Mafia 14 - The Good, The Bad and The Ugly Mafia: Game over-TOWN WIN!

[froganomis]

i never fooking said i was mafia,jeeeeeeeeeeeeeeez....or its him jumping on a bandwagon

everyones barking up the wrong tree at the moment and it needs to be changed or the town are going to suffer as a consequence

[MIASG]

TCH - possible mafia godfather - hes too quiet for comfort and knowing him hes definatley hiding staying low
MIASG - undecided - hes playing a different game from the last, quiet in that hes not investigating every detail so either he doesnt care which is unlikley or he knows whos who and is evil. Though nothing concrete on him atm.
Footballnob - probably townie but he has to show up first to defend himself

Well after reading all 12 pages im voting for Bluestars because of the following reasons ;
in the last 3 games you've played, you've been town.. so this goes against you in percentages

It's funny that 2 of the 3 people you work with are according to you mafia .. but the one who hasn't even posted is probably townie !  go figure.  it makes no sense.  your just trying to get people to vote for me ... again .. and also listing TCH as the only possible godfather - why only him - and why godfather? .. and me for changing the way I play .. I was away for 3 days and all your doing is making me go at you again .. like previous games .. I think it's funny that I get emails from you prompting me to log on and respond to something against me .. once again you are not helping the town .. and seeing how you away for a week your still no help.

You are an idiot and after re-reading 12 pages you vote on percentages according to roles in previous games ? 

[MIASG]

Maybe he just doesn't like you Amadjin

  who does ?

[MIASG]

Didn't like me calling you out pal???

So you go straight for the tit for tat vote...mmmmm...inte resting.

not I was responding to your quote

This stinks of a mafia long pointless post to look like town and then a strange vote for curriman who may or may not be mafia with you. Either way your vote at this time matters not and I think that is the way you want it. Could well be in cahoots just my original thoughts for some reason.


FOS Curriman and AMadjin

I was just putting my first real post down and you call it stinking of a long pointless mafia post.  I also explain why I voted for currieman but you call it strange and that my vote didn't matter.  Am I not entitled to vote for who I want to ?  seems to me that you want me to vote for the vote leaders .. and it's still you. 

[stevenryals]

Also we should make sure that the person in line for the lynching is not a townie before casting the final votes ! So dont be lazy and just vote on the bandwagon people provide a reason ! generally mafia players post the least as they dont read most of the posts like MIASG normally does !!!

You're mafia mate..  you're trying WAAAAY too hard to seem like your town..  waaay too hard..


then you do this:

Well after reading all 12 pages im voting for Bluestars because of the following reasons ;
in the last 3 games you've played, you've been town.. so this goes against you in percentages

each time you have waited until the end of the day after heavy research before posting a vote..
you have now posted 3 or 4 times and now you are already voting..  to early for normal townie bluestars

she's very calculated, posts statistics of votes, fos's etc etc, and waits until late in a lynch before posting a vote.. so so true you are never so eager to vote as you may kill off a townie

dont think she's ever been the first to vote for anyone..  she's playing a very different game from the previous where she has NEVER been mafia before.. which is why you have my vote the more responses I read from various people the deeper you sink. Steve should have just found a grave stone and put RIP Bluestars as your goooonnnneeee...

you've basically repeated me..  you're making big posts to seem like your town.. but you're just regurgitating the same stuff other people have said..

FOS Trick PONY

OK.. so Trick Pony & Amadjin are surely mafia.. anyone else?

[i2i Killer 89]

  who does ?

Trick Pony

[*Afroboy*]

To be honest I'm not as sure mikeblue is mafia as most other people are, I seen him do crazy stuff like this before and even though this is on a different scale I wouldn't jump to conclusions on him.

And why aren't we getting rid of the person who I'm very certain is mafia?

Mophead has said he is and then not come back since and also I don't think mophead was joking. He's not defended himself against it either.

Vote mophead

Yorky, Amadjin and bluestars are looking very suspisious to me as well. Yorky is sayin he is making mikeblue crack. Them one line garbage posts wouldn't make a ....... crack never mind anyone else. For me his posts have been useless, small, meaningless and backed up by nothing much than what others have already done. Fos Yorky

[froganomis]

OK.. so Trick Pony & Amadjin are surely mafia.. anyone else?

now your just being a cock 
look with your eyes steve at this page and the last and you'll find the truth
defend yourself bluestars,you've gone rather quiet. telling sign i think....disappeare d since going back to her old style of posting....

[laserblue]

Bluestars a few people have pointed to you as being possibly evil..... so why don't you defend yourself ?

Mophead all you have done in the last few days is basically say you are evil & disappear .. if this carries on for much longer I feel I'm left with no other option but to vote for you..

miasg your style seems to be reverting back to when you were evil .........
by that I mean last game you were town & were very pro-active in finding mafia.... but in this game you seem to be back to squabbling with tp ....

wes I don't think we have heard from you in a while

I hope axeman & hammerbro are going to be a bit more active in the future as they have been a waste of space so far.

