Mafia 14 - The Good, The Bad and The Ugly Mafia: Game over-TOWN WIN!

[stevenryals]

and steve you yet again ignored what i'd said....if it wasnt for mophead playing an even looser game than you,you'd be top of my suspect list

what'd you say amadjin?  give me a link.. i read the last 7 pages or so this weekend with a hefty buzz... 

[hippo]

I'd just like to point out that:

a) amadjin did exactly the same as what mophead did
b) amadjin gave exactly the same defense to it, i.e. saying it was a joke
c) amadjin reckons the actions of mophead are clear signs of being mafia

I'll leave it with you all.

For the record, i suspect both of them pretty strongly. But you should already know that.

Oh, and Steven, you've also not responded to:

I see what you did there. You tried to bypass answering the point about how you were 100% on bluestars being evil at one point, and now you don't even mention her as a possible evil.

You were absolutely convinced, and went out on a full-on attack (with good reasons) at the start. She doesn't give a satisfactory response and tries quickly to rectify the problem by going back to her old style, which completely contradicted her "i'm too busy" stuff. And what? That's it? You've completely bought that? Why would you be so strong in your attacks to start with, and then completely abandon them when the votes start to actually matter towards the end of the day? To throw everyone off?

I think she's blatantly mafia. The only reason she doesn't have my vote is this thing i can't get over, whereby i'm certain that one of those 4 people who claimed mafia weren't lying. I know for certain i'd have been straight in there after a few people had done it, just to see if i could get away with it, if i'd been evil in this game. Maybe that's what you're doing? I'm certain it's what mophead was doing, and mike's attempt was probably the best disguised, but it still stunk of evil.

If you had something to say about it. It's alright if you don't. Not sure how you'd have missed it, considering you made the post directly after it, so i guess you were just trying to avoid it?

[stevenryals]

I've said it before..  I think it's clear at this point to everyone that she has a role with some action..  looking at past games, she's never had that.. normal townie, normal townie & mason.. so her change in style could be a result of her being mafia or her being a pro town role..  I've said we should go after Amadjin first and then look back to bluestars tomorrow plenty of times.. 

[mophead]

mophead,i call you out and the best you can come up with is that?

]quote author=mophead link=topic=10109.msg114363#msg114363 date=1215439624]

Is anyone else seeing through Amadjins crap?

And besides, my post was just a little joke to get things moving.


what crap is that??
the crap where iv called people out to see what there responses were,or the analysing of what people are saying and to whom?
this compared to your complete lack of gameplay,your mention of mafia or transparent responses to peoples claims about you

and steve you yet again ignored what i'd said....if it wasnt for mophead playing an even looser game than you,you'd be top of my suspect list

MY MENTION OF MAFIA! YOU SAID IT TWICE IN ONE POST!!!!!!!!!!!!

[stevenryals]

MY MENTION OF MAFIA! YOU SAID IT TWICE IN ONE POST!!!!!!!!!!!!

oh my (*@*#$@#*)!#)!#*%)!(@#&*$    you frustrate me mophead..  i figure you're innocent.. but you're not doing yourself any favors..

[mophead]

What are you talking about Steve?

[stevenryals]

what do I mean?

1) you dont usually make much sense when you post..
2) you post very little which doesnt help the town at all
3) you're making it an easy first day for the mafia, because they're voting for you and you're not defending yourself properly..  you've been evil most every game you've played so far, and i can just tell (just like when you were beast in the xmen game) that you couldnt be bothered to play this game..  you're not reading all the posts, and you're not stepping up and challenging people..

get in mophead..  get started... if you're town, help out...  you're not helping yourself by the way your playing, you'll end up getting lynched.. and then it's night, and we'll lose another one or two townies.. 

