Author Topic: Mafia 15 - 24 - GAME OVER - TOWN WIN  (Read 380010 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline MASTERZULU

  • Busy Bee
  • *
  • Posts: 2304
  • Karma: 59
  • Adventuring across the Sword Coast
    • Suicide squad
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #840 on: October 19, 2008, 12:13:53 PM »
hmm seems like there may be more to miasg's role than meets the eye. Now we have jacks daughter involved, so how do we know she hasn't been kindnapped and jack is working against the town to save her, enough townies have been killed by jack a far to warrant suspicion.

Reading wiki she has been kidnaped more times than I've had hot dinners

TP claiming doctor has threw a lot of thing up in the air in my mind, looks like things may not be as black and White as I thought.

   

yorkshire blue

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #841 on: October 19, 2008, 12:31:59 PM »
I didnt get the chance to finish what I wanted to say.. but it doesnt matter anymore, and MIASG im starting to think your actually evil as you keep killing townies you have probably killed more townies than mafia have...

yes I am willing to roleclaim wesmancity as I said days ago if needed so who are you wes ? I am the town doctor wes so who are you ?

To prove I am the doctor I can post who I saved each night which may help us out but only if the majority say its a good idea.  I think it is necessary to roleclaim at this stage as we would waiste to much time looking at me instead of looking at;
 
Hippo
Wesmancity - waiting on his roleclaim - probably mafia
Yorkshire Blue
Masterzulu

VOTE YorkShireBLue 
worst role claim i have seen where is a name
i can also role claim if i need to but these games are getting pointless if were all just roleclaiming

ive got a good idea at the start of the next one lets all role claim then the town will win

vote trick pony until there is a name

i2i Killer 89

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #842 on: October 19, 2008, 03:57:02 PM »
Vote count
2 – Trick Pony (Wesmancity, Yorkshire)
2 – Yorkshire (MiasG, Trick Pony)

It will take 4 votes to get a lynch

Offline MASTERZULU

  • Busy Bee
  • *
  • Posts: 2304
  • Karma: 59
  • Adventuring across the Sword Coast
    • Suicide squad
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #843 on: October 19, 2008, 10:21:44 PM »
wes and YB we've heard very little from you two today, you've both posted and contributed nothing today so far. We are now in the position of you two looking like the main suspects, from the info I have hippo looks inocent, TP has roleclaimed doctor which no one has contested, Miasgs role claim looks pretty safe even though I still think there is more to his role than we know.

vote YB

At the very least one of you two are mafia so you get my vote.


Trick Pony

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #844 on: October 19, 2008, 10:23:16 PM »
worst role claim i have seen where is a name
i can also role claim if i need to but these games are getting pointless if were all just roleclaiming

ive got a good idea at the start of the next one lets all role claim then the town will win

vote trick pony until there is a name

i love how you show up just as each lynch happens YB your definatley mafia, and there is nothing more to look into
worst role claim i have seen where is a name
i can also role claim if i need to but these games are getting pointless if were all just roleclaiming

ive got a good idea at the start of the next one lets all role claim then the town will win

vote trick pony until there is a name

That is the worst come back to a role claim ever... nothing more to be said of your YB your definatley mafia, I love how you conveniently start playing just before a lynch occurs and attack the main town roles just after a claim. If you were townie which you are not you wouldnt vote of one of the biggest roles in the game. your a fool and you will get lynched. Lets see if anyone else claims doctor you fool, I am Michelle Dessler the doctor.

There is nothing more to be said about you..  VOTE: yorkshire blue  >:D again... maybe if I make all of the important parts bold you wont miss it in your skimming. The way you play wouldnt surprise me if your the god father mafioso

Trick Pony

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #845 on: October 19, 2008, 10:30:19 PM »
wes and YB we've heard very little from you two today, you've both posted and contributed nothing today so far. We are now in the position of you two looking like the main suspects, from the info I have hippo looks inocent, TP has roleclaimed doctor which no one has contested, Miasgs role claim looks pretty safe even though I still think there is more to his role than we know.

vote YB

At the very least one of you two are mafia so you get my vote.



yes im beginning to agree with you MZ about MIASG's role he may be mafia and if he is hes done a fantastic job of fooling everyone, though maybe he is just a sh@t town vigilantie :cowboy: who has only done one kill to help the town  >:(

My main suspects are WES and YB, YB conveniently turns up when the lynches occur and wes is always around so i say YB for now.

