Mafia 17 - Harry Potter Game *Mafia Win*

[Happy Axeman]

I wish you had aimed this at someone else axeman, becuase it would sound much better coming from me with a rebuttal...  but out of everything you said this is the most suspicious..

You tend to really think these things through, and you've not done it this time.  Here's why...

The reason everyone agreed 100% that there was a cult, was Hammer's claim that he was a anti-cult role.  Now that claim turns out to be crap, so we're back at square one.   you ignore the possibility that there may actually be no cult in this game.  This type of oversight is unusual for the Happy Axeman who plays for the town, becuase he usually digs deep and thinks things out greatly.   you've not done that, and this is the first time in a while I can say that you've slipped.  I believe you are mafia my friend..

Vote Happy Axeman

I think my laptop has just evolved to have smells, cause there is a wiff of bull shit after just reading that. even for your fabrication and standards, that is total and utter crap steven. an you know what, I think you know it is.

so now your deflecting the possibility that there could be a cult? YOUR the one that keeps bringing up the cult, and yet your the one blaming everyone else for bringing it up? wtf?

Why would i aim my suspicion at anyone else but you? i find your claim suspicious, just like i did hammers. Am I not allowed to suspect you? I see what your vote is. Its because i have said you are the only one of my suspects that is still alive.

Me an Mophead? pmsl.

try to lynch me, and you lynch a townie. its that simple.

[MIASG]

I was in the middle of thought when I posted last....was attempting to figure out in my head why Sir Hammer would find it a benefit to mention Hippo and Stevenryals as the ones he protects...after just calling out Stevenryals as being possibly recruited by the cult...

seems to me we are in the same situation with Mikeblue - BBM as we are with Hammer and Hippo & StevenRyals .. UNVOTE SVH as I'm still not sure of what side he's on - benefit of the doubt right now.

[mophead]

sorry people i ment to claim steven as the doc....i keep getting cop and doc mixed up 

[stevenryals]

how StevenRyals picks up on stuff is quite genius, and he picked up on what could be a mistake by MikeBlue.

even for your fabrication and standards, that is total and utter crap steven. an you know what, I think you know it is.

Funny how your tune changes throughout the game..  Guess it's not so genius when it's directed at you is it...

[MIASG]

sorry people i ment to claim steven as the doc....i keep getting cop and doc mixed up 

why are you claiming steven as doc ?

[stevenryals]

he's not been reading, so i told him to tell everyone my role within 5 minutes, he said i was the cop..  also said hammer was just trying to save his skin with his claim.....  so... obvious he's not reading that much..

[MIASG]

it's not like TP laid down a platform for him either

[Steve Van Halen]

so tempting just to vote mophead. His posts are erratic to say the least and this "I know something you dont" line is suspicious to say the least.


Balls to it vote mophead

Explain that line please as it is making no sense

[Happy Axeman]

Funny how your tune changes throughout the game..  Guess it's not so genius when it's directed at you is it...

not really, I find it funny how youve gone from genius to chump! the first quote you quoted from me was on page 4 of the first day, where i agreed that Mike blue was suspicious... but as we move on to the 2nd day, you seem to change tact and start fabricating, lying and making things up about peeps... and that brings us upto the here and now on day3. something has changed in your investigations, and is why I think you know you are talking dog poo. theres no substance to your accusations on me.

to be honest I'm thinking of voting Hammerbro as he is avoiding everything and staying well under the radar... same as amadjin.

[Steve Van Halen]

that is tempting but the whole "voting for non-posters" thing sometimes backfires though doesnt it?

[stevenryals]

not really, I find it funny how youve gone from genius to chump! the first quote you quoted from me was on page 4 of the first day, where i agreed that Mike blue was suspicious... but as we move on to the 2nd day, you seem to change tact and start fabricating, lying and making things up about peeps... and that brings us upto the here and now on day3. something has changed in your investigations, and is why I think you know you are talking dog poo. theres no substance to your accusations on me.

oh sorry, i forgot, you're never anything but a 'normal townie'... please excuse me for thinking that you may be anything other than a normal little useless townie..

bit of a backlash for a single vote..  I think my vote is in the right place based on your responses. 

[hippo]

Ok

The majority of players seem to think wes is more sus than bbm... I'm not sure I agree but I goona bring the day to an end & see what happens..... You lot better be right

Unvote BBM vote Wes

Just reading back through, this was the deciding vote on the wes lynch. He seems to be trying to absolve himself of any responsibility. Like he already knows it's not the right lynch, and is distancing himself, but contributing nonetheless. Might be nothing, might be something But i think it looks sus.

Oh, and steveryals, you're playing this game extremely weirdly - like it's still day one. On day one you poke for reactions using pretty much nothing, but by day four, there's a lot of stuff to use - alright, there's be no real night deaths or patterns to look for there, but they're usually set-ups anyway, there's been a few lynches to work from - there really is no need to be just fabricating stuff against people. Use the evidence available. I dunno if there is any for Axeman, but if you try to find something, rather than expecting people to just agree with baseless hunches, then we might get somewhere.

