Mafia 14 - The Good, The Bad and The Ugly Mafia: Game over-TOWN WIN!

[froganomis]

well if it means taking one for the team lets go for it,but everyone needs to be certain its the right thing to do first,dont you think?

[stevenryals]

This is one of those situations where its so obvious, but is it too obvious?

his erratic play in the first day, then his survival throughout the night...

[*Afroboy*]

Lets get this day started

VOTE MIKEBLUE

would have been a logical kill for the mafia hoping to take out 2 townies..  however, they wouldnt do that if they knew he wasnt innocent would they..

Wouldn't be too sure. I think the amadjin claim maybe a big cover up. I think amadjin might be mafia trying to fool everyone by telling everyone he's attached to mikeblue who he would obviously know was town so he has a good allaby for the rest of the game until mikeblue dies. A crazy but logical tactic which could save him from a lot of suspision. FOS AMADJIN

Now looking back mophead hasn't had a go at bluestars really like he usually would, also he didn't vote for her which I think he usually would of and has tried to be as far away from the main subject yesterday as possible. Maybe a sign he is on the mafia team and doesn't want to be associated, also if this is the case I feel stevenryals must be mafia too because he said mophead isn't acting in his evil way which could possibly be covering for him. Because he has been right everytime people just take his word for it and that's what he wants. FOS MOPHEAD and STEVENRYALS

Mophead and steve will both be the same side, either town or mafia, I don't know which but at this moment I'm thinking mafia.

[hippo]

Pretty good start to the game, even though we've lost TCH. The evil sides both weakened significantly. I'm not sure that's the end of the cult entirely, but essentially it should be - when i was cult in mafia 2 or 3, there was a leader and a deputy; when the leader was alive, there was a recruitment made every night, and with just the deputy it was every two. So that could well be the same. Also, if a cult member tried to recruit a mafia member, they would die. So that could have happened also. Which would mean that there might only be the mafia that can kill. Or, as mikeblue was such an obvious kill attempt for the evil ones, a doctor might have saved him, meaning there's a serial killer or something as well. There's a lot of possibilities really.

Theorising, i reckon there'll be a 4 person mafia and a 2 person cult, or a 4 person mafia, a 1 person cult, and a serial killer. We might even have a vigilante. There hasn't been one of those in a game for ages. Looking at the two people that died at night, both had attracted some suspicion, so one of them could feasibly be the work of a vigilante doing his job poorly? I dunno.

Anyway, i'm gonna read back and try and work out who the other mafia members, or cult member could be, based on day one stuff. I'll post back when i find something.

[stevenryals]

also if this is the case I feel stevenryals must be mafia too because he said mophead isn't acting in his evil way which could possibly be covering for him. Because he has been right everytime people just take his word for it and that's what he wants. FOS MOPHEAD and STEVENRYALS

Mophead and steve will both be the same side, either town or mafia, I don't know which but at this moment I'm thinking mafia.

then moppy must be a good guy, just like I already said i think he is..  you however forget that I am the one that put the wheels on the bluestars lynch mate..  which is a very handy thing to forget isnt it...  would be for a mafia player right afro?

I think it's interesting that afro is throwing suspicion on two people who have role claimed basically, and you have not been in volved in much of anything so far..

so.. out of the first day, you think, obviously, that me, amadjin & mophead are the most suspicious..

I suggest you read back a bit... maybe refresh your memory.. because you're looking quite sus at the mo

[i2i Killer 89]

Well I had MiasG and Bluestars in my top 3 on my suspicion list so I was right about 2 of them. Not sure if I'm right about Yorkshire and have to admit it's surprising that Mikeblue survived the night after what Amadjin claimed. Maybe he or Amadjin were saved by a doctor which is possible but I reckon the mafia took out MiasG and the other person, whether he's a vigilante or serial killer, took out TCH.

Gonna have to have a read back through some of day 1, see if I can pick anything out so I won't vote for anyone just yet.

[laserblue]

can we replace footy please as he obviously is not interested in playing.

mophead can you please come on & post something of sense as you only escaped last time cause your mom was more suspect...

[Steve Van Halen]

apologies for my absence in the latter half of day one but there was simply nothing going on whatsoever for me to respond to.

I dont think Steveryals is guilty as he was the first to point out Bluestars change of tactics. Yes he changed his vote but surely he wouldnt have been so daft to have planted the seeds of doubt and nurtered them against his own team mate?

[froganomis]

i did it when i was mafia steve...so no its not that daft,mafia won that game...so it is feasible

i still think mophead is mafia so until im shown better evidence of someone else looking bad,my vote shall be a repeat of yesterday

vote mophead

[yorkshire blue]

she turns out innocent and you lot are gunna make it much harder to know whos who in the next day

trying to defend bluestars here are we amadjin looks sus to me
steven i dont think they would kill mikeblue yet as he said he was a normal townie
vote amadjin

[froganomis]

trying to defend bluestars here are we amadjin looks sus to me
steven i dont think they would kill mikeblue yet as he said he was a normal townie
vote amadjin

no i was more sure mophead was bad and so i voted him. i just stated the blindingly obvious that happens each day if we get things wrong.trying to come out and intimidate me??