[froganomis]

the way its going we are going to lose a townie today regardless

iv noticed something about your last post,because you know him and he's coming across evil,your encouraging him to come across less evil regardless of wether hes evil or not. sounds to me like you two are on the same team and know it 

fos steveryals and mophead

[stevenryals]

the way its going we are going to lose a townie today regardless

iv noticed something about your last post,because you know him and he's coming across evil,your encouraging him to come across less evil regardless of wether hes evil or not. sounds to me like you two are on the same team and know it 

fos steveryals and mophead

your reaching amadjin..  big stretch there.

[hippo]

Think hammer should be back soon, but as he's not yet, i'll do his work for him.

Vote Count

amadjin 2 (stevenryals, Steve Van halen)
mikeblue 6 (hammerbro, mophead, Currieman, Yorkshire Blue, Miasg, Hippo)
footballnewb 1 (TCH)
bluestars 2 (wesmancity, Trickpony)
Yorkshire Blue 1 (Mikeblue)
Mophead 3 ( Afroboy, Laserblue, Amadjin)
Currieman 1 (Happy Axeman)

Yet to vote: Footballnewb and Bluestars


Footballnewb and bluestars both not voting is something i'm not keen on. Fair enough footynewb's had his internet connection problems, but bluestars has been active enough to actually vote.

But it's not just those 2 that are making this drag on. TCH, Mikeblue and Happy Axeman all have votes placed on people that, as far as i can see, have nothing incriminating against them - that's not to say they might not be evil, but in terms of voting for a lynch, there's just no point to it. A hunch is never going to get 9 other people to agree and end the day. To me, voting like this is a way of keeping under the radar - you're seen to be doing something, but you're having absolutely no impact on the day and there's going to be absolutely no consequences from it because the person you've voted for isn't going to be lynched.

Amadjin, Mikeblue, mophead and bluestars seem to be the people that are the most suspected, and all four have decent arguments against them. Might make sense for everyone to just vote for one of them? Or at least put forward a proper argument for somebody else, that other people can understand.

Or maybe if we all post our top 3 suspicions, and then agree to lynch whoevers name comes up the most or something? Seems like the only way we might get a decision that 10 people can agree is best for the town.

I don't think we'll get a deadline, Hammer likes the game to be played properly and to a natural conclusion.

[Happy Axeman]

am knackered and need to go bed, Ive only read from where i last posted(i will catch up eventually)...

This deleted currieman post looks dodgy and is a clear abuse of admin privileges!! Its HA's site so I guess he can do whatever the hell he feels like.

seems strange your the only one complaining, are you in cahoots with Currieman perhaps?

Amadjin has come back and shown he is still a player who always smacks of evil, but is on occasion TOWN... Same as mikeblue really.

Ive not had the oppourtunity properly to see if anyone has made any cockup early in the game through my time constraints, but Curriemans to me sticks out like a sore thumb... I'm usually good(and successfull) at picking the mistake out early on in the first day.

It seems strange that StevenRyals is defending Bluestars, cause her style has deffo changed. She doesnt seem pro-town.

Trickpony is annoying with his endless consectutive posts... just stick your findings in one post for christ sake... use quick reply for grabbing quotes, copy & paste... use a bit of effort.

Ok who's put there profile in hidden mode ? sometimes I'll try to stay on if I can see one of us looking at the boards especially if I'm waiting for an answer .. now some unknown hidden person is here but who?  I think it stinks of evilness myself - a bit like the no lynch debate - but it should probably be 1 in all in - for all future games. 

there is now no need to be hidden as far as i can see, as ive turned the who's online feature off, in fact i turned it off about a week ago...
so yeah, I agree that going hidden recently does smell of mafia... being ADMIN, no one stays hidden to me!!! they appear in itallic, although I can not go hidden either... StevenRyals is hidden...

I havent read enough of mikeblues posts to see why so many have voted for him, and i  dont think its fair to vote on someone who i read about. so my lonely vote on Currieman is going to stay. I am tempted by Amadjin, but Steven and Steve have voted for him... then theres Mophead, but Amadjin has voted him...

so there you have it, my suspects for mafia/evil from my minimal mafia interaction is Amadjin, SteveRyals, Steve Van Halen, Currieman, Bluestars.

