Mafia 17 - Harry Potter Game *Mafia Win*

[Happy Axeman]

first of all I'd like to say soz, didnt realize the day had started again, I must of missed a day in my life somewhere! lol Glad to see i was right all along with mike. 

Secondly I'm getting pissed off with people saying one minute I post more than i usualy do, then I get slagged for not posting!?! wtf?

Thirdly, Its a bold claim by mr ryals, but how do you know you were targeted by someone just because there was no kills? No-one is gonna come out at this stage and contest your name or role are they? your logic make sense, but i'm taking nothing for granted.

forthly, How can i be associated with TP just because he didnt mention me in one of his posts when i was clearly named in another of his posted just a few posts later? people skim reading and trying to implicate me with nothing? ....

the difference is none of this shit has anything to do with the game so Blus Stars, Happy Axeman, MIASG, and FBN have all contributed to fking this game up for me and since that is at least half of the main posters in this game then why not fk the game up for everyone else.  I thought it was ment to be fun to play and work out peoples roles from how they post etc but obviously some bored fkers have nothing better to do that go on about bs unrelated to the game.  Sad part about it is TCH makes a great game so sorry TCH, although the game had already gone to shit before I said that so fkn get over it and focus on the game instead of your fkn low brow game unrelating insults.  I dont care if insults are derived from what I have said to someone else and they respond but then it gets dragged on and on and on and its has absolutley nothing to do with the game so your just waisting everyones fkn time

fithly I see a connection between wes and mike, they pretty much stayed away from each other until mike started showing clear signs of mafia, and despite him eventually voting Mike it seems like it was a token gesture cause he knew his mafia mate was a gonna... and they both targeted BBN during the day... not saying wether BBN is mafia or not, he just hasnt posted enough to tell otherwise unless you want to think like Steven has said, mikeblue has hung him out to dry? but in a game of 17 peeps, isnt this a strange tactic for mafia to use? and wouldnt that also implicate wes?

He's not gonna like it and accuse me of picking on him again when i was quite clearly gunning for mike most of the day, but fuck it. VOTE WESMANCITY.

[hippo]

fithly I see a connection between wes and mike, they pretty much stayed away from each other until mike started showing clear signs of mafia, and despite him eventually voting Mike it seems like it was a token gesture cause he knew his mafia mate was a gonna... and they both targeted BBN during the day...

Might be something in that you know.

At the start, when i made Mikeblue cry, Wes did start amusingly accusing me of "sending coded messages to Yorkshire Blue", straight after. Possibly a defense, or an attempt to get the attention away from Mike. They were both asking other people to comment on whether they thought i was suspicious or not, however they never once mentioned each other, or each other's reasoning for accusing me. Bit weird really?

[stevenryals]

he just hasnt posted enough to tell otherwise unless you want to think like Steven has said, mikeblue has hung him out to dry? but in a game of 17 peeps, isnt this a strange tactic for mafia to use? and wouldnt that also implicate wes?

interesting take..  I dont see mikeblue saying he has a 'not with me' on someone who is not in his team so most likely would be guilty so as to seem like he is actually the cop..   he'd also know who was good and able to post those investigation results on the following odd day.. 

Do you really think mikeblue was going to let us lynch BBM, to find out he is innocent?  if he's going to sacrifice an innocent why not try to sacrifice one that will be harder to get rid of in the game than BBM??

I think mike tried to save his skin by hanging BBM out to dry and it didnt work.. 

In the case that both you and mikeblue are cop and doc, you'll both be targets until one of you is dead.

Good to know.. good think Mikeblue is dead..  try to go back and READ the thread..  we are now on day 2 and mike blue was lynched during the last day.. 

The fact that you can't see the obvious reasons why Mike chose BBM to target makes me either disbelieve your role claim even more... or think that you are really bad at being good..

the fact that you can't open your mind to the two sides of EVERYTHING makes me think you're willing to see what's obvious. 

fact is, mike blue either hung out a mafia buddie or an innocent...

lets try to figure out why?

Hung out a mafia buddie:

1) if it works, mike is considered a townie to the end, and can return "he is with me" results throughout the game while offing townies during the night phase

Very profitable for the mafia

Hung out BBM as a townie:

1) we lose one townie that mike has no idea is he's a regular townie or a power role, and then we know he's lying and we kill him on Day 2..  What good does that do the mafia really except bring about another night phase?

don't you think mike saw these two scenerios unfold in his head before making his last ditch effort to claim as cop??

or think that you are really bad at being good..

WHERE WERE YOU WHILE WE WERE LYNCHING MIKEBLUE?
---------------

[laserblue]

Sorry did not realise it had started again then I've been busy it seems like there is loads to read up on now ... I still have a few ideas form the previous day but I'd better read what's been said today first or I may end up looking stupid...