Offline MASTERZULU

  • Busy Bee
  • *
  • Posts: 2304
  • Karma: 59
  • Adventuring across the Sword Coast
    • Suicide squad
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #846 on: October 19, 2008, 11:42:22 PM »
so just hippo left to vote I think.

Can't wait to see the out come of this game.

Offline MIASG

  • Monster Member
  • *
  • Posts: 3026
  • Karma: 15
  • I don't want the world I just want your half -TMBG
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #847 on: October 20, 2008, 12:31:01 AM »
Hippo - I pretty much walked in and overheared TP talking to Footynewb (not playing this game) about who he should save .. they couldn't have known I was around but still I didn't 100% believe it as he could have be "turned" or he was setting me up - I just didn't suspect him of being able to kill therefore a threat.  Since I keep being saved I'm still assuming he's doctor.  And no one else is claiming that.

look I made 2 mistakes and killed axeman who was mafia .. night 1 is as potluck as day 1 .. TCH seemed very dodgy to me - maybe he was just rusty ... 

axeman claimed he was a character that in the show tortures jack - he had to go .. turnes out he was effectivley harmless but non of us were to know that.

afro just didn't participate quite enought to me  but I also didn't believe his claims .. simple I got that wrong too.  It was out of him and YB for me and laser's comments making me save him still weighed on my mind ..

I'm pretty sure mafia can't turn people ..so if I was cult I would have lost my powers like happy did .. wake up people.  If I was evil I would have taken out TP or mikeblue and not afroboy. 

so if people are to be believed ..
MiasG  - Jack - Vig
Hippo - Pres - ? (came back innocent - still outside poss mafia godfather but doubtful)
Trick Pony - :clown: - dressler - doctor
Wesmancity - kim - town
that leaves ..

Yorkshire Blue
Masterzulu

one is the remaining mafia - the other is a mason with Afro   

Hippo we await your vote ...

Offline wesmancity

  • M.C.F.C
  • Veteran
  • *
  • Posts: 1014
  • Karma: 7
  • MCFC
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #848 on: October 20, 2008, 08:45:28 AM »
wes and YB we've heard very little from you two today, you've both posted and contributed nothing today so far. We are now in the position of you two looking like the main suspects
At the very least one of you two are mafia so you get my vote.

This is what amazes me about this game, I have told you im the daughter of Jack which means im as safe as houses but still you say im possibly evil, what tree did you come from?
Unvote Trick Pony Vote Zulu
Axemans plastic moderator. I wear the suit, with fuck all power!

hippo

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #849 on: October 20, 2008, 11:42:20 AM »
Firstly, sorry for my absence over the last couple of days, it was a mate's birthday weekend. Just about recovered now.

so if people are to be believed ..
MiasG  - Jack - Vig
Hippo - Pres - ? (came back innocent - still outside poss mafia godfather but doubtful)
Trick Pony - :clown: - dressler - doctor
Wesmancity - kim - town
that leaves ..

Yorkshire Blue
Masterzulu

one is the remaining mafia - the other is a mason with Afro  

Hippo we await your vote ...

I've said all along that i think Yorkshire's evil. He's done so many dodgy things, and it's just all been capped off by Trick Pony claiming doctor and then him coming straight on and voting for him. How does that make sense, if he's a townie? It doesn't, so i'm gonna go with him.

But, i'm not sure it matters. Unless wes is lying, one of yorkshire or zulu must be the remaining mafia member, or members if there's two left. So it seems like it's just a matter of whether we the town collectively get to finish off the game with this lynch, or MIASG does it tonight. Which really doesn't matter does it? Hopefully the first one though, i want this to be the glory vote  :)

vote Yorkshire Blue

i2i Killer 89

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #850 on: October 20, 2008, 06:21:54 PM »
Vote count
4 – YorkshireBlue (MiasG, Trick Pony, Masterzulu, Hippo)
1 – Trick Pony (Yorkshire)
1 – Masterzulu (Wesmancity)

Everyone at CTU is getting extremely paranoid, they've received intel that not all the terrorists are dead yet and so start to turn on each other. A very heated argument erupts and in the commotion a shot is fired which kills YorkshireBlue.

