Mafia 17 - Harry Potter Game *Mafia Win*

[bluestarsneyes]

I just want to ask a question, not sure if TCH can tell us or not...but I do get confused easily and thought I'd better ask rather than assume.

Are we playing this game based on the latest released movies or the books? I'm sad and haven't kept up with the books but have seen all the movies...is that something you can tell us?

[Happy Axeman]

not much going on today.....   

yeah, I was hoping there would be more to comment on.
yet people have visited today and not posted. why?
this includes... SVH, Amadjin, Wes, Villain and currieman.

With a deadline coming up, at this moment in time I will be voting either Mikeblue or wes as they seem to be my main suspects.

I was only messing around with TP, but he's gone? why?

Laser is right, Footynewb has offered Nothing... but he has just posted as i was writing this, and i guess it does kinda add to wes's suspicion.

BBM has dissapeared too, maybe he thinks the games too hard?

MikeBlue is deffo trying to stay low as he is usually an ardent poster... I'm beginning to think he is the best bet of a lynch. but with a few days to go, plenty of things could still develop... hopefully.  

[Tommy Caton's Hairstylist]

I just want to ask a question, not sure if TCH can tell us or not...but I do get confused easily and thought I'd better ask rather than assume.

Are we playing this game based on the latest released movies or the books? I'm sad and haven't kept up with the books but have seen all the movies...is that something you can tell us?

The characters chosen should be known to all who have only seen the movies.

[hippo]

the only thing that makes me NOT want to lynch mikeblue is...    we are going to do the same thing as always..  lynch a big poster..  then kill another big poster or 2 at night.. then lynch another big poster and on and on..  and it's going to end up being another one of those games where the last month of it is 1 or 2 posts per day....  so..  I'd like to get a mafia member, but I'd also like to not f*** up and get rid of a good poster who's just slipped up..

Thinking like this also ruins the game though. By the time we'd voted off all the people who aren't really helping/aren't major posters in the daytime, all the major posters'll have been picked off in the night anyway - so it's self defeating. We've got to lynch suspicious people, or the game's pointless.

[MIASG]

I disagree hippo - your basically saying don't worry about the non posters but towards the end of the game that's what your left with and no real clue to what they are .. what makes  them less targets then regular posters ?  yes I agree lynch suspicious people but putting pressure on non posters usually brings them out .. surely people who are not posting can be classed as "highly suspicious" isn't that what we are saying about mikeblue now since he's not around  .. but hang on he's also classed as a big poster   sounds like the way to proceed in the game is do nothing ..

[hippo]

Absolutely everyone in this game has posted something though, we don't have "non-posters", we have people posting less than others. Mike is one of those, and by far the most suspicious of those because he is usually, and was in this game until he became largely suspected, a major poster. Of all the people sitting back doing nothing, we have more information about him to prove that it's tactical.

Maybe he's got a reason, but i know he was on this site for much of friday (the day after all the arguing), and his profile seems to say he was on during saturday too. So really, i'm unable to do anything other than suspect that he's hiding, unless i hear something very substantial in terms of justification from him.

[wesmancity]

I really have nothing to comment on, I have read threw peeps posts and the players that stood out are mikeblue and Hippo, but happy axeman as the norm find me most sus which is fine. But i am trying to read and re-read everybodys post to find some kind of slip up but at the moment nothing, I think the better players in Happy Axeman, Steve, Hippo, Bluestars etc are also finding it difficult thats why the game seems to be stale. All I can comment on is I am wondering if the mafia are keeping low because me and Mike are likely to get booted and as theres a deadline so there is no need for them to upset the apple cart. 

[wesmancity]

Also can someone try and get in touch with BBM as hes not been on line since the 13th which doesn't help this game

[Quig]

Unvote: Sir villian, Vote BBM
Fancy getting rid of him purely that he's barely posted (I know i've not posted loads either) and that when he did post, he was full of shit.


I'm going to Disneyland tomorrow. Should be on most of today but after that wont be on until sat night/sunday.

[Mikeblue]

For the record. I have not been hiding at all. As I have said before I rarely post at the weekends. I had a quick look on Saturday and didn't manage to read through all the posts and have just done so now.

What I am wondering is why Hippo is saying I got all angry at him? This was not the case at all. If you read back you will see that I was questioning him and he started to try and turn my questions back on me. Trying to put a mafia spin on this Hippo??? And still Steve and Hippo seem to have some kind of alliance and continue to agree with stuff each says........Can't remeber who said it but it was mentioned that I was saying Steve hadn't been posting and they said he had so that was sus of me? Go back and read....he hadn't been posting till he jumped in on me. Before that he had maybe 2 posts of complete crap.

I said this earlier on that this always seems to happen to me. I'm damned if I post and damned if I don't. Why am I always a suspect on day 1? Because I post? Is it the style I post in? For whatever reason seems we are wasting time again when the mafia sit back and laugh again at us all. I'm interested in the people that seem to be taking a back seat and showing up with the odd post such as Axeman, Hammerbro, Laserblue, Blueestars. I am town and started asking questions to try and find something out. Then because I do this people assume I'm mafia? How so? Should if I'm town sit back and not contribute and not get into conflicts? Open your eyes people.

[hippo]

For the record. I have not been hiding at all. As I have said before I rarely post at the weekends. I had a quick look on Saturday and didn't manage to read through all the posts and have just done so now.

You get 4 day weekends then? Nice.

If you read back you will see that I was questioning him and he started to try and turn my questions back on me. Trying to put a mafia spin on this Hippo???

I'm not putting a spin on anything. If anyone goes back and reads, they'll see you reacting to me mentioning you. I'll even put all the exchange in one big post if it's necessary, just to show there's no twisting going on by me.

