Mafia 17 - Harry Potter Game *Mafia Win*

[Mikeblue]

Either way you look at it you are getting a mafia member..........but at least give me a chance would ya, this shit happens every game to me lol. I think some people need to watch some X-Files because nobody ever wants to believe.

Dunno why every game I am always the first to be branded evil??? I play the same way every game, but its like there is a constant target on my head. Should you not have wised up slightly to my style by now?

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

Well 8 votes now cast

MikeBlue has 5 Votes
BBM       has 2 Votes
Wes       has 1 Vote

The people who have voted are FBN, Hippo, Laser, MikeBlue, Sir Villian, StevenR, SVH and Wes

The deadline is Midnight Monday UK time

[Steve Van Halen]

Mike that sounds incredibly desperate but you raise a good point! I think you are lying about your role and are trying desperately to stay alive which is understandable at the moment

Miasg, why have you believed him and voted for BBM? I can understand the vote as he has contributed nothing but this to me sounds either that you have genuinely believed him or are in cahoots with mike.

[Mikeblue]

Mike that sounds incredibly desperate but you raise a good point! I think you are lying about your role and are trying desperately to stay alive which is understandable at the moment

Miasg, why have you believed him and voted for BBM? I can understand the vote as he has contributed nothing but this to me sounds either that you have genuinely believed him or are in cahoots with mike.

Obviously anybody that has voted for me is going to question it as they thought I was evil. Nothing more that I can do so you may as well choose amongst yourselves. I don't see it as desperate though, I'm just letting you know either way that you make your decision. As long as the town wins I'm not arsed. I'm a team player and never expect to last till the end anyways. I'm not desperate to survive, just desperate to tell you what I know before I got evicted from "the big mafia house". I still think you are stupid if you don't let me prove you wrong though, cause I said if I'm lying its an easy lynch for 2moro.

[Steve Van Halen]

see im tempted to vote for BBM because hes contributed nothing and the first day is always a random vote. while others havent posted much either at least with yorkshire or football newb you get much more than DUN DUN DUUUUUUN. Yes the game is supposed to be fun but then we are supposed to be hunting down mafia members.

Now usually there is 3-4 mafia members which means voting for BBM is a 1 in 4 chance of him being mafia, im prepared to take that chance. Im not thinking of voting for him because of what you said because it sounds like tosh to me

vote bbm not because of mikeblue's claim but because he has offered nothing and I have to vote for someone.

[Sir Villain]

WTF ?? no we can't he hasn't claimed anything proven so you can't rule it out  FOS Sir Villian

Ahem, yes that should clearly say shouldn't instead of should. By the tone of my post, I hope thats obvious.

Unvote:Mike, for now although a cop claim or investigator claim is standard fair for someone near lynch. I think we need a full claim, Mike.

[Mikeblue]

Ahem, yes that should clearly say shouldn't instead of should. By the tone of my post, I hope thats obvious.

Unvote:Mike, for now although a cop claim or investigator claim is standard fair for someone near lynch. I think we need a full claim, Mike.

I can claim if you want, but I don't see this as any benefit really at this point. All it does it take one name out of the equation for mafia to use later on when there are less names left. Even when I claim you are still going to have to make a decision whether you believe it or not because I know nobody is going to refute it.......

[Steve Van Halen]

so you wont say if you are the cop or not? Makes sense, if the real cop came out now (if you're lying) to refute your claim that would make him a mafia target.

saying that you have already made yourself a target to the mafia if you are telling the truth. I cant see you lasting very long even if you avoid a lynch tonight.

[Mikeblue]

so you wont say if you are the cop or not? Makes sense, if the real cop came out now (if you're lying) to refute your claim that would make him a mafia target.

saying that you have already made yourself a target to the mafia if you are telling the truth. I cant see you lasting very long even if you avoid a lynch tonight.

Thats why I was calling on the doc to give me a hand......Its a wasted lynch whatever way you look at it really. I certainly know what I would be doing. Lynch BBM..... if he is innocent come back and get me 2moro. If he is guilty (which he is) then we have saved a power role.

To be honest you are either going to believe me or not. If you don't why would you want me to claim so that the real cop (if I was lying) would refute it. Either way you are going to make your own mind up......

[bluestarsneyes]

Okay...thanks SVH for clearing up the Spartacus thing it was totally lost on me...sorry...I was thinking it was some kind of hidden message...lol!

Look...I am reading what Mikeblue said about his role...and what if he gives the name...I see no reason to give the name of his role because it really isn't necessary. We've seen the mafia VERY good at picking out possible names....so we don't need to help them out that's for sure!

I think if you take a look at Mike's claim....and look at BBM's posting....also taking into account he's new...I was suspicious of him right away....but then gave him a bit of credit as being a new player...however... the only real evidence against Mikeblue is that he got angry when he perceived a bandwagon against him and he didn't post on a weekend and holiday.

I mean...if you take that out of the equation as being out of the game circumstances...and you look at these two's posting and offering of information...we have Mikeblue...at least questioning folks...going at a few people...and BBM that's offered well mainly nothing.

SVH first day is a guess anyway for townies...and I don't know mikeblue's role...but I'm inclined to believe him as I can't really think of a way that at this point if he was lying...it benefits him as he'd KNOW he'd be gone the next day.

VOTE BBM based on your postings that have offered little, and offered no questioning really of anyone....couple that with mike's claim...and a hope that this is a lucky guess turned good and we don't kill off a townie on day one for a change!

[laserblue]

Seems strange  it sounded like Mike was fed up with the game & was looking for a way out a few posts ago, now he seems desperate to stay in it?

