Axe Mafia 1: EVIL vs GOOD

[billyman]

1: Did you enjoy it?        YES

2: Did you like the good vs evil concept, ie two teams?         YES

3: Was it too hectic?             NO

4: What was the best additions/changes i made to the game?          DAY ACTIONS

5: And what were the worst?         DAY ACTIONS (only cos i was killed by one)

6: what would you of done differently?              MORE DRAMA

7: what needs tweaking slightly and how?            ?

8: Would you play in experiment 2?                            MOST DEFO

9: anything else you would like to say or comment on?           I HATE DOTLEO (serious, the game is still early and only trial and error will improve it for the future)

[stevenryals]

You can't hate Dotleo just for putting a bullet between your eyes, unless you want Der Hammer to HATE you because you killed him, and he was innocent....

grrr...

I love lamp!!
I love chair!!



-steven

[Happy Axeman]

cheers guys, I'll get working on another one, if we got a few more players playing, then I would add more team players and roles that can be recruited and some different specialized roles.

I am trying to incorporate basic rpg elements into it, and was planning on having different skill classes, like a +3 skill would negate a +2 block etc... but it proved a bit too early and i needed a lot more time to develop that idea.

In the end if it wasnt for Dotleo grabbing a life line by selecting the right choice when he was voted to go, then it would of been Raygin and Yorkshire(who had a protect which stopped Sweeney killing him!) left, Raygin and EVIL would of won as it was 1 EVIL and 1 NEUTRAL..

i could of ended it because there was 2 good(neutral were hunting evil) and 1 evil, but thought it would be interesting to see how it went. 

[ChurchofHalo]

1: Did you enjoy it?        YES

2: Did you like the good vs evil concept, ie two teams?         YES

3: Was it too hectic?             NO

4: What was the best additions/changes i made to the game?          Day Actions

5: And what were the worst?         None really.

6: what would you of done differently?              More ninjas and lasers.

7: what needs tweaking slightly and how?           

8: Would you play in experiment 2?                            yep.

9: anything else you would like to say or comment on?           Woo Hoo won again.

[stevenryals]

hmm... Ninja's and Lasers....

What about Ninja's with Lasers attached to thier heads?



-steven

[Happy Axeman]

funnily enough a ninja was a role i was working on. 
along with a priest, necromancer, flowerpower dude, evil doctor(harold shipman), and ... well there was more, but i'll stop there. 

would people prefer i gave peoples identitys away after they have been killed instead of waiting till the next night? 

[sweeney]

i think it works well in theory, but it made it that little bit harder for the first couple of days as you were still speculating as to who was who.

[stevenryals]

I say 1st night, give the identity .. after that maybe wait a night...
it seems like that idea could only help the mafia..