[stevenryals]

It seems strange that StevenRyals is defending Bluestars, cause her style has deffo changed. She doesnt seem pro-town.

not defending... why do people say I'm defending her?  I've clearly said we shouldnt lynch her TODAY...  amadjin for today..   I'm almost sure that even if she was the cop or the doctor, she wouldnt know how to act.. which may contribute to her acting so different..   as I've said over and over again...  we should re-evaluate her tomorrow based on the nights actions..

I've been stead throughout about Amadjin, my vote was cast and it's stayed there.. i'm that sure... 

do what you will... but I'm sticking with Amadjin..  if you want reasons.. read the last 50 posts i've made in this game, it's all there.. along with me explaining why i'm hesitant about bluestars..

maybe i'll have some time at work tomorrow to go back and compile some quotes and stuff to help get this day to a close..

[MIASG]

we should re-evaluate her tomorrow based on the nights actions..

how will we know A) if she has a night action B)if it's town or mafia

Hippo I disagree with your comment that Happy Axeman's vote is wasted on Currieman  .. A few of us are suss on him for his early post that got wiped.  I'm actually tossing up if I should unvote mikeblue and vote currieman or keep my vote on him .. I'm still uneasy on some of his responses especially to me so for now it's holding but just.  He isn't convincing me he's town. 

The only way not to lose a townie on day 1 is vote no-lynch and we know that just helps the mafia .. the majority of us have to spot the mafia and get him despite others attempts to lead us away - that's the struggle for us with no time limit.  So who's leading us away ?

[froganomis]

not defending... why do people say I'm defending her?  I've clearly said we shouldnt lynch her TODAY...  amadjin for today..   I'm almost sure that even if she was the cop or the doctor, she wouldnt know how to act.. which may contribute to her acting so different..   as I've said over and over again...  we should re-evaluate her tomorrow based on the nights actions..

I've been stead throughout about Amadjin, my vote was cast and it's stayed there.. i'm that sure... 

do what you will... but I'm sticking with Amadjin..  if you want reasons.. read the last 50 posts i've made in this game, it's all there.. along with me explaining why i'm hesitant about bluestars..

maybe i'll have some time at work tomorrow to go back and compile some quotes and stuff to help get this day to a close..

and if your wrong which i 100% know you are about me,you have to be lynched tomorrow and have me for company in the graveyard,'im that sure'.anyway it looks like being as soon as lynching today is over il be dead anyways,and by that i dont mean night phase...

[MIASG]

Amadjin what do you mean by this ?

anyway it looks like being as soon as lynching today is over il be dead anyways,and by that i dont mean night phase...

you only have 2 votes against you so far .. a bit far fetched don't you think

[froganomis]

Amadjin what do you mean by this ?  you only have 2 votes against you so far .. a bit far fetched don't you think

if id said,its because im going to be lynched id have wirtten that wouldnt i

[hippo]

If you don't mean night phase, and you don't mean you're going to get lynched, what exactly are you on about?

[froganomis]

if someone dies,i die too,wether or not that person is evil i dont know,but i am innocent,so it might make sense to keep that person in the game a little longer,at least til we work out alignment.

[yorkshire blue]

MY MENTION OF MAFIA! YOU SAID IT TWICE IN ONE POST!!!!!!!!!!!!

what are your thoughts mophead please post something useful
my main two suspects have gone into hiding (bluestars, mikeblue)
if we lynch amadjin and hes town then hippo or stevenryals as to be mafia
where are bluestars, mikeblue, hammerbro, footballnewbie

[MIASG]

if someone dies,i die too,wether or not that person is evil i dont know,but i am innocent,so it might make sense to keep that person in the game a little longer,at least til we work out alignment.

WTF are you on about ?  are you saying that your character is tied in with another ?