And i still want an answer from MIASG regarding why SVH is "definitely in a group" because i still don't really follow. He looks dodgy to me, because he seems to be trying his hardest to avoid confrontation with anyone major, and seems to be voting or looking to vote for people who either aren't around, or aren't the strongest. But yeah, was the reason for the group thing just because he's agreeing with people? 'Cause that's a pretty weakly substantiated statement if so.

[hippo]

Hammerbro and Amadjin are definitely more quiet than they should be though, i agree. Both decent players, so it's something to be wary of.

[hippo]

Apologies for three in a row, but vote amadjin. Might as well get some of these people out and playing.

[stevenryals]

there really is no need to be just fabricating stuff against people.

even for your fabrication and standards, that is total and utter crap steven. an you know what, I think you know it is.

IT WOULD REALLY SUCK IF YOU TWO WERE MAFIA OR CULT TOGETHER...     but that's what its starting to look like..  immediate defense of axeman..   

to be honest I'm thinking of voting Hammerbro as he is avoiding everything and staying well under the radar... same as amadjin.

Hammerbro and Amadjin are definitely more quiet than they should be though, i agree. Both decent players, so it's something to be wary of.

looks like the two of you are playing the same game..  very odd... 

you've both been a bit less helpful than usualy..  hippo, you've not really had a go at anyone yet, beside our day1 demolition of mikeblue..   what's happened to you since day 1? 

axeman?  anyone you've had a go at?  you say "all my suspects are dead"... but what have you done to make it happen? 

[Happy Axeman]

oh sorry, i forgot, you're never anything but a 'normal townie'... please excuse me for thinking that you may be anything other than a normal little useless townie..

bit of a backlash for a single vote..  I think my vote is in the right place based on your responses. 

youve accused me, Bluestars said she wanted to see my response, so i have responded? what else did you expect? to sit there and ignore your bullshit then you accuse me of not defending myself from your shit?
Yes in the past when i have been Mafia, i use the line i'm a useless townie... but in this game i really am on my own, lets just say I like the 'Luna' eclipse and 'Love' is 'good'. lol

But steven your game has changed since day one. If you cant see that then something in your mentality to this game has changed. 

All my suspects from the previous days are dead, except you. I didnt trust Mikeblue(and voted him out) or wes(i voted him out too), Yorkie needed to come out and play( i voted him in the hope he would come out)... but in the end i voted BBN, who was another mafia member out!!, and i also showed a major suspision towards Hammers role claim... and look, they are ALL DEAD.  what more do you want me to do? Ive tried harder in this game than Hammerbro, Amadjin, Mophead(formerly TP), bluestars and a few others. so i really dont see what your trying to get at?

Hammerbro and amadjin do need to be put under pressure though, cause if you cant see they are slipping in and out under the radar then you must know something that everyone else doesnt.

VOTE Amadjin

[Happy Axeman]

oh sorry, just realised that Hippo has just voted amadjin, that MUST mean i'm working with him. ffs

guess i'll have to UNVOTE AMADJIN, as Steve will say were working together.
VOTE STEVEN RYALS for being the harold shipman of mafia Doctors. lol 

[froganomis]

i think there were major deflection tactics in place when steve hippo and mike were arguin day one.

mikeblue turned out to be evil and i had a not with you on hippo in the last night phase.so i think it's time to get rid of another mafiosa

vote:hippo

[froganomis]

i realise that looks a like for like vote,i havent read through and just noticed the votes on me above

[hippo]

IT WOULD REALLY SUCK IF YOU TWO WERE MAFIA OR CULT TOGETHER...     but that's what its starting to look like..  immediate defense of axeman..   



looks like the two of you are playing the same game..  very odd... 

you've both been a bit less helpful than usualy..  hippo, you've not really had a go at anyone yet, beside our day1 demolition of mikeblue..   what's happened to you since day 1? 

axeman?  anyone you've had a go at?  you say "all my suspects are dead"... but what have you done to make it happen? 

Nice try. The reason i said that was because you keep doing it. You usually dissect posts, add spins to them, and try and annoy people in to reacting. What you did to me was just entirely made up. And the whole axeman thing seems weak. You keep claiming to have made people react, but there's a difference between that and someone responding to you. You know as well as i do, if you want to go at someone like me, you, or axeman, there's no real point unless you have something, and you obviously don't. I'm not saying there isn't anything in the game to find that he's done, i don't really know. The best i can find though is that he has voted for everyone who has been lynched, but didn't do it first on any occasion, which would to me indicate that he's trying not to stick out and staying in with the majority decision every time. But you haven't even looked that hard, you're just accusing him with nothing. How does that help anyone?

I'm not defending him, i'd advising you. Supposedly one of our biggest assets.

Yes, i've been slightly less aggressive on day two and three. This was simply because i had my mind made up that we should be lynching people we know to be evil, which the majority seemed to disagree with. I don't think you're mafia, purely because of your claim, but you're playing ridiculously. Surely you can see that from the list of people who agreed with that theory of yours on day two, and who voted wes (townie) over BBM (mafia), whilst some people might have been genuine and misguided, at least half of them will not have been, and will be mafia seizing on an opportunity that you and some others presented to them.

**4 POSTS APPARENTLY DURING THIS**

Lol, how quickly did you come out of hiding when you got a vote? Classic.