Dead players
StevenRyals: George Mason – Townie – Lynched on day 1
Hammerbro: Ramon Salazar – Cult leader – Shot in the leg and head on night 1
TCH: Bill Buchanan – Townie – Shot through head on night 1
Laserblue: Chase Edmunds – Townie bodyguard – Shot  in the back on night 1
Sir Hammer: Nina Myers - Mafia henchman - Lynched on day 2
Happy Axeman: Cheng Zhi – Neutral survivor – Shot through head on night 2
Bluestars: Philip Bauer – Mafia henchman – Lynched on day 3
Mikeblue: Tony Almeida – Townie Cop – Shot through back on night 3
Afroboy: Morris O’ Brian – Townie mason Shot through head on night 3
YorkshireBlue: Chloe O’Brian – Townie mason – Lynched on day 4

It is now Night 4. The deadline for night choices and communication is Wednesday at 7pm but if I receive all the night actions before then day 5 will start early. Anybody with night powers can now use them

i2i Killer 89

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #851 on: October 21, 2008, 06:06:00 PM »
[size=8]20:00[/size]

A few more hours pass in this very long day and CTU know that they still haven't found all of the terrorists! Everyone in the main control room jumps when they hear a loud scream coming from a back corridor. A woman has found the body of another person that has been shot in the head.

Dead players
StevenRyals: George Mason – Townie – Lynched on day 1
Hammerbro: Ramon Salazar – Cult leader – Shot in the leg and head on night 1
TCH: Bill Buchanan – Townie – Shot through head on night 1
Laserblue: Chase Edmunds – Townie bodyguard – Shot  in the back on night 1
Sir Hammer: Nina Myers - Mafia henchman - Lynched on day 2
Happy Axeman: Cheng Zhi – Neutral survivor – Shot through head on night 2
Bluestars: Philip Bauer – Mafia henchman – Lynched on day 3
Mikeblue: Tony Almeida – Townie Cop – Shot through back on night 3
Afroboy: Morris O’ Brian – Townie mason Shot through head on night 3
YorkshireBlue: Chloe O’Brian – Townie mason – Lynched on day 4
Masterzulu: Tom Baker – Townie backup cop – Shot through head on night 4

Players still alive (4)
MiasG 
Hippo
Trick Pony
Wesmancity

It is now Day 5. It will take 3 votes to get a lynch

Offline wesmancity

  • M.C.F.C
  • Veteran
  • *
  • Posts: 1014
  • Karma: 7
  • MCFC
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #852 on: October 21, 2008, 07:04:23 PM »
Right you tricky bastards Vote Trick Pony

Hippo i dont trust you either but TP is the one that sticks out for me tried to give us the doc route without naming a caracter which was well sus and Misag you really have not been helping the town have you with your voting. One thing thats really pissing me off is nobody has questioned Misag's claim about him being Jack including me he would or should deff. be in this game so that's why i dont think you could be evil but you voting pattern is shite!, Jack did get kidknapped in one of the series, so maybe your role Misag is to keep that quiet and not let the town find out. Who knows!!!, another sugestion is that in most all 24 series Jack is all ways against or doing things behined CPU's back to get to the bad guys.

Fuck knows now im bloody ill with it all and again the town is dieing quick TP you stink you need to go.
Axemans plastic moderator. I wear the suit, with fuck all power!

hippo

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #853 on: October 21, 2008, 07:50:03 PM »
Haha, quality. Two nights where the mafia have failed to kill? Leaving their remaining member completely with nowhere to go, other than to try and miraculously lynch the vig or doctor..

Right you tricky bastards Vote Trick Pony

Hippo i dont trust you either but TP is the one that sticks out for me tried to give us the doc route without naming a caracter which was well sus and Misag you really have not been helping the town have you with your voting. One thing thats really pissing me off is nobody has questioned Misag's claim about him being Jack including me he would or should deff. be in this game so that's why i dont think you could be evil but you voting pattern is shite!, Jack did get kidknapped in one of the series, so maybe your role Misag is to keep that quiet and not let the town find out. Who knows!!!, another sugestion is that in most all 24 series Jack is all ways against or doing things behined CPU's back to get to the bad guys.