[froganomis]

Bluestars a few people have pointed to you as being possibly evil..... so why don't you defend yourself ?

get your own ideas,read my post and thought you'd emphasise what i said huh?

[stevenryals]

bluestars, myself & mophead are at the beach until monday morning.. so we'll not be on much...   i've had about 8 beerz..and she's on the margarita's..  so.. we'll talk to you fool's tomorrow and stuff...

so... basically.. bluestars & I are out to the beach..  mophead is here.. but its just like he's playing...  you know.. just without the bizarre random quote here and there lol

we'll be back monday..  we have proof too.. just took some family photos   

[MIASG]

miasg your style seems to be reverting back to when you were evil .........
by that I mean last game you were town & were very pro-active in finding mafia.... but in this game you seem to be back to squabbling with tp ....

I feel that TP is provoking me again and I'm damned if I respond and I'm damned if I don't.  He knows he's going away so he can't respond to much and he's probably banking on that.  if it's the usual one of you must be mafia then I'd be the one to go becuase I'm still around and he can't defend himself .. and you'd all be wrong.
How and when have I not tried to help town?  I tried to stay away from TP last game but he looked suss and it turned out he was nazgul.  If I think he's possibly mafia then I will have a go at him.  All he's doing is setting me up .. and then emailing me telling me he's written something about me that he thinks will get me voted off .. TP do you deny this ? that my friends is a personal vandetta and not helping the town.   I'm finding it harder this game to really come into it 9 pages in and try to figure out where people are .. some gut feelings I had when reading on say page 3 might have been changed by page 7 .. but if I was playing online the whole time I probably would have questioned it along the way.   

[MIASG]

I keep checking but no one is either around or posting ... which is slack considering the pace early on- I had hoped my other aussies would have surfaced today.

I'm still waiting to know more about the hidden profile or whatever (I see someone is online now with it) .. what was said?  it would appear to be a mafia benefit at night time but otherwise I don't get it.

[hippo]

I keep checking but no one is either around or posting ... which is slack considering the pace early on- I had hoped my other aussies would have surfaced today.

I'm still waiting to know more about the hidden profile or whatever (I see someone is online now with it) .. what was said?  it would appear to be a mafia benefit at night time but otherwise I don't get it.

In the graveyard thing from the last game, laserblue (i think) raised some issues about how people were working out what people were just by sitting on the "who's online" thing, and seeing if they were sending messages or not, and ruling people out because they hadn't seen them online. So it was suggested that people change it (there's a box to tick somewhere in your profile settings), and i think a fair few people did it at the time, and then maybe a few more when mikeblue started speaking about it earlier in the game. There's only really a point to it if everyone does it though, because now i'm finding the people who changed at the start of this game suspicious - seems like they have something to hide. And that's kind of the same thing as what we were trying to get rid of.

As for the actual game, soz for not posting the last couple of days. Had my graduation so i was a bit busy.  Well, drunk anyway.

From just reading through now, it's really hard to judge. The same people always seem to accuse each other in these games, which doesn't help. I don't know how to judge a conflict between TP and MIASG because it all seems to be based on knowing what each other are like, rather than points that everyone else can see and use to form their own opinion.

I think largely stevenryals' points about bluestars seem to be taken less at straight value, due to the fact that every game he is 100% convinced that one of bluestars or mophead are evil on day one. This time though, her gameplay has changed drastically, and i can't help feeling that she probably is mafia. She's doing nothing to help the town, and everything she has done, has been kind of forced - producing a list when she'd claimed to not have time for it, claiming to be trying to spark conflict, when as soon as wes argued back, she unvoted; this makes me think she has something to hide. Her defense for not being evil was that we should be focusing on the non-posters - which is desperation. It's the easy option for her to get to the night phase. Strong sense that she's dodgy. Nothing about her seems right this time.

But, mophead has actually claimed to be mafia. He has said nothing since, and well, it just looks like he realised he made a mistake and hoped no one would remember it. I don't fully accept amadjin's claim that he was joking, but i'm not 100% that he wasn't.. whereas i think mophead just saw an opportunity to actually tell people he's mafia, and get away with it. So, with that in mind..

unvote amadjin
vote mophead

[stevenryals]

unvote amadjin
vote mophead

boo..  i still think amadjin should be the first lynch..  i'm sticking with him..

[Sir Villain]

Vote Count

amadjin 2 (stevenryals, Steve Van halen)
mikeblue 5 (hammerbro, mophead, Currieman, Yorkshire Blue, Miasg)
footballnewb 1 (TCH)
bluestars 3 (wesmancity, Amadjin, Trickpony)
Yorkshire Blue 1 (Mikeblue)
Mophead 2 ( Afroboy, Hippo)


Currently without a vote 4 (the rest)

Remember at the moment it's 10 votes to get a lynch.


I'm about to make a 16 hour car journey back to England so will be unable to update. The game isn't going into a deadline because of the lively debate and i'm sure a lynch will be achieved.