[hippo]

steven i dont think they would kill mikeblue yet as he said he was a normal townie

That's an interesting thing to say. I had a quick scan back to amadjin's claim (assume it'd be after that) but couldn't find him saying that, but either way, what you're saying doesn't make sense. Why would they decided against killing, effectively, two townies, based on thinking one of them was just 'normal'? Unless they hadn't been reading the game properly.

I'd understand if you'd voted amadjin because you didnt believe his claim, but you seem to not even have taken that in to account? All in all, it's a pretty bizarre post.

[stevenryals]

steven i dont think they would kill mikeblue yet as he said he was a normal townie

I can't remember mike saying that..   and mafia would be foolish if they passed up the chance to take out 2 town..
this is a sus comment yorkshire..

[i2i Killer 89]

That's a very odd post from Yorkshire. If what Amadjin said is true then Mike is anything but a normal townie and why would the mafia not want to take Mike out following Amadjin's claim. Surely they'd then find out whether or not Amadjin was telling the truth. Very suspicious from you Yorkshire, just adding to my thoughts on your actions yesterday. FOS Yorkshire. May turn into a vote later because you are definitely the most suspicious to me right now but I still haven't read back on the last day's actions so will hold fire on voting for now

[laserblue]

seems to be the same peeps making posts again  ... all those who are not posting & are town are only helping the mafia as we can't tell whose hiding & who just can't be bothered playing ... so come on axeman, hammerbro ... svh has been on & I hope where going to hear more from him but wes needs to post as well.... I've given up on footy I think he should be replaced...

[hippo]

Thought it might be worthwhile to have a proper look at what the two evil people did, or had done to them, on day one, to see if it tells us anything. So here we go.

Voting Patterns from Day One

Bluestars:
fos wesmancity
vote wesmancity
unvote wesmancity
unvote wesmancity (again)

MIASG:
fos trick pony
fos bluestars
fos mikeblue
fos currieman
fos amadjin
vote currieman
unvote currieman
vote mikeblue
unvote mikeblue
fos stevenryals
vote footynewb
unvote footynewb
vote yorkshireblue
unvote yorkshire blue
vote bluestarsneyes

People who voted and FOS'ed them

Bluestars:

votes: stevenryals, wesmancity, amadjin, Trick Pony, Hippo, laserblue, stevenryals, yorkshireblue, afroboy, currieman, TCH, MIASG
unvotes: stevenryals, amadjin
FOS: mikeblue, mikeblue, laserblue, wesmancity, stevenryals

final voters: wesmancity, trick pony, hippo, laserblue, stevenryals, yorkshire blue, afroboy, currieman, TCH, MIASG

people who at no pointed voted for her: Happy Axeman, mophead, mikeblue, SVH, Hammerbro, FootballNewb.
 
MIASG:

votes:
unvotes:
FOS: mikeblue, Trick Pony
final voters:

A Few Observations

MIASG's stuff in this post doesn't really help at all. He voted and FOS'ed far too many people to be able to tell anything i think. The las bit shows how good a town we are as well doesn't it? The only two people who suspected the cult leader were someone who always suspects him, and another who FOS'ed him for being ginger.

The Bluestars stuff tells us things though. The only person she did anything against in the entire game was wesmancity. Misdirection?

Some of the people not voting her at all could probably put it down to inactivity. That's suspicious, but not as much as mikeblue and mophead, who were both relatively active. Mikeblue even FOS'ed her twice, but no vote. Why?

Feel free to add your own analysis, i've run out of time to do it myself right now.

[Happy Axeman]

soz again for my inactivity, My Girlfriend is now getting BB later this month, so I will be able to get on for an hour most nights soon. lol
I had time before day ended to add my input, but alas i had internet troubles. bummer...

Anyway, I'm glad we had a favourable result by getting 2 seperate sides of evil.

not really had a chance to read properly what transpired in first day, but i will catch up...

With 2 aussie's dying a prime suspect has to be the remaining Active Aussie in Trickpony, my guess is he did TCH. Footynewb has been even less active than me, maybe he was on enough to do a night action?

apart from that i have nothing else to say at this moment until i catch up.

[MIASG]

My Girlfriend is now getting BB later this month, so I will be able to get on for an hour most nights soon.

BB = Back Brace?      Sorry my dead spirit couldn't help itself

[stevenryals]

broadband

[mophead]

Ok sorry i havent been on in a while.....I kinda forgot about it startinng back on thursday....right now im really not sure ill be back later to comment