Fuck knows now im bloody ill with it all and again the town is dieing quick TP you stink you need to go.

Right on cue.

Nothing in that post really makes sense. TP gave a name, and the fact that the mafia failed to kill twice surely makes it pretty blatant that there's a doctor? Unless they've chosen not to kill to mess with people, but why would they do that now? Wouldn't make alot of sense.

MIASG has practically announced who he's going to kill each night and they've died, so he obviously has killing powers. This a 24 themed game, so it's going to have Jack Bauer in it, and he's pretty certain to be good. Alright he's got some things wrong, but i've agreed with all of them to be honest. They all looked dodgy. Unless he's a serial killer, in a pretty major twist, he must be a townie as well.

Surely i would have been the easiest target if you'd actually planned this out? Because although i'm the second main character in the show, i hadn't actually claimed a power role or anything, that has seemingly indisputable evidence to back it up. I could protect someone once in the game, using my secret services. Used it on MIASG, night two. Didn't bother the first time because i assumed we'd have a more permanent protection person who'd obviously choose him to protect after his claim. Then on night one, Laserblue the bodyguard died, and i figured this was probably that protection role, so chose to use it.

Game over now i reckon.

vote wesmancity

The only way you're possibly not the last member of the mafia in my mind, is if Trick Pony has deliberately not killed anyone last night in order to make it look like there actually is a doctor or something. And if he's done that, well, he deserves to win really.

Offline wesmancity

  • M.C.F.C
  • Veteran
  • *
  • Posts: 1014
  • Karma: 7
  • MCFC
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #854 on: October 21, 2008, 10:19:42 PM »
Haha, quality. Two nights where the mafia have failed to kill? Leaving their remaining member completely with nowhere to go, other than to try and miraculously lynch the vig or doctor..

Right on cue.

Nothing in that post really makes sense. TP gave a name, and the fact that the mafia failed to kill twice surely makes it pretty blatant that there's a doctor? Unless they've chosen not to kill to mess with people, but why would they do that now? Wouldn't make alot of sense.

MIASG has practically announced who he's going to kill each night and they've died, so he obviously has killing powers. This a 24 themed game, so it's going to have Jack Bauer in it, and he's pretty certain to be good. Alright he's got some things wrong, but i've agreed with all of them to be honest. They all looked dodgy. Unless he's a serial killer, in a pretty major twist, he must be a townie as well.

Surely i would have been the easiest target if you'd actually planned this out? Because although i'm the second main character in the show, i hadn't actually claimed a power role or anything, that has seemingly indisputable evidence to back it up. I could protect someone once in the game, using my secret services. Used it on MIASG, night two. Didn't bother the first time because i assumed we'd have a more permanent protection person who'd obviously choose him to protect after his claim. Then on night one, Laserblue the bodyguard died, and i figured this was probably that protection role, so chose to use it.

Game over now i reckon.

vote wesmancity

The only way you're possibly not the last member of the mafia in my mind, is if Trick Pony has deliberately not killed anyone last night in order to make it look like there actually is a doctor or something. And if he's done that, well, he deserves to win really.



I am KIM, JACK's Daughter you spoon!! i am deff town you are a complete prat if yuo think that im mafia!
Axemans plastic moderator. I wear the suit, with fuck all power!

Offline wesmancity

  • M.C.F.C
  • Veteran
  • *
  • Posts: 1014
  • Karma: 7
  • MCFC
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #855 on: October 21, 2008, 10:23:46 PM »

The only way you're possibly not the last member of the mafia in my mind, is if Trick Pony has deliberately not killed anyone last night in order to make it look like there actually is a doctor or something. And if he's done that, well, he deserves to win really.

impossible,
as currie said It is now Night 4. The deadline for night choices and communication is Wednesday at 7pm but if I receive all the night actions before then day 5 will start early. Anybody with night powers can now use them

which mean all night a night powers was used
Axemans plastic moderator. I wear the suit, with fuck all power!