[laserblue]

Ok .. peeps who don't post stink  if your town & not posting then your making it easy for the mafia & possibly cult?

I know I had a go at TCH for voting footienewb as it was the easy option .. but I understand where he is coming from. if he hasn't posted by day 2 then I think he should go. FOS footie newb

mophead until I hear what you have got to say for yourself you get my vote .. vote mophead
I know this is looking like a bit of a bandwagon... but with the amout of votes needed to get a lynch this time peeps think they are to safe & coming on with a trick like that then not coming on to defend yourself you can't expect anything else...

I think bluestars needs to do some talking as well FOS bluestars

fos hammerbro & axeman until they post

[hippo]

fos hammerbro & axeman until they post

Hammerbro said he was going away for the week i believe.

Axeman needs to post. His excuses from earlier in the week hold no relevance now, and the other time he posted seemed to be an "i'll just check no-one's voting for me", show my face, and then disappear again kind of thing. The other time he just regurgitated what was being said by everybody else.

fuck gotta go out.. soz peeps, I'm off work tomorrow, I'll try and get on properly and let you know what i'm thinking.

This was days ago now; no post since; no contribution.

[hippo]

What was deleted beforehand? I have Admin privaledges which lets me read what has been deleted, before i delete it for good... I can ALWAYS see what peeps have deleted. And i got to say, i actualy read the posts before they were deleted, and there was a post by currieman which had me thinking he could of slipped up. I'm a believer that at least 1 mafia will always make a mistake early on... its just a case of picking up on it.

This is part of his one post needles me as well. If he thinks currieman has made a revealing mistake, then why would he be vague about it? Why not state what it was? Even if he's not certain, make Currie answer for whatever it was, and then he'll have a chance of working him out properly. He's a clever player and he knows how to play as a townie.

He stated in the previous game, or graveyard thread, that when he was playing as a serial killer, he tried to play in the same way as he would if he were a townie, i.e. causing conflict, trying to suss people out. He's not doing that this game. So what can we conclude from that? He's not playing like a serial killer; he's not playing like a townie.. what's left?

[Happy Axeman]

first thing first, you can all have my apologies for not posting, but unexpected things have happened in my life just as this game was started...

Axeman needs to post. His excuses from earlier in the week hold no relevance now, and the other time he posted seemed to be an "i'll just check no-one's voting for me", show my face, and then disappear again kind of thing. The other time he just regurgitated what was being said by everybody else.

This was days ago now; no post since; no contribution.

actually it does still hold relevance, because... I dont usually talk about my private life over bloody forums but since this is a mafia game and you have to explain yourself here goes. lol
 A its the truth
 B Its been that long since ive been attached to anyone, that you cant blame me for not being around..
 C Ive not even been on my forum as ive barely been home, there is no internet access where ive been staying. If i have access and time, I post simple as.
 D Ive dropped her off at the pub with her friends, walked the dog and here i am... only ive now got 13 pages of stuff to read and try and abosrb stuff and then be in bed soon to get up for work at 5 in the morning and then i'll get home at 6pm... walk dog for an hour, and somehow do the stuff i need to do and go bed before 11 to go get up at 5 again... can someone explain how i'm supposed to find more time?

This is part of his one post needles me as well. If he thinks currieman has made a revealing mistake, then why would he be vague about it? Why not state what it was? Even if he's not certain, make Currie answer for whatever it was, and then he'll have a chance of working him out properly. He's a clever player and he knows how to play as a townie.

He stated in the previous game, or graveyard thread, that when he was playing as a serial killer, he tried to play in the same way as he would if he were a townie, i.e. causing conflict, trying to suss people out. He's not doing that this game. So what can we conclude from that? He's not playing like a serial killer; he's not playing like a townie.. what's left?

Ive not had a chance to play as anything have i(see above shit) but yes i am a townie, but everyone is going to say that anyway so what good does it do?

the early deleted posts which i found a bit strange? I dont see anything in the rules which states i cant do this so here goes(I can quote the whole deleted manuscript - minus the quotes in the original posts i will be quoting) if peeps want me too....

Basically MiasG is trying to avoid suspiscion by going away for a couple of days so that we don't lynch him. Not gonna wash mate, you're mafia aren't you

No currieman I'm not mafia - but thanks for asking.  Are you ?

... the rule states if your away for more than 48 hours then let everyone know - I did that before the game started - plus mow it's on early I'm here - I'm not hiding and staying away for longer... you've missed a few games but the others can vouch for me that I'm always around and posting alot of shit   
Having a kid didn't really slow me down that much last game. 

When did I ask if you were mafia Trying a bit of misdirection are we? I see your game MiasG, you can't fool me. Fair play though, I believe that you aren't mafia.

Oh and I'm not mafia either, thanks for asking. The only way to figure who is and isn't is to point the finger and I reckon that Axeman is mafia

the exchange and Curries responses just didnt make sense to me, theres just something not right about him, and my instincts are screaming out he is evil.

does that clear up your questions hippo? or do i have to waste more time answering them meaning i have less time to make my own investigations?