Mafia 13: LOTR: Graveyard

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

well Yorkshire vs the rest, if he can kill the last hobbit tonight, then not get lynched he, the person with the ring would be consumed a person lynched and a kill during the night would make it

1 town 1 mafia at day 7

long odds though

[Trick Pony]

he can do it 

GO Yorky GO

 

[Mikeblue]

lol

[stevenryals]

lol

NOT!  lol

He's going down..  I think they'll get him...

think about it.. everyone has claimed so far except him and liverbird & liverbird has voted for mafia every time throughout.. should be an easy lynch to be honest...

and with mophead out of the game, I think most will use thier heads when voting today

Go TOWN!!

[stevenryals]

Ok lets work this out..

Bluestars         
Liverbird         
Miasg             
Wesmancity     
Yorkshire Blue   evil


so.. someone has the ring..  and if they are killed tonight then.....
ring goes to regular townies...

they will die because the ring will consume him..

so that leaves 2 vs Yorkshire blue..

if they lynch york its over, if they lynch anyone else.. its an evil victory..


but if yorkshire kills anyone but the ring bearer... then it's a town victory...

if he manages to guess the ring bearer.. then he has a good chance to convince MIASG that it's actually Liverbird that's evil.. because she wont be on often enough to defend herself.. 

and remember that he's Nazgul and probably still has the terrorist option..  if so.. and he kills the ring bearer... he can at least take someone out on his way to death... but that will still leave a townie and it will be a town victory 

tonight's kill will be important..   cant wait.. wish he'd go ahead and send it in so things could get rolling again..

[laserblue]

lol..   laserblue has resigned himself to defeat lol

nice final post 

Nice one

Hi all

Sorry steve but after reading this I'm glad we got you out of the way....

I'm not mad at mophead cause I know he was trying to help , but I think it only brought things more on top for me unfortunatley....

But TP what were you doing man there was no way you where going to get out of that one ... the town used your post to help nail me....

It was a bad mistake I made killing axeman but he had named nearly all of us .. Yorkshire wanted to go for someone else...

anyway enjoyed killing you all (well nearly all) but I prefer to be town it's easier...

I think it's a town win ... maybe they will role claim them yorks is done for...

anyway go yorks... the evil ones are behind you

[stevenryals]

the evil ones are behind you

distubring statement....

[laserblue]

distubring statement....

 

[laserblue]

I almost believed laser but I was never fully convinced. Knew the swine would take me out! 

I wasn't actually my idea .. as I was certain to die the next day I sent a pm to yorks asking him for a name .... he gave me 2 you & wes ... so afro flipped a coin & you where out

[stevenryals]

I wasn't actually my idea .. as I was certain to die the next day I sent a pm to yorks asking him for a name .... he gave me 2 you & wes ... so afro flipped a coin & you where out

I see you are talking to dead mafia members...  against the rules!!!!

you must shun your family during these games!!!!!  it's IN THE RULES!!!

[laserblue]

didn't you just say you where talking to bluestars about the game

anyway who said anything about talking ... you don't flip a coin with yer mouth   

[stevenryals]

how did he know to flip a coin?     lol

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

well he went for Wes so a town win is now assured i'd say

[Trick Pony]

But TP what were you doing man there was no way you where going to get out of that one ... the town used your post to help nail me....

Meh that was on purpose to try FORCE you guys into trying to save me, as if they had believed I was the elf queen we almost definatley would have won, so from my point of view you screw yourselves over on that one... its ment to be a team game and i wasnt getting any help from the rest of you. 

Anyway GG to the townies

[Mikeblue]

NOT!  lol

He's going down..  I think they'll get him...

think about it.. everyone has claimed so far except him and liverbird & liverbird has voted for mafia every time throughout.. should be an easy lynch to be honest...

and with mophead out of the game, I think most will use thier heads when voting today

Go TOWN!!

I think she has only voted twice though lol.

I think its obvious she ain't mafia as she wasn't on for like a week.

[laserblue]

I think something needs doing to save the mafia games..... people are just looking who's logged on to see who could have sent a mafia post during the night or who's messaging TCH ..... it totally defeats the object of the game & makes it not worth playing

also with all the rollclaiming & death posts giving people's identity.....  it's just ruining the game

[stevenryals]

I think something needs doing to save the mafia games..... people are just looking who's logged on to see who could have sent a mafia post during the night or who's messaging TCH ..... it totally defeats the object of the game & makes it not worth playing

also with all the rollclaiming & death posts giving people's identity.....  it's just ruining the game

I've been thinking of this..  and I think we need to add two rules..

1)  Mafia can use email or MSN to communicate between each other at the night phases and to send in thier action, so as to keep the "he's sent a msg to TCH" comments down...   also, we can make 'who's online' illegal for the purposes of the game..  it's really the honesty policy that has to take force, shouldnt be too tough just to enjoy the game without trying to view who's online doing what..

2) not sure what we can do about role climing..  but I think if we make a rule that you can't roleclaim unless you have votes for you, or something of the manner... or even, you can claim until the 5th day of the game unless you are within 2 votes of a lynch..


I agree 100% with you laserblue..  the game where everyone role claimed excpet one person... it took the luster from the game.. as everyone knew who was who.. and the whole point of the game is that you DONT know who's who

[hippo]

Maybe if we just don't have all of the games having known characters and rigid themes? That way, a role claim is always questionable, and the mafia can always do them as effectively as townies, because no one knows what's out there. Roleclaiming should always be allowed though, it just shouldn't be so easy.

The who's online thing is easily solved. Just get everyone to make themselves appear hidden at the start of the game - like Hammer already does himself - and it's problem solved.

I like the idea of doing another secret account game actually, to stop people just killing the obvious choices easily right at the start of the game.. every time.

I'll do Kingmaker II at some point if people want?

[Mikeblue]

Totally agree with what you are both saying.

How do you hide if you are online???

Everyone role claiming towards the end gives the town huge advantage but only in games where people know the characters. But games that are familiar I think are more fun to be honest.

And I don't have MSN as am sure others don't but if you were shown offline it wouldn't matter would it.

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

the hidden option would work, i don't use it but might in future games if i can work out how to set it up.

I don't mind role claiming as in the last game two people claimed to be xavier and it cost the town the win. I find it strange though that people who would contribute to the game a killed early and people who say nothing waltz through days at a time. It has effected this game a bit.

Like i mentioned earlier but my ultimate mod game would be to have separate accounts people used thereby its just user1, user2, user3 etc and you have no idea who's who and can only work things out from their posting style. It might help Steve make it to day 2 too !!