Can't remeber who said it but it was mentioned that I was saying Steve hadn't been posting and they said he had so that was sus of me? Go back and read....he hadn't been posting till he jumped in on me. Before that he had maybe 2 posts of complete crap.

I dunno why you're persisting with that. There were 36 posts in the game overall before he mentioned you - 8 of them were by him. That's 22.22% of all posts by my calculations. They may have been complete crap - the majority of posts in the early stages of a game are going to be - but they exist. Why are you lying?

I said this earlier on that this always seems to happen to me. I'm damned if I post and damned if I don't. Why am I always a suspect on day 1? Because I post? Is it the style I post in? For whatever reason seems we are wasting time again when the mafia sit back and laugh again at us all.

That's desperate. Nice use of mafia cliche at the end there though.

I wanted you to convince me i was wrong, because you do post alot and it'd be good for the game if you were a townie, but you're just not convincing, you're persistently making things up, and i simply don't believe you are good this time.

[stevenryals]

Should if I'm town sit back and not contribute and not get into conflicts? 

Should if I'm town?   

Another example of editing your thought process I believe..

[Mikeblue]

What have I made up exactly?

That you thought I was getting angry when I wasn't? Is that the way it read? I'm thinking you seem to know a bit too much for my liking.....how would this be the case if you didn't know I was town?

What cliche did I use? I think the mafia are laughing? It seems to be the same people not posting as much as they don't need to.

Why are you protecting Steve so much? If you were town you should be sus of everyone but you insist on being his love buddy and protecting him? The pair of you have done this several times now and this is extremely sus!

You seem to have a lot of questions but not many answers...........

[Mikeblue]

Should if I'm town?  

Another example of editing your thought process I believe..

WTF?!?!? You are pricelss. Sorry I missed the word "I" from my sentace then.....Should I if I'm town......

You two are so in cahoots a joke!!!

[Steve Van Halen]

Axeman I wont post if I have nothing to add that hasnt already been said as it reaks of posting for the sake of it.

BBM hasnt posted for a while and when he does its normally a daft post to say the least. Does TCH have replacements lined up before the mob makes a decision?

[Mikeblue]

I agree with hippo here..  My vote is on Mikeblue and has been..  I think that he's been by far the most dodgy up to this point..  adn the fact that he's went AWOL since he was put under pressure...  speaks volumes.   

I mean, Mike is the guy who's on here every day posting replies to my replies...  you have to know he has internet access at work..  since he's on during the day ALL day long lol..  just like me..  but now he's gone adn hasn't come back..  frustration maybe? or trying to drop off the radar..

the only thing that makes me NOT want to lynch mikeblue is...    we are going to do the same thing as always..  lynch a big poster..  then kill another big poster or 2 at night.. then lynch another big poster and on and on..  and it's going to end up being another one of those games where the last month of it is 1 or 2 posts per day....  so..  I'd like to get a mafia member, but I'd also like to not f*** up and get rid of a good poster who's just slipped up..

Ive mentioned the psychological implications of his "I" post before..  that alone really isn't enough to lynch someone..  I feel like his subsequent responses to pressure, and now his disappearance says more than that...   

This is blatant shit Steve. Why would you try and put this in peoples heads? Show me a topic I posted in since Friday and that I have deliberatkly avoided the mafia game?!?!?!

[stevenryals]

where in that post did I say you had posted in other topics? 
I said it's obvious that you have internet access at work as you're always online here posting back and forth...  for you to not be on for on a weekday to me looks like hiding..  considering you're usually on ALL weekdays..

[Mikeblue]

where in that post did I say you had posted in other topics? 
I said it's obvious that you have internet access at work as you're always online here posting back and forth...  for you to not be on for on a weekday to me looks like hiding..  considering you're usually on ALL weekdays..

You made it sound that I was posting in other topics yet not in mafia. Accusing me of hiding etc etc.

This simply is not the case. I had not been on period!

You posted it in such a manner that others would believe you that I had gone into hiding. Why would you do this?

 I post whenever I can and thats a lot more than most. I believe that by me posting so much and quickly that it is more likely (obviously) for me to make a typo or people jump to assumptions. I ask people questions....they don't like it and then suddenly the attention comes on me. I am town and trying to help the town. By not posting this is only helping the mafia. The game I finally turn out to be Mafia is the game my style might alter and I won't post because the non posters seem to get away with murder because it doesn't give anybody any ammunition....this is the reason I am suss of the "show up and post once" posters.

Apologies on a postcard please. I am always in work on a Saturday too but I am simply too busy to post. I was off work Friday, Sunday and Monday.

[stevenryals]

see, this is why I still find you sus..


my post very clearly said:

I mean, Mike is the guy who's on here every day posting replies to my replies...  you have to know he has internet access at work..  since he's on during the day ALL day long lol..  just like me..  but now he's gone adn hasn't come back..  frustration maybe? or trying to drop off the radar..

now you claim that:

You made it sound that I was posting in other topics yet not in mafia. Accusing me of hiding etc etc.
You posted it in such a manner that others would believe you that I had gone into hiding. Why would you do this?

when I clearly said you hadn't come back, in no uncertain terms.. 

[Mikeblue]

see, this is why I still find you sus..


my post very clearly said:

now you claim that:

when I clearly said you hadn't come back, in no uncertain terms.. 

It was the way you said it Steve and I think its obvious for others to see. You were trying to lead peoples thoughts that I had delibaretly not posted and gone into hiding.

And in your defence you think I am sus? Give me a break. You are sus thats why I have voted you and have no intention of changing it. You and Hippo have been so sus the way you have continued to agree with one another and single me out.