I understand what's being said & I agree that if we don't all contribute it not only ruins the game but helps the mafia so I will read up & post soon

  

[wesmancity]

He's not gonna like it and accuse me of picking on him again when i was quite clearly gunning for mike most of the day, but fuck it. VOTE WESMANCITY.

LMFAO!! you know me so well 

[wesmancity]

Might be something in that you know.

At the start, when i made Mikeblue cry, Wes did start amusingly accusing me of "sending coded messages to Yorkshire Blue", straight after. Possibly a defense, or an attempt to get the attention away from Mike. They were both asking other people to comment on whether they thought i was suspicious or not, however they never once mentioned each other, or each other's reasoning for accusing me. Bit weird really?

the sheep that followed, you could of came out and said this before, why wait till someone else said it??

[hippo]

the sheep that followed, you could of came out and said this before, why wait till someone else said it??

If agreeing with a point someone raises makes me a sheep, then so be it. What do we call someone who completely sidesteps a point though?

Anyway, my vote's staying on BBM. He's obviously evil, or what Mike did would have been a pointless and ridiculous. If he wanted to take a townie out as his last act, he wouldn't have chosen an easy to lynch person, he'd have chosen me or steve. BBM comes back guilty, Mike looks like he actually is a cop. That's the tactic. It's so basic, i'm a bit confused that so many people are saying there's nothing in it. What else would Mike possibly have been doing? What would be the point if BBM's not evil? Was he just gonna hope everyone forgot what he'd told us overnight?

[stevenryals]

exactly hippo..  i can't understand Footballnewb's refusal to see any light in the Mikeblu-BBM thing..  as well.. MIASG, Hammerbro & Axeman seem to see it as little more than coincidence that mike chose him..??
the mind boggles..

I also find Villian's play to be totally bizarre..  he's said some weird shit so far in this game..  he's definately one to watch...

He's not gonna like it and accuse me of picking on him again when i was quite clearly gunning for mike most of the day, but fuck it.

axe, you need to tell us something?   lol... 

[laserblue]

I think bbm needs to make an appearance & sharpish..... If he's not mafia with mike then he needs to tell us cause his non posting only makes me think he has resigned himself to his fate & given up?

Yorkshire you may think your gonna drift through without anyone noticing but I'm gonna keep reminding peeps your hiding 

SteveR if you are who you say you are... are you guessing someone tried to kill you or do you know something for sure?


 

[Quig]

Woah I completely fucked up there. Completly forgot mikeblue was dead. Yeah ignore my last post there.

[Steve Van Halen]

If agreeing with a point someone raises makes me a sheep, then so be it. What do we call someone who completely sidesteps a point though?

Anyway, my vote's staying on BBM. He's obviously evil, or what Mike did would have been a pointless and ridiculous. If he wanted to take a townie out as his last act, he wouldn't have chosen an easy to lynch person, he'd have chosen me or steve. BBM comes back guilty, Mike looks like he actually is a cop. That's the tactic. It's so basic, i'm a bit confused that so many people are saying there's nothing in it. What else would Mike possibly have been doing? What would be the point if BBM's not evil? Was he just gonna hope everyone forgot what he'd told us overnight?

Steve and Hippo have both raised valid points towards the BBM lynch stronger than me voting for him just for not participating

BBM, going to defend yourself?

Itl be interesting to see the death toll tonight if Steveryals is the doctor, which at the moment its hard to believe otherwise. If we lose two in the night that would mean the presence of a serial killer and that that person and the mafia did try to kill him in the night.

[stevenryals]

SteveR if you are who you say you are... are you guessing someone tried to kill you or do you know something for sure?

the only thing I know is I protected myself last night and there were no kills.  I even asked TCH if he could tell me if someone tried to kill me and he said he couldn't tell me, which I assumed, but if you don't ask, you'll never know... 
It's only an assumption that the mafia tried to kill me, and possibly even a serial killer as well.. but to me it's obvious as i get killed on night one every game!!  there are 3 scenerios, 1) both tried for me 2) one tried me and the other tried someone else who ended up being a bulletproof townie  3) there is no serial killer

Steve and Hippo have both raised valid points towards the BBM lynch stronger than me voting for him just for not participating

but why is it that some people refuse to see these points?  (footballnewb)

[Steve Van Halen]

that mikeblue would not incriminate anyone unless he knew they were mafia

you are always targeted because you post a lot and ask a lot of questions

[Dickens Cider]

don't you think mike saw these two scenerios unfold in his head before making his last ditch effort to claim as cop??

