETHING so you can be eliminated from the list

Hammerbro .. don't know?

if I've miised anybody sorry I'll get back to it but I'm of to pick up a take-away now

If I am wrong about anybody I suspect please come on & tell me why I don't want to vote for someone that's not evil.


someones posted since i started but my wife is shouting at me to pick up the take away so I'll read them later.

[stevenryals]

you said i was sus before that, so thats not a good enough for me. Please answer me and the rest of the town why i am a sus?? please we are all interested

It's all within this thread... search and ye shall find.  I'm not into repeating myself for those who dont read every post.

Can she not speak for her self?, ffs have i just asked you a question??

I'm positive that she can.. you're fishing pretty hard here wesley..  I dont think that NOT HAVING ACCESS allows one the opportunity to ACCESS the forum...  get the correlation there?  I think bluestars shouldnt be considered sus for not posting if she really has no access right?  maybe we should just lynch her and see, right wes?  yea.. she's most certainly evil because she's been in a training class for the new software that her job requires...  great detective work wes... well done..  lol 

any other questions?

[stevenryals]

Steve, i'm sure you're aware that MIASG has already voted for his prime suspect in YB. So what exactly are you discussing? If you want to go along with what MIASG says, do it. Vote. If you don't, you can hardly complain the day's lasting too long. A couple more votes, putting him close to a lynch, will also make him respond to questions - which used to be how the game was played?

Technically, i suppose i'm willing to go along with this "plan" to do as MIASG does, because we've already voted for the same person.

no hippo..  obviously it would be just him saying "lets lynch yorkshire"... it would be a common knowledge that MIASG has this backing, and his inquests would then be much more powerful..  everyone is pulling in different directions..  it's funny though how WES has posted quite a bit but not mentioned this idea... Hammer is opposed, but has his reasons.. wesley has completely ignored the fact that this is out there..  could be a hint as to what team he's playing for.....

[laserblue]

what about my post  say something comment on it

[stevenryals]

I also agree that yorks does not look particulaly mafia in this game once again yorks played his first when I did & everyone since.

This leads me to wonder about Mike blue he just seems to be carrying this yorkshire vendetta over from the last game when yorks has posted about & voted other people ... yes yorks style always makes him a target but he is infact getting more involved in this game when he's evil he refuses to enter the game

ok laser ok.. geeeezzz...

I think Yorkshireblue looks as sus as usual..  the fact is he's playing different than HE EVER HAS BEFORE.. not just when he's evil.. but different from his play style from ALL previous games..  he's more involved... is it because he's got a great role?  who knows.. but I find him sus..

mikeblue..  not sure about what you're saying here.. but i see why we differe because you dont find Yorkshire sus and i do..  so..  I guess that settles that eh....

Axeman quiet at first then a flurry of activity latched on to tch vote for afro & his reasons for voting for him when challenged by hippo ... gut instinct please also his posting style so far is to much like last game when he was evil not not like when he is innocent.

Hamer I'm not sure about... again like axeman hardly posted on first few actual days .... he started of by indirectly bigging himself up .. remember I don''t see why peeps think I so good.. or words to that effect, then in his later posts says how he finds it sus when people blow there own trumpet .. so which is it ? he also had an fos for afro is this a coincidence that he & the other people who I suspect most strongley all pick on the same player? maybe ? or maybe not?

This may be a better pick than you expected it to be..   I'm talking about the comparrison between the two players..  they are playing similarly... and have largely stayed completely out of each others way..  hammer seems to just be in a "response" mode.. where he answers things that are directed at him... while axeman is the same with the added dynamic of posting random gut feeling votes....

[laserblue]

ok thankyou .... anybody else 

I hear what your saying about yorky slightly different style seems to me he's a least trying to get more involved sometimes misguided but on the whole leaning towards town I'd say.. but certainly not the most sus pect player on the board & not the most dangerous... it's those players we need to pick out?

like I said I welome any input on this (even from TP )

[laserblue]

oh about your idea steve

 Usually when someone comes out this early they tend to be telling the truth..

so so far the probability is that miasg is telling the truth

so yes your idea has merit but mafia can hide behind it, one of the things to go off on day two is who voted who?

also how do we know miasg will pick wisley (no offence miasg) cause already I have stated I don't think yb should be the first to go.

[stevenryals]

but certainly not the most sus pect player on the board & not the most dangerous... it's those players we need to pick out?

how do you know who's the most dangerous?

[stevenryals]

just an observation, but laser, you seem to be pointing out quite a bit about who you think is innocent..  more than anyone else that I can see..  just an observation..

[wesmancity]

It's all within this thread... search and ye shall find.  I'm not into repeating myself for those who dont read every post.


I'm positive that she can.. you're fishing pretty hard here wesley..  I dont think that NOT HAVING ACCESS allows one the opportunity to ACCESS the forum...  get the correlation there?  I think bluestars shouldnt be considered sus for not posting if she really has no access right?  maybe we should just lynch her and see, right wes?  yea.. she's most certainly evil because she's been in a training class for the new software that her job requires...  great detective work wes... well done..  lol 

any other questions?

pointless post if i ever read one zzzzzzzZZZZZZZZZZzz zzzzzzzz. And you call me.

[wesmancity]

  maybe we should just lynch her and see, right wes?  yea.. she's most certainly evil because she's been in a training class for the new software that her job requires...  great detective work wes... well done..  lol 

any other questions?

you really are protecting her, why is this? do you know her role? you seem to do. 

[laserblue]

i already said who I thought looked evil & would like some feedback on the post from other players ... I was merley debating the pros & cons of your idea

why I say that some players are more dangerous to the town & some not is that with his two to four liners yorks is hardly going to sway the voting of many people he has a style & sticks to it in the main part it makes it hard to see what side he is on  ... there are others you for instance , axeman hippo hammer maybe miasg & myself who post longer & try to effect the way the game is played thats what I'm saying I may be wrong but that's what I'm thinking

like I said I'm not dismising the idea straight off I thought a deadline of some sort was a good idea but can see a lot of holes in this plan it first glance.

[stevenryals]

pointless post if i ever read one zzzzzzzZZZZZZZZZZzz zzzzzzzz. And you call me.

IT WAS ENTIRELY POINTLESS...   had you read properly you would have never had to post it.. therefore I would have never had to respond..  

and why did you respond to the same post twice? makes no sense..  it's as if you didnt read the whole thing (big suprise) before responding..