Mafia 20 - Avatar

[stevenryals]

That's because you're not thinking very well at the moment..

1)  why would mafia take out mophead, someone who's not voting, or posting at all..?? makes no sense

2)  mafia wouldn't go for wes because they would assume that he was protected at night

3)  the lack of a 2nd kill leads me to believe that there an attempt on eddiemunster.  and since i'm of the belief that a town vig killed mophead, that means mafia tried to kill him imo.  I have no other information as to whether he is town or not, but this is why i'm inclined to believe he's not mafia.

4)  Killing eddie would be a good kill for the mafia because it would incriminate wes, who's known to be good.

[froganomis]

why are you so certain theres meant to be 2 kills??? unvote svh

[MIASG]

Can someone tell me when the last straight mafia v town was?   the last twisted game was the one with numbers .. otherwise there's usually more then 1 night kill action .. I can;t talk for Ryals but that's my assumption and I have to stick with it.   

Mikeblue ..

Again I believe your logic to be flawed Mr Ryalls and I think I have stumbled upon possibly 2 mafia members. I feel it in my waters. It seems far too elaborate and usually the simple theory is the correct one. You and either Wes or Eddie are Mafia and you are trying to convince us all a little too much that you are town. I mean Wes claiming so early and now you more or less telling us your role in an effort to convinve us we must not vote for you and you are essential to the town? I think not. Doesn't sit right with me I'm afraid.

which 2?   I'm getting the feeling that your not mafia.. or town .. and possibly a serial killer who took out mophead, or maybe as steve suggests a vigilante... nothing concrete .. yet .. but I feel it in my waters.

look I want to hear more from Villian .. very very quiet .. claimed mason but I can't see who the other one is ..

[stevenryals]

why are you so certain theres meant to be 2 kills???

Not certain, but I can't see TCH not giving at least one townie the ability to kill at night..

[stevenryals]

Vote Savechip55 for being completely silent..

Also want to hear more from Villian & Axeman..

[Mikeblue]

Well in that case then maybe the Vigilante decided not use his kill as he wasn't sure of getting an evil member and didn't want to kill a towny and ivestigated instead......

[froganomis]

who first planted this idea of a vigilante even being in the game? there is only 12 of us in the game,i would have thought a vigilante would make the game unbalanced,or is that just me? lol

[Mikeblue]

I agree Amadjin.

[MIASG]

Well in that case then maybe the Vigilante decided not use his kill as he wasn't sure of getting an evil member and didn't want to kill a towny and ivestigated instead......

that is true .. I've been known to knock out townies when I've had said roles ..

who first planted this idea of a vigilante even being in the game? there is only 12 of us in the game,i would have thought a vigilante would make the game unbalanced,or is that just me? lol

we lost Phil early on so it was 13 so start with wasn't it? I'm just going on past games scenarios and I feel there probably is more than 1 kill night action .. I have no idea if there is or if it was used or not .. I guess with the story line a  SK would be hard to put in unless one of the native wildlife so vig more believable.  I think we are getting bogged down a little on the 2 kills per night vs 1 kill scenario .. not really doing more then that - still shouldn't really stop in search of mafia though. 

[eddiemunster]

unVote stevenryals

Vote Savechip55

no word in the past forever. 


stevenryals, Im inclined to agree with your way of thinking.  you make some valid points in your previous posts.

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

Current vote count is

Savechip55 2 votes
Stevenryals 2 votes
Amadjin 1 vote
Axeman 1 vote
Eddie 1 vote
SVH 1 vote

I will place a deadline for Day 2 of Midnight Sunday Uk time, so one week if you cannot determine who to lynch.

[MIASG]

TCH are you doing post count again if a tie?  and if so just day 2 only ? 

[froganomis]

i took my vote off SVH because this whole 2 kill night phase scenario...but nothing seems to come out of it other than a madcap theory.so seeing as im convinced he's not part of the town,and no-one else has rung alarm bells the way he did before disappearing,i'd like to Re-Vote: SVH

[stevenryals]

who first planted this idea of a vigilante even being in the game? there is only 12 of us in the game,i would have thought a vigilante would make the game unbalanced,or is that just me? lol

I agree Amadjin.

The two of you are not being open to the idea of a vigilante?  Why?  just because we started with 13?   You can figure probably 3 mafia.. and the rest town..  I can't see a cult or serial killer with only 12/13 in the game..  but why would the town not have some type of kill action at night?  What's your reasoning based on?

[froganomis]

because of the small number of people in the game i dont see there being a vig without there being an imbalance. i would think it more likely to be a cult present then a vig. but on the other hand,we're all speculating unless someone actually knows something

[Steve Van Halen]

Folks, I am finding it hard to find the time for this game at the moment for various reasons. I havent been on much at all lately and dont want to hold the game up by being inactive. I can get online tommorow for maybe an hour and the same again Wednesday and Friday but the weekend is a write off really. If you are happy with that I am happy to continue but I would have no objections if you have a suitable replacement in the waiting.

My contract at the magistrates court has been extended until august and I want to keep my nose clean in the hope of extending it further so I cant get online during the day like I used to. I would like to apologise to everyone of you for not being able to get online much lately which means I havent got anything to contribute.

I had no idea this would happen when I signed up. Sorry folks

[MIASG]

caught in 2 minds now .. unvote SVH in case someone else comes on board .. or keep it on becuase I think he's the most likely still ..   think i'll keep it on for now.

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

Well a 3 way tie now


Current vote count is

Savechip55 2 votes
Stevenryals 2 votes
SVH 2 votes
Amadjin 1 vote
Axeman 1 vote
Eddie 1 vote


If no one is lynched by the deadline i will let fate decide and toss a coin to decide

[MIASG]

just out of interest how would a 50/50 coin toss decide the fate of 3 people ?  random draw ?

[savechip55]

Sorry been absent over the last week, been on hols!  Nice to know you get 2 votes just for that, must be a slow game!