If mike's telling the truth then it makes my reasons for voting for Wes look a bit stupid so unvote Wes for now & vote BBN.

If Mike is Lying he gets it next I think.

[Mikeblue]

I'm fed up of always having to do this on day 1.  Nobodys ever believes me and can never look past me to anyone else at the start of the game. Nobody ever seems to learn how I play. 

[Mikeblue]

I'm not overly desperate to stay. You will get a mafia either way you go eventually, but its in the towns interests to save me and I know this for a fact. I wasn't going to just let myself be lynched when I had information to help the town was I. Like I said I am a team player, If the town wins, I win!

I might not be on for a couple of days. Just letting people know so they can't say I'm hiding again. If BBM does get lynched...........d oc please don't forget about me. Cheers. 

[stevenryals]

a cop who can investigate every other night....  who could be a parnoid cop.. 

investigates the new player, knowing that he's new adn would probably f**** it up.. 

bollox..  you're full of crap..   you would have investigated me, hippo, hammer, svh or axeman... 


I don't believe your claim one bit..  if you did chose to investigate BBM pre-game..  that was just silly..

and as far as I can remember, TCH games haven't had pre-game investigations in the past.. so ..

it's too obvious this...and loads of people jumping on the BBM wagon... and they should be looked at intently..   I just simply think you are full of crap...


UNVOTE MIKEBLUE


VOTE MIKEBLUE

[i2i Killer 89]

I'm inclined to believe Mike because of the way it works for us townies.

1. He is mafia and has just killed off a townie. Chances are he doesn't know what role BBM has anyway so it could just be normal rubbish townie.

2. He is town and we've just got rid of a mafia player.

Only thing that makes me think otherwise is that Mike could be mafia and has picked out BBM because he is an easy lynch. He has hardly posted to start with and probs wouldn't be very good at countering Mike as it's his first game and surely Mike would've investigated someone like Steven or Hippo?

I'm very undecided on this and think we should atleast give BBM a chance to speak up because we lynch him because Mike could be taking us for a ride and he may have some role that means he can't be lynched or killed at night or something.

We've only got until Monday though so BBM needs to get on sharpish otherwise I may give Mike the benefit of the doubt and just vote BBM and then if he is town then we can lynch Mike the day after

[bluestarsneyes]

UNVOTE BBM

Mikeblue...I'd like to see what you have to say to about the reasons for picking a new player....I have to admit that is kind of weird....to be able to investigate before the game really is weird...but to pick BBM is a valid point as a very odd pick!

I'd have a hard time not picking one of the players that I KNOW had experience...got to say I didn't even think of that being as bizzarre before Steven mentioned it.

I am not sure what to think....you and BBM neither have given me much confidence...but D@M!T...you can't also make a blanket claim that you are always targeted every game....you got two people asking you questions...Hippo and Steven...and I had just as many...ask me questions...and to be honest they are people that have questioned me in previous games....it's just the nature of the game.

I worry that thou dost protest too much...not sure...but BBM ought to be able to speak for himself

[Blue Blooded Maniac]

wat do u want me say?

what were u doing at 12:37pm GMT on the 8th of febuary 2009?

or would you prefer to just waffle, ok il waffle, I WENT SWIMMING TODAY! that was after i took me mam shoppin at morrisons, and i bought her and me gf breakfast, and me gf ordered to extra hash browns but they didnt come so i had to go back to the till and complain, and then they eventually come out with them. after we had been swimming we went to makky ds and i had a burger from the winter warmer menu, it had chicken, cheese, bacon and mayonase on it, was very nice. i dont usually like fast food but its good it u want it fast , i then took my gf home so she could get dressed into her work attire and then took her to work, i then come home and curled one out, and i need to go for another one, must be that bludy winter warmer, and im now goin to put me tea in the microbing cos im gettin a bit pekish.

happy?

[wesmancity]

thanks BBM 

anyway unvote BBM and Vote Mikeblue

the reason is simply, you know that you and BBm are mafia and you know that BBm talks crap and now no one is going to believe him. So when you came out saying that you got to investigate someone you chose BBM (BOLLOCKS) because if we believe you and BBM gets lynched and we find out he is mafia, its then an easy ride to the final day for you.

Also when I was telling people about BBM's lack of posting you never came out and defended me or backed what i was saying.....now if you where town you would of tried! surely?

[wesmancity]

wat do u want me say?

what were u doing at 12:37pm GMT on the 8th of febuary 2009?

or would you prefer to just waffle, ok il waffle, I WENT SWIMMING TODAY! that was after i took me mam shoppin at morrisons, and i bought her and me gf breakfast, and me gf ordered to extra hash browns but they didnt come so i had to go back to the till and complain, and then they eventually come out with them. after we had been swimming we went to makky ds and i had a burger from the winter warmer menu, it had chicken, cheese, bacon and mayonase on it, was very nice. i dont usually like fast food but its good it u want it fast , i then took my gf home so she could get dressed into her work attire and then took her to work, i then come home and curled one out, and i need to go for another one, must be that bludy winter warmer, and im now goin to put me tea in the microbing cos im gettin a bit pekish.

happy?

BBM your Mafia buddy (Mikeblue) is trying to get you kicked off this game what do you think?

[stevenryals]

Also when I was telling people about BBM's lack of posting you never came out and defended me or backed what i was saying.....now if you where town you would of tried! surely?

Great point.. it would have been an excellent time for him to try to push people in the right direction without having to claim if he were a cop.. which he's not..  good point wes..