Actually... no... I don't think he saw any scenarios in his head... I don't give his play that much credit...
I do however see what you are saying... and you make a very good point
But still... I just can't give Mike that much credit... not from what i've seen from him...

There's just not enough evidence there yet, for me, to calculate a vote on...

I'd be more inclined to vote for BBM for lack of contribution...
But then there are quite a few people that aren't contributing...

hippo you best go back and read some of the mafia games there was only the last one where i didnt post alot
when you dont get much chance to post and then theres 5 pages to read its not easy

I will however VOTE Yorkshire Blue as he has only posted 2 times and has not posted since page 6 !!
As he said... he usually posts a lot... and has not offered any reason why he's not in this game...

[wesmancity]

I posted to say that Hippo hes just followed what Happy Axeman has said then Hippo replys.........

If agreeing with a point someone raises makes me a sheep, then so be it. What do we call someone who completely sidesteps a point though?

Anyway, my vote's staying on BBM. He's obviously evil, or what Mike did would have been a pointless and ridiculous. If he wanted to take a townie out as his last act, he wouldn't have chosen an easy to lynch person, he'd have chosen me or steve. BBM comes back guilty, Mike looks like he actually is a cop. That's the tactic. It's so basic, i'm a bit confused that so many people are saying there's nothing in it. What else would Mike possibly have been doing? What would be the point if BBM's not evil? Was he just gonna hope everyone forgot what he'd told us overnight?

But you already had a go at currieman for doing the same thing, funny that

If you really want to know, i voted Currieman because he said that about the game, and offered nothing new himself. He pretty much recycled something Axeman had already said, and he's a better player than that. And he only offered an FOS, during what's supposed to be the random voting phase.. for an experienced player, i found that weak and non-committal.

[wesmancity]

This is a responce from mikeblue to BBM on his first post!! looks obvious to me that hes telling his team mate to not post crap!

Another nail in BBM coffin.

I think not.

Anyway all these stupid short posts are a waste of time and Happy is going to do his nut when he comes on and sees them all! lol.

If you have nothing to post of any relevance or opinion don't bother because it just clogs up the thread!

[wesmancity]

Reading threw the first ten pages or so when Mikeblue was having heated debates over stevenrynals and hippo it became clear that mikeblue tried to put pressure on Trick Pony (mophead), Miasg, Steve, and Hippo. Now I'm tryining to but my self in mikebblue shoes here, he’s obviously trying to put pressure on people voting for these people, but also maybe including on of his mafia members so later in the game he can back track. Now out of these players IMO i think:

Trick Pony (Mophead) is sus, but really had not much communication from him yet.

Steven, with his role claim should be good

Hippo, for some reason you are coming across as a serial killer, i don’t think you are mafia the way you kept on with mikeblue putting pressure on him but I feel you have a important role.

Miasg, you I feel with mophead are the most sus and I am leading to you as a member of the mafia team.

also...

footballnewb and Bluestars never really commented that much about mikeblue when they posted so to me they either thought he was being treated unfairly or not wanting to put more coal on the fire to kill there team mate, I would like answers you two please?

[Sir Villain]

Hippo, for some reason you are coming across as a serial killer, i don’t think you are mafia the way you kept on with mikeblue putting pressure on him but I feel you have a important role.

Speculating about a serial killer at this point is abit pointless since we have no evidence. No kill last night, points to there being no serial killer, but ominously that is the sign of a cult, meaning that I don't trust Stevenryals at all since he is probably the biggest target for someone to want to recruit, and if not already, then definitely now, since he claiming confirmed innocent. If we get evidence of cult, then steven is my main suspect, but for now no point speculating....

Plus a doctors protection only protects against one kill, so unless Steven is just bulletproof, he was only targetted once.

I also find Villian's play to be totally bizarre..  he's said some weird shit so far in this game..  he's definately one to watch

In fairness, if you think im acting completely out of character, I have been evil in virtually everygame so that proves nothing..

I think I'm going to Vote:BBM. Mikeblue doing a 'Hippo' and strongly targetting a fellow mafia member early seems the more likely plan, although BBM probably was an easy target.

[Steve Van Halen]

all evidence so far points to BBM doesnt it? I think we are seeing that Mikeblue gambled but its actually cost his team two members.

vote bbm

This could be over quickly!

[bluestarsneyes]

wes...read through those posts again....I didn't get involved with what did look a bit like a bandwagon at first....I let it all play out a bit...as I don't know anyone's role but my own and wasn't sure what was going on exactly....I did however get involved asking Mikeblue questions and he did respond to a few of them...then disappeared again....I think it was becoming a bit obvious after the BBM as his choice to out

That being said...here we are and not a word from BBM to defend himself...says alot