Offline MIASG

  • Monster Member
  • *
  • Posts: 3026
  • Karma: 15
  • I don't want the world I just want your half -TMBG
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #856 on: October 21, 2008, 11:52:07 PM »
if I'm still alive then someone can save me .. pres - normal townie by admission .. kim - normal by admission .. that leaves TP claim as doctor .. therefore guilty is between hippo and wes ..

impossible, as currie said It is now Night 4. The deadline for night choices and communication is Wednesday at 7pm but if I receive all the night actions before then day 5 will start early. Anybody with night powers can now use them 
which mean all night a night powers was used
exactly .. and wes wants to kill the doctor .. VOTE WESMANCITY ..

TP if wes is good then it must be hippo so if you save me then I'll kill him in the night therefore game over .. unless wes or hippo want to claim some extra powers ..

I killed Zulu last night .. so my track record isn't great  :'(  the reasons are that the other 3 claims are very plausable .. zulu claimed nothing .. simple to me .. to be honest who the fuck is Tom Baker ? Dr Who ?  if he had said that I would have had to look it up as I've never heard of him in 24 let alone a backup cop ..

this game should either now be a townie win (despite me taking 3 out) - not counting axeman as town .. or a draw at worst case ..


hippo

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #857 on: October 22, 2008, 09:55:55 AM »
impossible,
as currie said It is now Night 4. The deadline for night choices and communication is Wednesday at 7pm but if I receive all the night actions before then day 5 will start early. Anybody with night powers can now use them

which mean all night a night powers was used

Yes, you're right. Sending a PM to currie saying "I'm not going to kill anyone" today is entirely impossible. It's unlikely yes, which is why you have my vote and 99% of my conviction that you're the last mafia. But hardly impossible.

MIASG, all this talk of killing me at night worries me slightly. Not too much, like i said, i'm 99% sure it's Wes. It just makes sense. However, IF it isn't, killing me'll lose the game, guaranteed. I'll modkill myself to prove this, but with these numbers, i'm not sure that'd help.

I'm David Palmer and i've already stated what power i had. It was a one-off protection, which i used on you once the bodyguard died - so night two. There was no mafia kill that night. Not saying Trick Pony is lying for now as we probably just both protected you, and if Wes is mafia like we're all pretty much sure of, then it's all irrelevant. But IF it goes that way, then you're literally never going to hear the end of it from him.

And i'd like to point there's been a vig, 2 masons, a cop, a back up cop, a bodyguard (so, a proper protection role) and a one off protection role - so the equivalent to the bodyguard of the 'back up cop'. If it's not Wes, are you really gonna just go along with being convinced that there's 2 permanent protection types? I claimed Palmer when practically everyone in the game was still alive. Like you know, Palmer's a massive character in 24. How could i possibly risk claiming that if i wasn't? Trick Pony waited until there were about 5 people left, with half of our names known, in order to claim his. Okay Michelle's probably in the game; he's probably telling the truth, with wes reaking of scum. But if he's not. It's not me.

There's hopefully no point to this post, because Wes has to be mafia. If there is, i'm pretty fearful that the mafia are going to win. But to be fair, i'd admire the gameplay if it was a hoax. Not as much as i want the town to win obviously (think it'll be my third victory in the hall of fame  :D), but still. It'd have been pretty genius.

Offline wesmancity

  • M.C.F.C
  • Veteran
  • *
  • Posts: 1014
  • Karma: 7
  • MCFC
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #858 on: October 22, 2008, 10:32:24 AM »
I will give you my house if i turn out to be mafia i promise you, what else could i offer! im town and you are going to lose the game if we dont get this right, if you are David Palmer and Misage is Jack then the Mafia is 100% Trick Pony. Fucking hell its so simple you havent got long to change your vote because TP will vote me and we will then loose.

Hippo and Misag rewmember if i get lynched then you have lost it for the town.
Axemans plastic moderator. I wear the suit, with fuck all power!

hippo

  • Guest
Re: Mafia 15 - 24
« Reply #859 on: October 22, 2008, 10:43:58 AM »
unvote wes

because as it stands, TP could just come on and win the game, if wes is telling the truth. Argh.. this game's so confusing sometimes.

Not saying i believe you 100%, but i want a bit of time to think. Maybe i've overthought myself with all that TP stuff, but i'm doubting myself now.

If i was thinking about who'd be in the game at the start, i'd say:

Bauer - guaranteed
Palmer - guaranteed
Dessler - probably
Kim - probably

The fake's one of the two probably's. I just don't know which.

Either of you got anything to add that'll make me believe you?